PE1909, on removing the “gender-based crime” domestic abuse narrative and making it gender neutral and equal, was lodged by William Wright. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to make domestic abuse policies, guidance, agendas and practices gender neutral; to introduce equal domestic abuse provision and funding for everyone in Scotland, regardless of any protected characteristic; and to ensure that all domestic abuse joint protocol guidance, policies and practice for Police Scotland and the Crown Office and Prosecutor Fiscal Service are gender neutral.
At our previous consideration of the petition, the committee agreed to write to the Scottish Government, Police Scotland, the ManKind Initiative, the Paul Lavelle Foundation and Men’s Aid Ireland. The Minister for Equalities and Older People has advised that the Scottish Government is engaging and consulting on a national strategy on ending intimate and sexual violence against men and boys. She thanks the petitioner for his interest in this area of work, and notes
“the importance of developing this strategy, which will be complementary to the Equally Safe Strategy which addresses violence against women and girls.”
The ManKind Initiative says that a fully gender-informed approach should be taken to domestic abuse, and that framing it as a gender-based crime leads to unequal outcomes for male and LGBT+ victims.
Police Scotland states:
“There is no variance in the current training provided to officers on how to support victims of domestic abuse based on the victims’ specific gender.”
It outlines Abused Men in Scotland’s work on Police Scotland’s domestic abuse forum, which informs the police’s strategic direction in relation to domestic abuse. Police Scotland also reiterates that the definition of domestic abuse does not distinguish victims or perpetrators on the basis of sex or gender.
William Wright has provided us with further information about his experiences as a male victim of domestic abuse. He says that statistics on crimes committed against men contradict the view that men in Scotland have privilege that enables them to oppress others.
In view of everything that we have heard and the response from the Government and agencies that are now seeking to reach out and take the issue seriously, do colleagues have any reflections on how to proceed?
