I think that the most recent review is taking place right now. This is an on-going learning process. The cabinet secretary, Kate Forbes, and I, in my role as public finance minister, have both been strongly committed to seeking to provide as much information as possible to the finance committee and to Parliament to assist in scrutiny and understanding.
However, this is an iterative process. I recognise that having these twice-yearly budget revision events might be insufficient to progress the type of change that we want to see in presentation as quickly as we would like. It might be useful for dialogue to take place with the finance committee, perhaps along with one of the budget review sessions, to consider that more formally.
I appreciate that it is for the committee to determine its own work programme, but if the committee has any more general reflections on having something beyond a specific presentation of a specific spring or autumn budget revision, I would be keen to hear them. Transparency and engagement are at the heart of not just our framework for tax but how we want to go about the business of ensuring that Parliament can come to decisions based upon the most accurate information possible, which is as easy to grasp as possible. A priority for me is trying to ensure that members of the public have the fullest understanding without having to wade through dozens and dozens of pages of dense, technical language and a lot of numbers.
It is an open invitation—I am keen to have that engagement, because it is very important. There are a lot of things that we have drawn out in this session. I recognise that members take a keen interest in specific budget lines and it can be difficult to give the authoritative answers that I would like to be able to give, given the breadth of possible questions that may arise.
I recognise the points that the convener, Mr Gibson, has made with regard to different aspects of the budget—discretionary and non-discretionary—and the points that Mr Johnson has raised with regard to presentation relative to the last budget revision, compared with the budget as passed by Parliament.
We can draw a number of things from this meeting. I would be keen to have an on-going dialogue about how we can improve the presentation.
This may sound as if I am shifting that position, which I do not mean it to, but the Government has to decide how much information to provide. We do not want to overload you, because we appreciate that you have many other things to consider. We could give you 50, 100 or 150 pages, but that would become more challenging and would probably raise suspicion about what is in there that might be missed.
I am keen to have that dialogue to understand what would be best for the committee and what would assist you as custodians of the Parliament’s responsibility for financial scrutiny, and I am keen to work collaboratively to deliver a better product for you, Parliament and the public to utilise.