I want to come back to William Wragg on that question. The point about what is party political, what is constitutional and what the cross-overs are is really interesting. You mentioned the issue of respect and trust. How do you embed that in the process?
To what extent will your committee look at legislative consent motions when devolved concerns are expressed at a parliamentary rather than an intergovernmental level? To what extent is that on your radar? To what extent do MPs on your committee challenge the Government when looking at an issue in the round? I am thinking about the Retained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill. On one level, that is very controversial, but our stakeholder input shows that people are unhappy on a different kind of scale. How would you handle something like that?
When something is clearly a devolved issue, to what extent will you actively consult committees in the devolved legislatures in order not just to understand the politics of the situation, but to gain interparliamentary awareness, so that committee members can identify what the devolved tensions are in a formal way?
That is helpful. I will leave that with you and your committee to think about. When you compare our report with the Senedd committee’s report, you can see that there are a lot of cross-overs. There is quite a range of people on our committee.
I will follow up on that question with Huw Irranca-Davies. I was very interested in your committee’s report, because of the cross-overs with what our committee thought. I want to hear your comments on solutions for interparliamentary and intergovernmental relations. I will start with interparliamentary relations, because you talked about your committee engaging directly with counterpart committees. What are the key lessons for developing solutions in respect of devolution across the UK?
That is very interesting and helpful for our report. What about the intergovernmental solutions that you have suggested in your report? In particular, you mention two potential solutions—a formal dispute resolution procedure and an independent secretariat—to strengthen intergovernmental work. Were those proposals agreed on a cross-party basis in your committee?
That is very useful. I wanted that clarified because, given the tensions, working out whether people agree with one another is significant when making recommendations.
Do you want to say a bit more about transparency? How would we deliver that or make it work in the different legislatures, as well as across the UK? I am conscious that the retained EU law issue makes that particularly challenging for us all, but what would be your key recommendation as a committee?
That is useful, and it provides a nice link to my final question, which is to Baroness Drake. Will you talk about how you are able to provide scrutiny? What is your committee’s role in ensuring that the concerns that devolved legislatures express are taken on board when the House of Lords provides scrutiny? Have you any thoughts on how the system could be made more effective and transparent?
What kind of feedback have you had from the different Governments on those issues? To what extent are Governments prepared to provide for intergovernmental discussions, negotiations and transparency?
The sense on our committee is that these major challenges, particularly following Brexit, have not really been experienced before. On the issue of safeguards, in relation to the Sewel convention and the “not normally” principle, to what extent is there an awareness of the significance of that convention regularly being overridden? What is your committee’s view on that?
We would be interested in seeing that. I am very interested in the point that you made about the Retained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill. Were witnesses from different parts of the UK involved in the work that your committee did on that bill?
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.