Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Ferry Services (Reliability)

Topical Question Time

Tuesday 7 March 2023 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 12 contributions · 5 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

12 contributions
Edward Mountain Con Highlands and Islands
link

To ask the Scottish Government, in light of the recent comments by the chief executive of CalMac, what action it is taking to prevent island residents being impacted by any reliability issues affecting their ferry services over the next two years. (S6T-01236)

Jenny Gilruth SNP The Minister for Transport · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I have been clear to Parliament, including to the Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee only last week, that investment in new ferries to replace the existing fleet has been one of my key priorities as Minister for Transport. We are delivering six new major vessels in the life of this session of Parliament, as well as the purchase of the MV Loch Frisa, which has been in service on the Oban to Craignure route since last summer.

We are investing almost £700 million to support the improvement in the fleet, which will also allow investment in the small vessel replacement programme. Although I recognise that those vessels will take time to deliver, we are also investing resilience funding of at least £4 million per year to maintain the existing fleet and we continue the search for additional tonnage that can be chartered in the short term.

Edward Mountain Con Highlands and Islands
link

I thank the minister for that answer. I am flabbergasted by that. I asked about the next two years. There is obviously a timescale problem—the same timescale problem that results from the 10-year ferries plan being left on the shelf and ignored.

As far as resilience and the plans for the £4 million are concerned, the last time I am aware of that being spent, it was on improving fire extinguishers in a ferry, which should have been a normal contract thing.

Where are we at the moment? We have three candidates to be First Minister—one who oversaw the ferries, one who signed off the payments to a turnaround director who failed to deliver, and one who appears to be content to build a doomsday thermometer for independence. Will the Minister for Transport give me an assurance that, if she is still in position after the leadership battle, a spare ferry will be either rented or purchased to cover the next two years?

Jenny Gilruth SNP The Minister for Transport · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I am more than happy to give Mr Mountain a confirmation in relation to that request. It is important to reiterate that, when I appeared in front of Mr Mountain’s committee only last week, I gave a very clear guarantee in relation to the search for on-going additional capacity on the network. I put on the record again that Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd made offers to purchase two second-hand major vessels—the MV Arrow and the MV Straitsman—but they have unfortunately been unsuccessful.

We will absolutely continue to look for the spare vessel that Mr Mountain alluded to. I recognise that there is a challenge in relation to the current fleet and the availability of services at the current time.

Mr Mountain will recognise that, if there are on-going conversations in relation to securing an additional vessel, some of them will be commercially sensitive and I will not be able, as minister, to share some of that detail in the chamber. However, he has an assurance from me that we are absolutely seeking the additional tonnage that we need in relation to the CalMac fleet.

Edward Mountain Con Highlands and Islands
link

The Government has been looking for a ferry to rent for the past 16 years and it has not come across one. That might give it an indication that there are no ferries out there and that it should have been building them—and building them in a much quicker process than we have had.

We have the MV Pentalina, which we hope will come on to station and operate, but that is just one extra ferry. My question is very pointed. Will hull 802 be on station and operational by early 2024, as the Government has announced?

Jenny Gilruth SNP The Minister for Transport · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

In responding to Mr Mountain in relation to the hiring or renting of vessels, it is important to say that we have chartered the MV Arrow, which is currently covering the Uig outage, so is not true to say that the Government has not considered such opportunities.

Since May 2021, the Government has bought an additional vessel, the MV Loch Frisa, which is operating on the Oban to Craignure route. We have chartered the MV Arrow, as I mentioned, and we have made significant progress on the construction of vessels 801 and 802. We have commissioned two new vessels for Islay and confirmed the award of contracts for two new vessels for the Western Isles and Little Minch routes, supported by an additional £115 million of investment. We have progressed investment in key ports and harbours, including the completion of major works at Tarbert and Harris.

Ministerial responsibility for Ferguson Marine sits within a separate portfolio, but we remain absolutely committed to the completion of those vessels and to supporting our island communities that rely on that type of vessel.

Jenni Minto SNP Argyll and Bute
link

As the minister knows, every cancelled sailing impacts our island communities. As the minister said, second-hand tonnage has a key role to play here. CMAL recently told the Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee that it had looked at a substantial number of vessels. Can the minister therefore set out some of the particular challenges of specification and suitability when it comes to trying to acquire additional tonnage for our ferry routes?

Jenny Gilruth SNP The Minister for Transport · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

As the member knows, CMAL has undertaken extensive searches and continues to engage with ship brokers to look at vessels available worldwide that would be potential additions to the CalMac fleet. CMAL needs to consider a wide range of factors when it is looking at vessels, including the fit for the specific characteristics of our harbours, the condition of the vessel and, importantly, whether the vessel will be compatible with the requirements of the Maritime and Coastguard Agency.

As I mentioned, we were able to secure the MV Loch Frisa. As I confirmed to the Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee last week and mentioned in my response to Mr Mountain, CMAL also made bids to purchase the MV Arrow and the MV Straitsman. Regrettably, we were unable to secure those vessels, but that demonstrates our willingness to secure suitable new tonnage when it becomes available.

Katy Clark Lab West Scotland
link

Does the minister accept that the scale of the disruption that is being faced by islanders is a direct result of the Scottish Government’s failure to adequately invest in new ferries since taking office? Bar the overdue ferries that are being built at Ferguson Marine, there still does not seem to be a strategy. In total, CMAL has examined 650 second-hand ships, most of which were found to be unsuitable. Will the Scottish Government commit to developing a long-term strategy to build capacity so that we can build and commission vessels here in Scotland?

Jenny Gilruth SNP The Minister for Transport · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

There is a strategy. The first part of the draft islands connectivity plan, which was published in December last year, sets out quite clearly the future investment trajectory for this Government. If Ms Clark wants to look at that plan, I would commend it to her.

Secondly, if we look at overall investment by the Government from 2013-14 to 2022-23, we see that there has been a steady increase in our ferry fleet, so it is simply not true to characterise this as a lack of investment on the part of the Scottish Government. I would refute that point from Ms Clark. The most important thing now for our island communities is that we deliver the ferries that are on order and improve the services that they are receiving. That is what I am absolutely focused on as transport minister.

Graham Simpson Con Central Scotland
link

Ferguson Marine faced being struck off because it had not filed its accounts on time. Is there, as has been reported, an £11 million shortfall between what the firm has been asking for and what the Government has agreed to give it? Will that impact on the building of ferries?

Jenny Gilruth SNP The Minister for Transport · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

As notified to the Public Audit Committee in December last year, the chief executive of Ferguson Marine expects the costs to complete both vessels to be £277 million. Scottish Government officials are working closely with Ferguson’s to review assumptions behind any revised costs and a schedule on how spend aligns to the vessels’ delivery.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Time for Reflection Time for reflection · 2
  2. Topical Question Time Questions · 1
  3. Loganair (Flight Suspensions) Questions · 12
  4. Ferry Services (Reliability) Questions · 12
  5. Deposit Return Scheme (Payments) Questions · 21
  6. Women’s and Girls’ Safety (Public Transport) Debate · 64
  7. Motion without Notice Business motions · 1
  8. Decision Time Decision time · 9
  9. Imprisonment and Release (Effect on Families) Members’ business · 17

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.