To ask the Scottish Government when it will publish the outcome of both the statutory review of snaring and its additional review, which was considering a potential ban on snaring in Scotland. (S6O-01512)
Official Report · Chamber
Snaring
Portfolio Question Time Rural Affairs and Islands
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Màiri McAllan SNP 4
- Colin Smyth Lab 2
- Rachael Hamilton Con 1
- Christine Grahame SNP 1
- Annabelle Ewing SNP 1
The record
9 contributions
link
We published the outcome of the statutory review of snaring earlier this year on 1 April, and it can be found on the Scottish Government website. As Mr Smyth mentioned, I commissioned a review on the animal welfare aspects of snaring and also the implications of a ban on snaring on land management activities in Scotland. I expect to be able to publish the findings of that review soon, including any decisions made regarding the future of snaring in Scotland.
I note that the recommendations of the review that were published in April seem to implement the recommendations of the previous review in 2017, which have not yet been implemented. I hope that they will be delivered this time.
Can the minister give a clear assurance that, should there be any proposed legislative changes arising from the wider review of snaring—which, of course, I hope will involve a full ban—the timescale for publishing the review and any necessary consultation will allow any proposed changes to be incorporated in the proposed wildlife management (grouse) bill, which is the obvious place for them, rather than having to wait for separate legislation in the future?
link
I am happy to confirm my view that, should my view be that legislative change is needed as a result of the review, that will correlate with that bill and be included therein.
link
NatureScot predicts that the capercaillie will become extinct in the next two to three decades, and the British Trust for Ornithology notes that curlew populations have been rapidly declining over the past two decades. Predation by species such as fox is one of the foremost challenges that are faced by these rare birds, so how does the minister intend to confront biodiversity loss and protect species such as the capercaillie and curlew while her Government systematically dismantles the tools for ethical predator control, such as snaring?
link
On the one hand, I understand why many people instinctively feel that snaring is cruel but, on the other hand, I understand that land managers require access to control methods for legitimate purposes, including conservation, as Rachael Hamilton said. It was for exactly those considerations that I commissioned a review and, as I said to Mr Smyth, I will consider its outcome and publish it shortly.
On 25 November 2021, in answer to my colleague Colin Smyth, you indicated in your ministerial role that the Scottish Government would extend the scope of the snaring review to include a potential outright ban on snaring in Scotland. Is that still on the cards?
link
Yes, it is. The statutory review is, I think, required to take place every five years, although I might be getting the number of years wrong. I commissioned the separate review that Christine Grahame referred to, which went beyond the terms of the statutory review and looked at the potential and impacts of banning snaring in Scotland. That is the review that I hope to publish soon.
Question 6 was not lodged.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 9 Nov 2022 →- Rural Affairs and Islands Questions · 1
- Meat Exports (United Kingdom Regulations) Questions · 6
- Farm Payments (Convicted Criminals) Questions · 4
- Pet-owning Households Questions · 6
- Food and Drink Sector (Impact of Brexit) Questions · 4
- Snaring Questions · 9
- Argyll and Bute (Depopulation) Questions · 10
- Proposed Agriculture Bill Questions · 7
- Health and Social Care Questions · 1
- Advanced Clinical Practitioners (Training) Questions · 7
- Excessive Alcohol Consumption (Impact on National Health Service) Questions · 7
- Long Covid (Support) Questions · 8
- National Treatment Centres (Staffing) Questions · 10
- Rural General Practices Questions · 10
- Forestry (Contribution to Net Zero) Debate · 102
- Business Motions Business motions · 25
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 11
- Petrol and Diesel Prices (Inverclyde) Members’ business · 16
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.