Thank you, deputy convener.
There has been a lot of research on the needs of island groups around the world. Frequency is often top of the list, as it also gives reliability in the system. Price tends to come a bit lower down the list. Frequency, which gives reliability, is the most important feature in most studies of user needs. That can be achieved through faster speeds and more vessels per route—simpler vessels rather than opulent vessels, which the CalMac-type ships have been described as. That is important.
There has been enormous investment in ferries in Scotland. Investment is not the problem; the problem is that it is spent very badly. That is related to the very poor procurement process, which is very restrictive. The specification of the ship is very tight, and lots of bidders are squeezed out of the procurement process. For example, in the recent bidding to provide the second two of the four vessels for Islay, there were only two bids, but the second bid was rejected for spurious reasons.
A lot of my research in the past 30 years has been on catamarans around the world. We have catamarans in Orkney—we are now on the second ones. They have replaced the CalMac monohulls that started the services in Orkney, and we have tried to get those ferries widely used in Scotland.
All of us were members of Keith Brown’s expert ferry group, which has since disbanded. We—certainly I—advocated the deployment of catamarans, at least for trial periods. We were able to offer catamarans to ministers, officials and ferry agencies, but they always refused to buy them. They raised what were, in my view, fallacies—I produced a paper and a presentation for the Mull and Iona ferry community on the ferry fallacies that were raised. CalMac and CMAL have always refused to use catamarans, but it so happens that, this week, I believe, they may well be chartering the Orkney ferry catamaran—the MV Pentalina. After 15 years of rejecting catamarans, they might finally be using one, because they are desperate for tonnage and ships are collapsing.
Catamarans come in at between half and one third of the price of CalMac monohulls, it takes half the time to build them, and they are much more efficient to run because of the lower displacement—I mean the weight of the ship. The designs that CalMac has come up with are inordinately inefficient. They are the equivalent of bricks; they add as much weight as they can to the ship. The catamarans have half the power requirement of a monohull, so they have half the emissions. If you are interested in net zero, the catamarans give that. They are half the price or less, they produce half the emissions, and they are the most stable and safe ferry platform that you can get. That was the result of Professor Vassalos’s recent study on catamarans at the University of Strathclyde. They are much more stable—the fact that they have no need for ballast tanks or stabilisers is a good indication of that—and they represent a massive saving on price.
The problem is that CMAL does not include catamarans in the tender process. It excludes them. It even went to the extent of inventing a false catamaran in the Islay ferry class development. It got its naval architect, who had never designed a catamaran before, to design a false catamaran, adding as much weight as they could, just to discount it, which is worse than negligent.
I would also raise the issue of inflated prices for ferries around the world. That tends to indicate that something else is wrong here. In the recent tender for the second Islay class, there was a bid that was 20 per cent below the winning bid, with a delivery time of 18 months, which was half the time in the accepted bid from Cemre in Turkey. CMAL is taking bids, accepting winning bids, appointing bidders that have bid higher prices, excluding catamarans from the bidding process, and accepting later delivery times. That makes things worse for the islanders, who are desperate for ships.
We also have to remember that these are agencies that do not really have much in the way of maritime education. They do not understand that there is a shipbuilding cycle, for example. If they knew the theory of shipping and maritime transport theory and policy, they would understand that you never order ships at the peak of the cycle. That is what they have been doing: they have been ordering ships at the peak of the cycle, when they are expensive. That is another problem—ferry agencies and Government tend not to be aware of those things.
There is a range of issues to do with user needs and frequency—that is a key issue—but it always comes back to procurement. We have a flawed and failed procurement process and, if you do not mind me saying so, a lot of potential skulduggery on the Ferguson Marine thing. A lot of evidence that was previously presented to committees from Luke van Beek, Ferguson’s management, me, Roy Pedersen and others demonstrated that the bringing down of Ferguson’s, which happened for the second time—not the first time—with CMAL, could have been intentional. Going in every day and making changes to the design and production ensured that the ships would never be delivered. Why was that? That was probably because the preferred bidder did not get the contract. This is where—