Thank you, convener, and good morning.
The draft order under consideration is a minor amendment to the Renewables Obligation (Scotland) Order 2009. Before I move on to the amendment, it might be helpful to provide some background information on the scheme.
The renewables obligation scheme was introduced in 2002 to support renewable electricity generation projects. Equivalent schemes are in place in England and Wales and Northern Ireland, and are managed under separate legislation. All three United Kingdom schemes are administered by the Office of Gas and Electricity Markets. Throughout its existence, the Scottish obligations scheme has remained largely aligned with the England and Wales scheme.
The scheme closed to new generation capacity across the UK in 2017, but it will remain operational until 2037. Some 565 existing generators are accredited under it. That accounts for 8.8GW of renewables capacity in Scotland.
The obligation requires electricity suppliers to source a percentage of the electricity that they supply from renewable sources. Accredited renewable generators are awarded certificates according to their output per megawatt hour. They are then sold to suppliers. That incentivises renewable generation by providing projects with revenue in addition to the wholesale energy price.
Electricity suppliers fulfil their obligation by providing the required number of certificates to Ofgem in proportion to the amount of electricity that they have sold. Alternatively, they can make a fixed payment into a buy-out fund at a higher price than procuring certificates typically requires. That fund is then recycled back to suppliers that provided certificates to Ofgem. However, when some suppliers fail to meet their obligations, a shortfall in the fund is created, which reduces the value of any recycled payments. A mutualisation mechanism exists within the scheme to prevent excessive shortfalls. If the shortfall exceeds a certain threshold, existing suppliers are required to pay the unmet obligations of suppliers that did not meet their obligations. In each of the past five years, mutualisation has been triggered due to an increasing number of suppliers defaulting on their obligations.
The amendment order under consideration will alter how the mutualisation threshold is determined under article 48 of the Renewables Obligation (Scotland) Order 2009. The mutualisation threshold has failed to keep pace with the growth in the scheme and proportionality. It is now considerably smaller than it was when it was first introduced.
The aim of the amendment is to better protect customers by restoring the balance of risk between generators and suppliers. As the cost of the scheme to suppliers is passed on to consumers in their energy bills, any increased costs associated with mutualisation are also passed on.
The amendment will alter the mutualisation threshold for Scotland from a fixed value of £1.54 million to 0.1 per cent of the forecast costs of the scheme across the UK. It will also restore alignment with the scheme in England and Wales regarding mutualisation as the UK Government made a parallel amendment in 2021 to move to a variable level of scheme costs. Critically, the amendment will ensure that suppliers and, in turn, their customers are not more likely to face the costs of mutualisation in Scotland than they are in England and Wales.
Finally, a further provision is included in the proposed Scottish statutory instrument, allowing Ofgem to publish the mutualisation threshold for the 2023-24 obligation period as soon as reasonably practicable after 1 April. Ordinarily, Ofgem must publish the threshold before the new obligation period starts but, given that the SSI will not come into force until 31 March, it is allowed to publish the threshold later than that.
For the reasons that I have set out, I believe that the proposed amendment is necessary and proportionate, and I am more than happy to answer any questions before we move on to the debate.