Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Detainees in Custody (Access to Medication) (PE1900)

Wednesday 7 December 2022 Citizen Participation and Public Petitions Committee About 09:30–10:30 Petitions 37 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

37 contributions
Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Item 2 is consideration of continued petitions, the first of which is PE1900, on access to prescribed medication for detainees in police custody, which was lodged by Kevin John Lawson. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to ensure that all detainees in police custody can access their prescribed medication, including methadone, in line with existing relevant operational procedures and guidance.

Colleagues will recall that, at our most recent meeting, we took evidence from David Strang, former chair of the Scottish Drug Deaths Taskforce—I gather that he is now part of the implementation group—and Dr Carole Hunter, who is a former member of the task force. Our discussion with them has informed some of the areas that we would like to explore during this morning’s meeting.

I am delighted to say that we are joined this morning by the Minister for Drugs Policy, Angela Constance, and her officials from the drugs policy division of the Scottish Government: Morris Fraser, head of delivery and support unit, and Henry Acres, head of cultural and structural change.

Good morning, and thank you all for coming; you are most welcome. We can move straight to questions, but if you would like to say something by way of introduction or clarification, minister, we would be happy to hear it.

Angela Constance SNP The Minister for Drugs Policy · Almond Valley
link

Thank you, convener, for inviting me along this morning. This is my first appearance at the committee in my capacity as Minister for Drugs Policy.

I want to start by thanking the committee and the petitioner for the work that they have done on this matter. Access to the right treatment at the right time for each and every person is at the very heart of the national mission. I support the aims of the petition and agree that the people who are detained in police custody must have access to their prescribed medication, including medication assisted treatment such as methadone.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Given what we heard from David Strang and Dr Carole Hunter at last week’s meeting, what is the Scottish Government’s reaction to the Scottish Drug Deaths Taskforce’s “Changing Lives” report, which included a comprehensive suite of recommendations? Will the Scottish Government publish a plan for those recommendations? At the end of January it will be six months since the publication of the report. I recognise that there is an implementation group, but what is your reaction to the report and can you summarise how you expect to move forward?

Angela Constance SNP Almond Valley
link

I very much welcomed the task force’s report, as I had been looking forward to receiving its vital recommendations. The task force has made a comprehensive suite of 20 recommendations with 139 action points, and we will issue our full response to those at the start of the new year.

We have given an initial response to the report to the Health, Social Care and Sport Committee, the Criminal Justice Committee and the Social Justice and Social Security Committee. We gave some indication of our direction of travel, but the culmination of our response will be presented to Parliament at the turn of the year.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

You paid tribute to the work of the petitioner earlier, and it was obviously a difficult personal situation that led to the petition being submitted to the committee. The petition identified some issues that were accepted in our correspondence with the Government as areas that merited a bit of further work and explanation.

We were impressed with the evidence that we heard last week. The experience of David Strang and Dr Carole Hunter is significant, and it underpinned an informed discussion.

Our job is in relation to the issues raised in the petition, and I will let David Torrance turn to those.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

How important is it to embed the medication assisted treatment standards in practice, especially to ensure that individuals receive appropriate medication while they are in police custody?

Angela Constance SNP Almond Valley
link

There are two points there, Mr Torrance. One is a more global point about the implementation of MAT standards. They are vital and they are a big part of the Government’s reform programme. They are about ensuring that people have quick access to and informed choice about their evidence-based treatment, and that services are planned and operate in a way that they anticipate people’s needs. All of that is connected to mental health and primary care, and the MAT standards are therefore crucial and not optional. Members will be aware of the statement that I made to Parliament earlier this year, and I will make a further statement next week.

On the specific issue of the prescription of medicine or opiate substitution therapy in police custody settings, MAT standard 3 requires people’s treatment to be provided to them irrespective of their setting. OST needs to be routinely available to those for whom it is prescribed in custodial settings if MAT standard 3 is to be met. All health boards, alcohol and drug partnerships and integration joint boards have accepted the importance of that and our shared agenda for implementation of MAT standards.

We have been engaging on the issues raised by the petitioner in committee with various police and healthcare networks, such as the Police Care Network and, to the best of my knowledge, the only place where there appeared to be an issue was in Elgin. However, I want to be clear—and the guidance and MAT standards are clear—about what should happen.

In my view, as Minister for Drugs Policy, any interruption of a person’s medical treatment is utterly unacceptable because of the consequences that the committee is well aware of. The interruption of someone’s medical treatment is discriminatory and not acceptable. Ultimately, the implementation of MAT standards will resolve the issue where it exists, and as I said, the issue appears to be specific to Elgin.

I hope to convey to the committee in the strongest terms that the practice, where it exists, is discriminatory and that we treat drug and alcohol problems as a health condition, so drug and alcohol treatment has to be on a par with any other treatment for any other condition.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

The Scottish Drug Deaths Taskforce recommends that the MATS should be embedded by May 2024. Is the Scottish Government on course to meet that? If not, how much work is still to be done?

Angela Constance SNP Almond Valley
link

There is a lot of work to do, and a lot of work is on-going. Members will be aware of the ministerial direction that I issued in June because I was not content with the scale and pace of progress. Part of the purpose of the statement that I will make to Parliament next week is to reflect on the information that all areas have provided on their improvement plans. All areas are subject to regular reporting on progress. For most areas, that will be done quarterly, but for areas that have particular difficulties, it will be monthly.

The other purpose of my statement next week is to inform Parliament of the Government’s view not just of the task force’s recommendations but those of Public Health Scotland’s benchmarking report, which was published in June.

Alexander Stewart Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

In the submission that the Scottish Government made to the committee in March, you committed to consulting with stakeholders in justice and health to establish the best methods of recording how many requests for prescribed medication had been made by individuals in custody, and whether those requests had been met. Can you give us an update on any progress on that?

Angela Constance SNP Almond Valley
link

That is an area that we have given considerable thought to, and I understood that the committee was raising the issue because there could be a gap in information. Part of the underpinning evaluation of our national mission to save and improve lives is to ensure that we have the right measurements in place.

I will not repeat what I have said about MAT standards, but ultimately issues such as these are resolved through the delivery of MAT standards.

I will just take a slight step back from the question to introduce some context. Public Health Scotland already publishes a range of information about OST, such as the number of people who are in treatment, for example. The committee is also well aware of the information that is held on the prescription of healthcare at the local level. The information that we are talking about is available, but it is held in Police Scotland’s national custody records. We are giving some thought to that. The task force has made more broad recommendations about ensuring that our healthcare and justice systems speak to each other, and other important recommendations about information sharing.

On information that is held by a statutory organisation such as Police Scotland, there are particular complexities around unravelling that. I am aware that His Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary in Scotland has access to a range of information that is held by Police Scotland, so I am contemplating whether that is a potential route and whether I, as minister, should engage with the inspectorate.

I do not know whether the committee has considered that. The information is available to the inspectorate through the inspections that it has done. Indeed, this time last year, it did an inspection that involved the Elgin custody suite and it made a number of recommendations. I am informed that that led to increasing nursing provision in custody so that there is now full-time nursing cover in that centre.

09:45

Alexander Stewart Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

That information gap might well have been identified, minister, and you have now indicated that through other resources and ways of managing it, it might be closed. We are trying to identify whether such a gap exists—and it would appear that it does—and whether everyone is supported while in custody.

Angela Constance SNP Almond Valley
link

It is not so much about a gap in the information as the availability and transparency of the information at the national level. More information is gathered about what happens with the prescription of OST in police custody settings than in other settings. That goes back to the nub of the issue. We have lots of information about where OST is dispensed, whether it be from a hospital or pharmacy, but we have much less information about where it is administered. The amount of information that is gathered in the police custody setting is much greater than that gathered in, say, homeless settings, where there are in-reach medical provisions.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

I wanted to pursue that issue myself. You started by saying that you thought that the incident in Elgin was isolated to the particular example that the petition raised. I was unclear why you thought that, but you explained that, although the information is not publicly transparent, it is there, and through the information that Police Scotland has available, you have been able to satisfy yourselves that it was just an isolated example. Therefore, when you said in response to the committee that the Scottish Government is giving consideration to that, it is not that you are considering a wholly new process, because you believe that the information is there already, but that you are considering how that information that is not necessarily or demonstrably available for people could be more transparent, so that people can see that the medicines have actually been prescribed. Is that correct?

Angela Constance SNP Almond Valley
link

That is an accurate summation about the information that is currently gathered by Police Scotland. In terms of me satisfying myself about what is happening on the ground, the major stream of work on that is around the implementation of MAT standards. We have a lot of granular information about what is happening at the local level. Colleagues might be aware of the supplementary information that was published in August that gives an area-by-area breakdown of where individual areas are with their MAT standards. The MAT standards implementation support team—MIST—is providing practical, hands-on support to local areas on how to gather information better and how to change the ways in which they are working while being fully cognisant of the need to challenge stigma, discrimination and culture. We have improvement plans in from all areas. We also have quarterly—or monthly, in some cases—reporting.

Through the serious and significant endeavours to implement MAT standards, we have much more information at the local level, which gives us a real connectivity between government and communities that we have not had previously.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness and Nairn
link

I preface my question by pointing out that I am not, of course, a clinician, but I want to raise an issue that was referred to in evidence. There was some concern that dihydrocodeine has been prescribed in NHS Grampian. We had some concerns about the appropriateness of that. During last week’s evidence session, I took the opportunity of asking Dr Hunter about it, and she said:

“Dihydrocodeine is sometimes prescribed in custodial settings. There is guidance on exceptional circumstances within the UK guidance that I mentioned. Its prescription should not be routine as a replacement, but there are some exceptional circumstances—including when it is not possible to get access to existing prescribed medication safely—in which it would be used by an experienced clinician.”—Official Report, Citizen Participation and Public Petitions Committee, 23 November 2022; c 4.

To be fair, we are seeking a response from NHS Grampian about this matter, as is only right and proper, and I am not sure whether we have that yet. I just wondered whether I could raise the issue with you and ask what the Scottish Government’s view is of the use of dihydrocodeine and whether it should be minimised, thus ensuring the availability of methadone, which I imagine would be the normal opiate substitute that is prescribed in most cases, at least in accordance with my understanding. Without casting any aspersion on or blaming NHS Grampian, I just want to raise the general issue with you, minister, to see what the Scottish Government’s view is because it was raised, either by the petitioner or others, in evidence.

Angela Constance SNP Almond Valley
link

Like you, Mr Ewing, I am not a clinician. You have, however, heard the evidence from Dr Carole Hunter, who is a senior pharmacist of many years’ standing.

This is one of the issues that I have written to NHS Grampian about. On the specific point about dihydrocodeine, while prescribers can make judgments on a case-by-case basis, based on clinical judgment and health and safety, the bottom line—as I understand it as a non-clinical person—in accordance with the United Kingdom guidance that Dr Hunter referred to and the guidelines for Police Scotland and healthcare professionals, is that the routine use of alternatives such as dihydrocodeine does not meet the required level of support for MAT standards, and they should only be used in exceptional circumstance, not routinely. That is what I have stated in my correspondence with NHS Grampian. Essentially, it is a reiteration of the guidance.

For information on the broader context of my correspondence with NHS Grampian, convener, I have written in fairly direct terms to say that it has come to my attention and I am aware that, despite the longstanding nature of the issue, it still does not routinely provide OST in all circumstances. The issue is around the routine nature of the provision. Yes, Dr Hunter spoke about exceptional circumstances but the health board should be in a position to provide OST routinely and it should not be disrupting people’s medication. I have therefore asked NHS Grampian if that is the case, and if it is, what is it going to do to remedy it, and when? I would be happy to share that letter and any response I receive in due course with the committee, if it would be helpful.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness and Nairn
link

That predicted the question that I was going to ask, which was whether you could let us know what response you get from NHS Grampian. It must obviously have an opportunity to respond and give its view; that is only fair and proper. However, part of our job is to make sure that the Parliament has properly and thoroughly analysed and responded to the petitioner’s plea for the availability of the prescription of opiate substitutes, principally methadone. I am keen to see the result of the inquiries and pleased that the minister has already pursued them rigorously. Thank you for that.

Paul Sweeney Lab Glasgow
link

A key aspect that was discussed in a previous evidence session was the risks that are associated with release from custody, particularly the Friday release practice, which the “Changing Lives” report recommended should be banned as expeditiously as possible. Will the minister give us an update on where the Government is with progressing that?

Angela Constance SNP Almond Valley
link

That is a feature in the Bail and Release from Custody (Scotland) Bill, which is at stage 1. I have been a longstanding advocate of ending Friday liberation. It just does not make sense to me. I appreciate that there are significant operational issues for the Scottish Prison Service to consider in all of this, but when I think of my time as a prison social worker—admittedly that was a long time ago now—I know that releasing large numbers of people on a Friday because people cannot be liberated on Saturday or Sunday can often lead to people not being liberated until later in the day. Although people’s care arrangements should be in place before they are liberated, which is part of the proposed justice legislation that the cabinet secretary is taking through Parliament, people have practical issues to contend with on the first day of their release that mean that it does not make sense that it should be on a Friday. If they face any challenges, it can mean that they have to wait until Monday.

We have to follow the evidence that shows that any period of transition and change comes with its risks. We know that people being released from custody means them going through a period of elevated risk, so we need to plan to mitigate that risk. At a commonsense level, Friday liberations do not make sense.

Paul Sweeney Lab Glasgow
link

In relation to that practice, Dr Carole Hunter made a key point about the support of the pharmacy network in Scotland, particularly around seven-day access. Does the minister have a view on how the pharmacy network could support the infrastructure around releasing prisoners from custody? I am particularly thinking about potential changes to doses when people who have been in a custody setting have to manage their medication outside.

Angela Constance SNP Almond Valley
link

In general, I agree that community pharmacies are an underused resource. The task force has made some interesting recommendations about an enhanced service contract, and there are some parallels with that around arrangements with general practitioners and primary care.

There are 1,250 pharmacies in Scotland. That is quite an extensive network that we could be tapping into. There is innovative, progressive and helpful use of pharmacist services in different parts of Scotland, but there is a network and expertise there that we need to make more use of. It is imperative that we use all the assets that are at our disposal and community pharmacies are very much part of that.

Paul Sweeney Lab Glasgow
link

Another key point about support from our pharmacy network more generally was about ensuring that people who are released from custody or those who are caring for them if they have a support network are provided with naloxone. The evidence that has been provided has indicated that that is a patchy practice. What is the minister doing to ensure that it is more of a standard protocol?

10:30

Angela Constance SNP Almond Valley
link

Good progress has been made in increasing the distribution of take-home naloxone kits. Quarterly figures were published on either Monday or Tuesday that approximately 6,500 take-home naloxone kits have been distributed. Members can refer to those published figures at their leisure but they give a breakdown of the settings from which they come, including prisons, community pharmacies and the Scottish Ambulance Service.

There are 13 alcohol and drug partnerships that have a prison within their catchment area, and 85 per cent of those have made specific arrangements with their community justice partners around identifying risks, part of which is the issuing of naloxone. In some cases, good use is also being made of peers, peer networks and people with lived experience who are now in recovery going into prison settings and supporting people with training on the take-home naloxone kit.

There is another statistic that we monitor. I hate talking about statistics in this fashion, convener, because, at the end of the day, we are talking about lives, but the reach of Scotland’s national naloxone programme continues to increase, and it is estimated that 66 people out of every 100 who are at risk of opioid overdose have been provided with a take-home naloxone kit.

Naloxone is very important but it is just one part of the solution, which is a whole system of care, treatment and support. I believe that we are making progress but we need to continue on our trajectory.

Paul Sweeney Lab Glasgow
link

I have one final question, if I may, convener. A key part of the wider network that supports people being released from custody is referrals to supervised overdose prevention facilities, which were highlighted as a key measure in the reduction of harm while someone is going from a supervised setting to being unsupervised. I am cognisant of the Glasgow pilot on such a facility. Can the minister provide an update on progress with that pilot and on the interaction with local custody settings as a mechanism for referring vulnerable people to it?

Angela Constance SNP Almond Valley
link

Mr Sweeney knows of my enthusiasm for safer drug consumption facilities, and we are doing everything possible, within our powers, to leave no stone unturned to achieve the goal of a pilot site in Glasgow.

The short answer is that the Crown Office is now in a position to advise the Lord Advocate. As you know, I cannot speak on behalf of either the Crown Office or the Lord Advocate but, along with our partners in Glasgow, we have done an extensive amount of work on the matter and pursued it to the nth degree. It is not a silver bullet, but it is one piece of the jigsaw and, given the scale of the challenge that we face in Scotland, we need all the bits of the jigsaw.

Paul Sweeney Lab Glasgow
link

I have a small supplementary, convener, if that is okay.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

We have strayed a little bit outwith the terms of the petition that the minister is here to discuss.

Paul Sweeney Lab Glasgow
link

I just wanted to go back to the point about interaction between custody settings and the potential pilot. Will there be a definite link there?

Angela Constance SNP Almond Valley
link

Mr Sweeney’s broader point, whether it is in relation to safer drug consumption facilities or any other service, is about the connectivity between services. To go back to the petition, one of the improvements made by the Elgin custody suite was to put in place systems whereby the local service is informed when people are brought into custody, when they are on an OST prescription, and when they are to be released. The issue that we are all concerned about is what happens while someone is in custody and whether they are getting the medically prescribed treatment to which they are entitled and which should, under no circumstances, be disrupted unless there are exceptional health and safety issues.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

A final thought has occurred to me in relation to the availability of healthcare staff. In the wider political context, we are discussing the pressures on staffing resources. Are you aware of any data or issues with the availability of staff who can ensure that prescribed medicines are safely delivered to those who are in custody when it is appropriate?

Angela Constance SNP Almond Valley
link

On the broad point, health boards and IJBs should monitor that. Through their routine reporting structures, they can and do raise workforce issues with the Government and NHS Scotland.

On the work that I and my drug policy officials are pursuing on the implementation of MAT standards, a financial resource is attached to that implementation. When I spoke to the committee before the summer recess, I said that approximately 100 posts were going to be funded. That figure has increased. To be specific and more helpful, I know that Moray, where Elgin custody centre is, has been successful in recruiting staff to work in and around MAT standards. Similarly, NHS Aberdeenshire has sought a number of staff and has largely been successful with that.

I am not disputing that there are issues with the workforce but there are examples of where those have been overcome, either through additional resource to help with recruitment or through the redesign of services.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Thank you. I have not been ignoring your officials, minister; I just assumed that you would bring them in if you felt that there was anything appropriate that they could add.

Today has been helpful with the issues that we have been exploring with our petitioner. Minister, would you like to say anything further in conclusion?

Angela Constance SNP Almond Valley
link

I appreciate the committee digging into the issue. Because drugs policy can rarely be considered in isolation, the debates in the chamber or during other committee appearances that I have been obliged to make have often been very wide-ranging. It has therefore been useful for me to take a specific issue in a specific locality and bore down into the detail. Thank you for that.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Thank you. That is one of the advantages of the Citizen Participation and Public Petitions Committee. We are taking forward the issues of an individual with a petition rather than bringing forward individual party-political considerations, which sometimes allows us to have a meaningful conversation about the particular issue at hand.

Thank you for your appearance with us this morning.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Members, before I suspend the meeting briefly, are you content that we consider the issues raised by the evidence we have heard this morning at a later date?

Members indicated agreement.

10:08 Meeting suspended.

10:10 On resuming—

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 37
  3. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 55
  4. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 33
  5. 11:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  6. 11:30 New Petitions Petitions · 9
  7. 11:30 New Petitions Petitions · 5
  8. 11:30 New Petitions Petitions · 6
  9. 11:30 New Petitions Petitions · 5
  10. 11:45 New Petitions Petitions · 3
  11. 11:45 New Petitions Petitions · 3
  12. 11:45 New Petitions Petitions · 10

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.