Thank you. We have different areas of expertise, so, at some point—I apologise for the informality—I might say, “Ask Ali,” or she might say, “Ask Luis.”
I thank the committee for providing us with the opportunity to discuss minimum core obligations. We are excited to be able to do so, as it is a really important area of economic, social and cultural rights and one that is often not carefully considered and understood.
It is useful to start with a general understanding of what minimum core obligations are. Under international legal standards, as developed by the United Nations Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, which is the treaty-monitoring body in the UN that monitors compliance with the covenant that was ratified by the United Kingdom, minimum core obligations are those obligations that are essential and of such importance that, if they are not complied with, the purpose of the covenant will not be met. They have to be complied with—they are not subject to progressive realisation or available resources.
I will provide the committee with a very simple definition: minimum core obligations are the obligations relating to economic, social and cultural rights that a country needs to comply with at all times and in all circumstances, regardless of the resources or the overall conditions of a country. If minimum core obligations are not met, a country is not complying with its international legal obligations.
We can understand minimum core obligations as being in two categories. One category relates to results. The obligations in that category are often viewed as obligations of entitlement. For example, in relation to food or education, they mean having the right to have access to essential food stock or the right to have access to the most basic forms of free primary education.
The other category is obligations of conduct. We are no longer talking about entitlements; we are talking about the way that the state has to behave and act. Using health as an example, we are not talking about access to a specific medical service; we are talking about an obligation—a minimum core obligation—to set forth a public health plan. That is an obligation of conduct and not necessarily an obligation of result.
It is important to raise the fact that, as of now, since the UK ratified the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights in 1976, minimum core obligations should be met in Scotland today, and duty bearers should be working tirelessly to ensure that they are complied with. The process of incorporation, which I am sure that we will talk about today, reaffirms the legal commitments and ensures that there can be legal accountability when minimum core obligations are not met, but that does not mean that, as of now, given the ratification of the covenant, they should not be met at present.
I also want to make sure that we understand that minimum core obligations are part of a set of four really important, inherently intertwined and interdependent obligations that are attached to economic, social and cultural rights. ESC rights are subject to progressive realisation, which means that they have to be improved over time, and efforts need to be made to ensure that the realisation of rights can happen over time, but they are dependent on the maximum available resources. Therefore, it is necessary to ensure that proper funding is allocated, mobilised and spent in such a way as to ensure that you can progress rights. There is a lot of overlap with why that is really relevant to the work that Ali and the commission have done in relation to human rights budgeting.
The third component is those obligations that are of immediate consequence, which include the minimum core obligations that we are talking about today.
The final component, which it is really important to mention, is non-retrogression, which involves ensuring that the level of enjoyment of the right is not regressed in any way. If it is regressed, there is a very strict test of the reasons for that—reasons have to be provided.
I will conclude by sharing our recent publication, “Building a new human rights framework for Scotland”, which gives our overall analysis of the key legal features for the new human rights bill. In it, we explain what the new human rights bill needs to guarantee to ensure that it is maximalist, internationalist, multi-institutional and world leading, as the national task force indicated it should be. Our analysis is mostly based on international legal standards and best comparative examples across the world.
It is useful to mention the four essential elements that we have said need to be guaranteed in relation to minimum core obligations. First, we recommend that an obligation should be placed on relevant duty bearers to ensure that the minimum essential levels of economic, social, cultural and environmental rights for people to be able to live a dignified life are always met.
Secondly, those essential levels must be defined in further secondary legislation after a participatory process has taken place, which includes taking careful consideration of those with lived experience, technical expertise and policy makers.
Thirdly, the secondary legislation should be reviewed every 10 years to ensure that those essential levels are a reflection of the technological, societal, financial and environmental realities of Scotland. The process should continue to ensure that the views of those with lived experience, technical expertise and policy makers provide the basis for any changes.
Fourthly, the bill should include an impossibility test that allows duty bearers to avoid responsibility only if they are able to prove that, in spite of all their efforts, they could not comply with achieving their minimum core obligations.
We look forward to discussing minimum core obligations today. In future, we will be happy to talk more about what we consider to be the key and essential legal features from a human rights perspective for the human rights bill.