It is one of the points that we highlighted as not being feasible to consider at this point but that we would like to be considered in a future review.
On people who receive disability benefits, Governments and the World Health Organization recognise that disabled people typically have higher energy costs. They will often spend more time at home and need a higher temperature when they are there. Therefore, additional support for disabled people in general could merit consideration, but we did not recommend it in our report as a feature of winter heating payments specifically.
The reason for that is that the winter heating payment is a low-income benefit and not everyone who is in receipt of a disability benefit is on a low income. If you are on one of the qualifying low-income benefits and have a disabled person in the house, you will qualify for the payment already, so the position of someone who is on disability assistance but a higher income is, in a way, a separate question. Child winter heating assistance is a more obvious model in that situation than winter heating payments.
When it comes to people who are on in-work benefits, a few things were on our minds. First, there is a basic inequality in how the regulations treat people who are in work and receiving income support, employment and support allowance or jobseekers allowance. They qualify for winter heating payments on the same basis and in the same way as people who are out of work and receiving the same benefits, whereas in-work claimants of universal credit can qualify only if they have a disabled child in their family.
Secondly, we all know that there are lower earners who will face the same cost of living challenges as people who are on out-of-work benefits. They might have more income, but the extra that they get could well be taken up by some of the costs that they face because they are in employment.
Thirdly, the social security charter required the Scottish Government to work to improve people’s perceptions of social security. Providing support to people who are out of work that is not available to very low earners is not likely to help with that project.
Those were a few things that we were thinking about. However, I emphasise that we recommend a review of the qualifying benefits, which the Scottish Government has indicated it is open to doing. We are not prejudging what the outcome of that review should be.
There is another difference between the legacy benefits and universal credit in that income support and the other legacy benefits are paid to people who are out of work or working only few hours, whereas people who are on universal credit could be working a far greater number of hours and have significantly higher earnings. That means that extending eligibility to in-work universal credit claimants but limiting it to the lowest earners for consistency with the current approach on the other benefits could mean a lot more work for Social Security Scotland in identifying who has entitlement.
It is another example of the administrative proficiency principle that I mentioned at the start, which could pull it in a slightly different direction to some of the other principles.