Again, I want to reiterate that the Scottish Government has already recognised much of that to be true, because we have committed to achieving good environmental status and to fishing below the maximum sustainable yield. To achieve that, you must have extensive spatial management. The inference that extensive spatial management will lead to improved fish populations, environmental health and jobs is already implicit in the Scottish Government’s commitments, the sustainable development goals and the UK Fisheries Act 2020. Indeed, it is implicit in all those things that we must have extensive spatial management of trawl and dredge gear and more static gears in order to meet our commitments.
Those commitments are based on the fact that the Government has already recognised that those are basic requirements for ecosystem health, and a healthy ecosystem will produce more jobs and more robust coastal communities.
There is, though, more direct evidence. In 2015, the Scottish Government commissioned a report called “Management of the Scottish Inshore Fisheries; Assessing the Options for Change”, which showed that the introduction of a 3-mile limit in Scotland would produce more jobs and supply better ecosystem health and that it would also supply associated jobs, such as diving, angling and so on. There is huge potential for jobs to be created for coastal communities indirectly by introducing good environmental health to our marine ecosystem.
Furthermore, in 2016, the New Economics Foundation produced a working paper called “The Scottish Nephrops fishery: Applying social, economic, and environmental criteria”. I will provide a bit of background to that. Article 17 of the common fisheries policy obligated us to use social, economic and environmental criteria as the basis for allocating fishing opportunity, but many people found that to be quite complicated and they wanted to know how to go about doing that. The New Economics Foundation wrote a report on how that would be progressed in the Scottish nephrops fishery. It concluded that swinging the bias towards more creel fishing would employ more fishermen, have a reduced impact on the environment and generate more revenues for coastal communities. I think we can infer from that that there would be more jobs as a consequence.
Lastly, the Scottish Creel Fishermen’s Federation produced a document called “Correcting the Misallocation of Nephrops Stocks in Scottish Inshore Waters: Untapping a Vast Economic (and Environmental) Potential”, which clearly demonstrated that every time that you take an equivalent two-man small-scale trawler out of the system, you could replace it with four two-men creel boats without extracting a single extra nephrop. Therefore, there would potentially be far more employment not just directly in the fishing industry but indirectly in angling, diving, marine tourism and suchlike. I think that that is a given.