Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Petitions

Makaton Sign Language (Legal System) (PE1787)

Tuesday 13 December 2022 Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee About 11:15–12:15 Petitions 36 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

36 contributions
Joe FitzPatrick SNP The Convener · Dundee City West
link

Welcome back. Our next agenda item is to hear more about a petition on Makaton sign language. Our predecessor committee kept the petition open and included it in its legacy paper for us to consider. I welcome to the meeting the petitioner, Sandra Docherty, who is accompanied by David Bain, and I invite Sandra to speak to the petition.

Sandra Docherty
link

Good morning. I will start with what I have written down on paper. Please excuse my nervousness.

Sandra Docherty
link

Makaton was created more than 40 years ago by Margaret Walker, who now has an MBE. She is a trained speech therapist and founded Makaton sign language back in the 1970s. Little did she know that it would become so widely known by children and adults with severe communication and learning disabilities all over the United Kingdom. It is used at home, in schools and colleges, within the community and at work. No one thought that it could or would be used in 40 countries, from Kuwait to Japan, and from France to India.

How did Margaret Walker come up with the idea of Makaton? In 1968, she was working in a large hospital in the south of England called Botleys Park hospital. It was not a hospital for people who were medically sick; it was for children and adults who were severely disabled. There were 1,100 adults and children in the hospital, and they were all classified as patients, although it was a huge institution for children with learning disabilities. Expectations for those patients were low; they were not expected to be able to communicate, and it was thought that they would not have anything beneficial to say. Education, social interaction and activities were on a very low level.

The staff communicated only with patients with speech, so many patients could not even express their thoughts and feelings, which led to frustration. One day, that was brought to Margaret’s attention when working with one of her boys. He turned round and bit her on the arm through frustration. From that, she decided to start an assessment of all 1,100 people in Botleys Park in order to get a better understanding of their communication problems. Such an assessment had never been done before. Margaret discovered that 60 per cent of patients had severe communication problems and 50 per cent had additional problems such as hearing impairments, visual impairments, physical disability and autism.

As a speech therapy student, Margaret worked with profoundly deaf children, so she knew the importance—

Do you mind if I get a drink of water?

Sandra Docherty
link

She knew the importance of the many basic signs for everyday life experiences. Margaret wondered whether adding signs from British Sign Language using only the key words in speech might help patients’ understanding—for example, asking “Do you want a drink?” by signing “you” and “drink”. Margaret went on to create a vocabulary of signs that reflected patients’ everyday lives. She spent six months talking to staff and patients and listening to patients attempting to respond. Margaret ended up with thousands of pages of results, which gave her around 350 signs, ranging from simple ones such as “you”, “me”, “eat”, “sleep”, “good” and “bad”, to more difficult ones such as “to think”, “to understand”, “to ask why” and “because”.

Linguistics shows that there is a pattern in every spoken language, and that there is a small range of vocabulary of essential words called a threshold or core vocabulary, which was compiled by the Oxford University Press. In 1976, Margaret held the first-ever Makaton workshop, for 40 people, which was instantly a huge success. A book with pictures of signs using hands and arrows was created, and more workshops quickly followed as a result of the growing interest from all over the UK.

11:45

Margaret established the Makaton vocabulary development project, which later became a charitable trust called the Makaton Charity. Following the original success with signing, they noticed that some patients with severe physical disability who were unable to make the signs and clearly express themselves needed a symbol system to match the words and the signs in the core vocabulary. That was another huge task for Margaret. It took about five years to research and to design symbols for dramatic elements such as sounds, verbs, prepositions and so on. Makaton signs are now an integrated part of the Makaton language programme.

Thankfully, in the 1970s, 1980s and 1990s, attitudes changed and institutions such as Botleys Park started to close. The patients were recognised as children and adults, entitled to have normal lives in the community like the rest of us. With the help of others, they produced a large resource vocabulary library of additional signs and symbols arranged around topics, which would be used as core vocabulary. At present, we have more than 7,500 signs in the Makaton resource vocabulary. It seems that Margaret had, unintentionally, produced a threshold core vocabulary. Now, there is a broadening vocabulary experience through a staged approach to learning Makaton vocabulary.

Margaret needed to know whether the patients could learn signs and, if so, how many signs could they learn and would they be able to use the signs to communicate with others? Margaret started her research evaluation in 1972 and it lasted nine months. She found that the patients could learn signs: 50 per cent of the group learned 90 per cent of the signs, but even those with lower scores learned about 60 per cent of the signs. Margaret also found that some patients were attempting to sign to each other, which made a huge improvement to their lives and understanding.

What was most noticeable was that all the patients became more alert, attentive and sociable and, to Margaret’s surprise, some patients tried speech, something that was never expected. No one had tried to speak to those patients before. Soon after that, Margaret repeated the same evaluation with children between the ages of three and seven, all of whom had similar disabilities to the adults but were living at home and in the community, not in an institution. The results showed similar positive outcomes but extra vocabulary was needed to cover community life, so Margaret enlarged the core vocabulary. It was then that she named it Makaton: “Ma” for Margaret, “Ka” for Kathy, and “Ton” for Tony—Kathy Johnston and Tony Cornforth were two BSL signers who were working alongside Margaret. It used to be pronounced “Mak-ton”, but “Mak-a-ton” is how it is said nowadays.

Makaton entered mainstream education as professionals working in mainstream education and training began to see the potential of using Makaton signs and symbols for the development of literacy and number skills.

The creation of Makaton was very challenging and it was a lot of work for Margaret, Kathy and Tony but—excuse me; I need a drink of water—it must have been an incredible experience, and can only have been rewarding to see how it can change the lives of users and their families and carers, and of professionals. My sister signs Makaton, and she amazes me every day. She uses Makaton signs every day: polite ones and a few that she has created herself—they might not be quite so polite, but they are her signs and she uses them, and she is amazing.

It is amazing to see how others have expanded on Margaret Walker’s work in ways that she would never have thought that it could have gone. There are new and exciting resources, which are all different: from the smile with baby resource and Makaton nursery rhymes to the award-winning BBC children’s series “Something Special”, which uses Makaton signs and symbols. On YouTube, there is “Makaton CarPark Karaoke”, along with “Makaton Topic” videos—for example, on feelings and emotions—and many more videos that use signs, symbols and speech. There are also connections on the computer in order to see different things.

Margaret has said that she felt that she was privileged to work with professionals in many different countries, adapting the British Makaton programme to different cultures and providing essential training. Tens of thousands of people have now been trained to use the Makaton language programme through the network of tutors.

Finally, Margaret is grateful for the commitment and interest of people who have given hope for improving the lives, chances and opportunities of those with disabilities from all over the world.

Joe FitzPatrick SNP The Convener · Dundee City West
link

Brilliant—thank you so much, Sandra. That was really good. If we were to stop now and do nothing more on the petition, you should know that you have already achieved a significant raising of awareness in this place and probably further afield. I thank you for that, because it is really important.

We will now go round the committee and ask a few questions. I will start. The petition talks specifically about the use of Makaton in the legal system. I wonder whether you might want to talk a little about that and about whether, if we are going to look at this issue, we should look more widely than the legal system. We are the civil justice committee, but we are also the equalities and human rights committee, so we span all those areas.

Sandra Docherty
link

I have outlined the history of Makaton and set out how it started. There is no doubt that it has benefited many people through the years, but there is a problem for people who sign Makaton. Four things are always required for anything in life: who, what, where and when. People who sign Makaton might not be able to do “where” and “when”, but they might be able to do “who” and “what”.

If a situation was to arise in which the police were involved, they would need information on who, what, where and when. Personally, I can say that my sister could tell you who and what, but she does not have the capacity to tell you where or when. That does not affect only my sister—it will affect thousands of people all around the UK, in Europe and even further afield. If these people cannot get those two bits of information out, the police—as great as they are; they are supportive of and understand Makaton—can only go so far to check what is going on. They cannot take a matter to any level of criminal investigation, because they do not have the four bits of information that they need. They can look into it, but I have spoken to quite a few police officers, and they say, “We can’t take it any further if we don’t have the where or the when.”

That is what we need, and that is where Makaton is not really able to push things forward because of how the justice system currently sits.

I do not know how to change the justice system, or what kind of law or change in the wording would be needed. However, the issue needs to be looked at and the situation needs to be changed—we would hope—for people with disabilities who use Makaton. People who sign BSL are a lot more capable of signing and communication, whereas Makaton is much easier and simpler—for example, as I said, Makaton uses the signs for “you” and “drink” to say “Do you want a drink?”, and there is no extra signing from BSL that would be involved in that.

I believe that people who sign Makaton should be helped, and the legal system should be made aware of people who use it and who do not have the capacity to say where or when something happened or whatever else is involved.

Joe FitzPatrick SNP The Convener · Dundee City West
link

I suppose one of the questions is how often people who communicate using Makaton will come across people in the legal system and elsewhere who can understand them and communicate back in Makaton. We may want to look at that to ensure that, whatever information people have, or even if they sign, “I want a glass of water before I go any further”, they can communicate that, be understood and get a response.

Sandra Docherty
link

The police have to get a specialist in, which takes time. Also, when an interpreter comes in, the person who uses Makaton has to make a connection with them. It does not matter how good or how kind the interpreter is; the person will be feeling apprehensive and, if they and the interpreter do not know each other, they will find it harder to get the information over. Even people who do not have problems can feel a bit tense or nervous when they go to give information—as I do now—and it can be difficult to deal with that. When disability and incapacity are thrown in as well, it becomes a lot harder for people. Hundreds or thousands of people across the UK are probably in that situation right now, unfortunately. It would be nice to know that the justice system will cover the Makaton side and help things to get to court.

Fulton MacGregor SNP Coatbridge and Chryston
link

Good morning, Sandra, and thanks for your presentation on the history of Makaton. I found it very interesting and helpful. You apologised to the committee a couple of times during your presentation, but there is absolutely no need to apologise. You gave a very clear and concise history, and I thank you for that.

My questions follow on from the convener’s question about how Makaton fits into the legal system. You have spoken a wee bit about the police. Do you have any information—I would not expect you to have data—on how often Makaton is used in court settings, be they civil or criminal? Is that something that you have heard about? Have people asked for Makaton to be used in court settings? If so, is it made available to them?

Sandra Docherty
link

Makaton is used in the legal system, although BSL is a lot more to the fore. The problem with Makaton is that it is very basic. Somebody who signs Makaton may have real incapacity problems with speech and communication skills, which makes things 10 or 12 times harder.

I had a situation where I had to see the police to discuss a situation that had arisen and I had to explain to them that the person I was with could sign “who” and “what”, but not “where” and “when”, and that she did not have the capacity to give them that information. They could not get a Makaton signer to come in and help the person to put the information forward. The police did checks on what had happened, but because they only had the who and the what, not the where or the when, they could not take it any further.

The justice system needs to change to open the door for people who cannot give that information. It may be that they have witnessed something but they cannot give the where or the when. That is hard. The thought that those people are not getting the opportunity to have the legal system protect them is upsetting. We do not see them getting something back from a situation that was negative in their lives, whatever the area. Does that make sense?

12:00

Fulton MacGregor SNP Coatbridge and Chryston
link

It does, thank you.

Have you come across any examples of an individual—perhaps an advocate—having requested that Makaton be used during court proceedings, where that has not been provided for? We may need to ask the Government or someone who would keep records about that.

Sandra Docherty
link

I have never found anything in the legal system that has got that far. I could not find any particular cases where Makaton has been used throughout court proceedings. We are getting stuck at the starting block. The police have not been able to progress the issue; unfortunately, we have not been able to get to the stage of having evidence in Makaton and being able to go to court with it, as far as I am aware. However—this might sound strange—it would be good to find a way of being able to do that for someone who has disabilities that require them to use Makaton, as they would then be able to go to court and get fairness and justice for themselves.

Everyone is entitled to justice and to being able to speak, communicate and be part of the world. If they are not happy with what is happening, they should be able to speak out—or sign out—and the legal system should be able to pick up on that and pursue the issue they have raised. People who use Makaton are human beings, just like everyone else. I regularly hear the word “normal” being used. I am sorry, but what is normal in this world? Normal is a hard thing to describe when someone who is in front of you has problems with speech and understanding. In their world, they are normal, but there is a great big jump between them and the legal system. That gap has to be filled. There is still a perceived line between them and normality, which is such a shame.

The people in Botleys Park hospital were not called adults and children; they were classified as patients. That type of hospital did not shut until the late 1990s. There is still a perceived line today between disability and normality, and I think that that is unfair.

Fulton MacGregor SNP Coatbridge and Chryston
link

I could not agree more with what you have said. That shows the importance of the petition.

David Bain
link

As Sandra Docherty has said, it is hard for people to express themselves. Usually, the people who use Makaton as opposed to BSL also have learning difficulties. In the situation that Sandra referred to, there had been an assault. Even though that person’s face was visibly marked down one side, the police could not do anything about it. Seven different stories were told about how the mark on the person’s face came about. No one believed the person, because she could not explain fully what had happened to them.

You were talking about Makaton interpreters, but different people have different interpretations of Makaton, which is a big problem. For example, we were at an adult protection event, where a group of people, some with responsibility for others, were sitting around a table, and one person was using a sign that, to them, meant “That was bad”, but someone else at the table was from an organisation that used that sign for “bold”. Their meaning was manipulated, because the organisation tried to say that the person was signing the word “bold”, but they were not. It is very easy to abuse Makaton, and we have found that people do, so we need a voice for people. We need the police to try and get around the communication issues and find another way to gather evidence so that people can be brought to justice.

Joe FitzPatrick SNP The Convener · Dundee City West
link

That is a good point, and that was a helpful intervention, David.

Pam Duncan-Glancy Lab Glasgow
link

Thank you, Sandra, for everything that you said. I was not aware of the detail of the history of Makaton that you shared, which was fascinating. I was aware of what it is, but I did not understand its history. Thank you for telling us about that and for answering our questions.

David, your point about justice really got to the heart of what this is about, which is justice for disabled people, as you both described. Many of those who are in the circumstances that you described are people with learning disabilities.

Sandra, you made a point about the need for the person to connect with the interpreter. Are you aware of any situation where somebody who already has a connection with the person who uses Makaton—a member of their family or friendship group, or a person who provides interpretation in another context, for example—has been allowed to support them in a legal situation? If so, has that carried any weight?

Sandra Docherty
link

I do not know of any situation like that. I have never found a case that has got to court where Makaton has been used. I have seen a lot of interpreters meet people who sign in Makaton. They can go in and start signing, and it is great to see two people sign away in Makaton and be able to understand each other.

Another important thing about Makaton is that, when you sign, you speak at the same time. For example, if you use the sign for the word “coffee” or the word “drink”, you would speak the word “coffee” or “drink” at the same time. Some people believe that, if a person cannot speak, they cannot hear, but that is not the case. Susie, my sister, might not be able to speak, but she can certainly hear a pin drop, and I assure you that she does not miss a lot. That is just another example of how things are different on the disability side of the fence and—I am going to use this word again—the normal side of the fence.

It is unfortunate that I have not found a case that has gone to court where an interpreter has been there and that has worked. If that ever happens, it will be good to see people being supported in court by an interpreter. As yet, I have not heard of a case where that has happened.

Pam Duncan-Glancy Lab Glasgow
link

Have you heard of anyone who got support before a case went to court?

Sandra Docherty
link

I have heard of a lot of people who have been able to get support from a Makaton signer, but I have not heard of anyone who has had that support in the legal system.

If a person wants to do sport or another activity that they are interested in, interpreters allow them to make connections with people so that they can start going and getting involved in sport, cooking or arts and crafts—whatever it is that they want to do. Makaton can link into different areas when a person shows a sign that they want to do something. However, as I said, I have unfortunately not heard of it being used in court.

Pam Duncan-Glancy Lab Glasgow
link

Do you mean that people report crimes to the police but they do not get support to use Makaton or to express themselves so their cases never reach court because they do not quite reach the bar for the amount of evidence that is needed?

Sandra Docherty
link

That is right. A lot of people go to the police, but the police say that they need four bits of information: the who, the what, the where and the when. If the police do not have that information, they have nothing to start on. I have spoken to quite a few officers and they all told me that they need to know who did it; where it was, whether it was in the house or in a street; and when it happened, whether it was in the morning or the afternoon, so that they can do a criminal investigation by looking at closed-circuit television, talking to people and all of the rest of it.

As far as I am aware, nothing has got that far. Cases may have gone to the police, but they have said that they cannot pick them up or take them any further because they have nothing to work on as they need those four bits of information. I think that that, in itself, is a crime against people who need to use Makaton.

Pam Gosal Con West Scotland
link

Thank you for your presentation, Sandra. Like my colleague Pam Duncan-Glancy, I did not know much about Makaton, so it was really useful to hear about that and about the great work that Margaret Walker has done.

Our briefing for the meeting highlights a

“lack of a routine procedure for identifying individuals with a learning disability”

and a lack of intersectional data. If there was more in-depth data collection about different types of physical and learning disabilities, would that help to identify where Makaton would be most useful and how best it could be delivered in certain services? Which services should it be used in?

Sandra Docherty
link

It is important to get it out there that Makaton is now a huge and vitally important thing. Social workers in all areas, the police and those who work in adult protection are aware of Makaton, but I have never found a social worker or a police officer who was able to sign Makaton back to a person. That needs to be put in place. The data needs to be shaken up and looked at again. Everything in the world is moving forward, so I feel that Makaton should be right up there, and if data needs to be updated, that should be done.

It is vital to get the whole legal system involved, but I have not found an example of something going right through to the court process with a result at the end. I have not found anything like that. I believe that a lot of work needs to be done and that there is data out there that needs to be looked at and reviewed. Whatever is not up to scratch, as we might put it, should be looked at again and refreshed or restarted. I am not sure which word I am trying to find. We need to give this more life again so that more people have a chance to understand exactly where Makaton is in the legal system—and in every other system. Updates are important and the data is important.

Karen Adam SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

Thank you for bringing the petition to the committee. I am excited about being able to talk about a sign language. It is really important to note that, as you stressed, BSL is different from Makaton. I was brought up bilingual, so to speak, because my dad was deaf. I was brought up to be quite fluent in BSL, so I know the difference. BSL is a full and complete language in itself, whereas Makaton has a sign per word for someone who may already understand English or spoken language.

I have seen the communication difficulties for people who use sign language in any form and I know how incredibly frustrating they can be. There are different signs for different words, which is why it is important to have an interpreter who knows how someone uses the signs. There is some crossover with the idea of understanding. I completely get where you are coming from: communication is vitally important.

It was interesting that you brought up the signs for who, what, where and when. I always add why and how. We have who, what, where, when, why and how. When someone can make the signs for those words, as I have just done, they can begin to open up and really communicate with another individual.

The point about communication is key to the evidence that you are giving today, particularly when it comes to the justice system, because in that case we are talking about people who are already in a vulnerable position. Statistically, they are more likely to be taken advantage of, which is why it is so important that we get the communication right.

12:15

I am saying all this because I want you to know that I really understand where you are coming from. I have seen somebody with a learning difficulty start to use Makaton and it made a massive difference in their life. I could see it in their demeanour and how they could express themselves. Just to be able to show that they wanted something to eat, for example, made a massive difference.

We are focusing on communication in the justice system. Are there any other areas that you think should be opened up through use of Makaton or do you want to focus only on the justice aspect?

Sandra Docherty
link

It should be opened up across the board. However, it was the justice side of things that really made me aware of the issue. I spoke to a police officer who said that two bits of information were not enough and that they needed the four bits of information. That made me stop and think that hundreds or thousands of people out there could be going through the same things as Sue and not getting any further because the police need those four bits of information.

I thought about the issue in relation to the justice system in the first place but, as you said, there are so many signs that can get mixed up, which means that people do not understand. For the people out there who use Makaton, it is their way of speaking to the world and to everybody around them, and they can express their feelings and their emotions using it, so I think that it should be included in other areas.

If someone is unwell and they go to a hospital, as great as the staff and doctors are at their jobs, there is a problem. Sometimes you will find doctors who can do some BSL, but either they have not heard of Makaton or they do not know how to use it to benefit the person and to understand them.

Also, as you said, everybody has their own signs and their own ways of signing. Susie has a certain set of words that she will sign to me and I will know exactly what she is saying—sometimes they are rude words. It is a case of using signs that we both know. There are other people around Susie that she will sign slightly differently to. She has the capacity to sign in one way to one person and in another way to somebody else.

This whole area really needs to get opened up.

Karen Adam SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

That is really helpful. What you have said makes me think that it would be good to keep some documentation of the signs that a person uses. We had a wee document passed to us today that shows us some signs. I was just thinking that I sign my name by pointing to my cheek, because I have a dimple, but those things are quite individual even in families or households. We also have regional sign language—I talk mostly Doric BSL—so I completely get your point, and that has opened up another aspect.

Sandra Docherty
link

We were lucky in that Susie’s speech therapist created a folder for Makaton that is full of pictures. When Susie comes out to stay with us for holidays and things, she can use that folder if she is trying to tell me something and I am not getting it. She will keep going back and forward through it until she finds the sign, and then she will point at it and sign it. There is that help from speech therapists. I think that many speech therapists have done that for people who use Makaton, because it is a vital stepping stone for them.

It is also about the act of using your hands and signing. There are disabilities that mean that people cannot make a Makaton sign clear. They need to use something that is called a talking mat, which is literally just a board that has pictures of whatever we are trying to discuss on one side and, on the other side, a happy face or a sad face. It can be easy enough for the person to tell you “football—sad face” or “swimming—happy face”, which means that they want to do that. In that way, you can get that connection with them. That is something else that needs to be pushed out there.

David Bain
link

As Sandra Docherty said, Makaton is a wonderful thing for the people who use it. It has given them the freedom to express themselves, yet when it comes to the justice system, they can be let down and made more vulnerable. It has enhanced people’s lives, but they are let down by the justice system.

Karen Adam SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

That is really helpful—thank you.

Maggie Chapman Green North East Scotland
link

Sandra and David, I have learned so much from you this morning, so I thank you both for what you have said so far. I also thank you for bringing in the point about health settings, because I was going to ask about widening our consideration of the issue. However, I know that you are focused on the justice issue and the question of vulnerability, which David has just mentioned.

I will play devil’s advocate a little. I should say straight up that there is definitely something here for us to explore, although we will need to consider in more detail exactly what route we might take. One of the challenges that we might encounter as we pursue this work is the argument that there are already facilities for when somebody does not have “normal” mental capacity. For example, there are mental health provisions and learning disability provisions for those people. It could be argued that those should be the routes that we use to enable their involvement in and engagement with the justice system.

One of the challenges that I expect will come along with that is that legislation on mental capacity, for example, comes with measures to safeguard the best interests of the person who lacks capacity. What is your response to such challenges? It would be useful for us to hear from you, given your personal experience with your sister, how that wider legal framework supports her—or not, as the case may be.

Sandra Docherty
link

If my sister needed to go and speak to the police, she would now happily do that. She thinks that the police are great and they are friends, which is all positive. Under the legal system as it stands, the police can deal with “normal”—there is that word again—day-to-day incidents. However, when somebody has incapacity problems and they require BSL, Makaton or any other form of help with communication, that is pushed through the social worker or whoever. They might be able to help a bit, but there is still the legal bit where the person has to come back into the legal system, and the facility is not fully in place to pick that up and take it forward. A stepping stone is required.

I could take the matter to the police, but then the police, or whoever else, would need to speak to Susie anyway so that she could take it forward. However, her capacity covers only the who and the what, and not the where or the when, so she cannot give all four bits of information. She could give you the where and the when by putting somebody else in the picture, because they may have thought of something else, or she may think of something else.

It can be difficult, in certain respects, to get people like my sister to concentrate on one thing. It is sad, but it is just part of their condition and their incapacity, whatever level that is at. With Susie, it is cerebral palsy—that is why she cannot talk. Nonetheless, she knows how she wants to live her life and how she can do that. She loves life, and I am a proud big sister, but I wish that the legal system was a bit more bendable and ready for Makaton, if you understand what I mean.

Maggie Chapman Green North East Scotland
link

I think that I do. Thank you—that is really helpful. Some of the challenges that I think might come at us exist because there is a rigid, inflexible justice system. You made the point that social workers and support workers can help up to a point but there is nothing that connects across the gap.

You have both given us a lot to think about and pursue, so I thank you for coming along this morning. I really appreciate it.

Joe FitzPatrick SNP The Convener · Dundee City West
link

A huge thank you to Sandra and David, who have raised a huge number of issues, some of which I do not think we were expecting. I had an expectation about where our discussion would go, but they have raised more issues for us to consider. As Maggie Chapman suggested, we will want to take a bit of time to do that and work out our approach.

I suggest to members that, for now, we make a formal decision to keep the petition open and write to the Scottish Government for its initial thoughts on the evidence that Sandra and David have presented today. Are members agreed?

Members indicated agreement.

Joe FitzPatrick SNP The Convener · Dundee City West
link

Brilliant—we will keep the petition open, write to the Government and decide in a future work programme discussion how we will take the matter forward. I thank Sandra and David again. We will now move into private session.

12:26 Meeting continued in private until 13:05.

  1. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 5
  2. 10:00 Petitions Petitions · 62
  3. 11:15 Petitions Petitions · 36

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.