The positions on all three boards are ministerial appointments—ultimately, the decisions are taken by ministers. They are regulated appointments, which means that the recruitment process is subject to the “Code of Practice for Ministerial Appointments to Public Bodies in Scotland” and is overseen by the Commissioner for Ethical Standards in Public life in Scotland. That ensures a degree of impartiality in the process.
The starting point for any of the recruitments is identifying the skill sets that are required on the boards. Those will change over time, depending on the particular challenge that each organisation faces. We will have in place a skills matrix for each of the boards, which we will review to identify the skills that are needed. We recognise that those include a knowledge of island life and that island representation needs to be at the forefront of the board’s consideration. We will use that matrix to identify the number of positions that need to be filled and the particular skills required for the vacancies that have arisen, and we will agree those with the ministers and with the ethical standards commissioner.
In some instances, the ethical standards commissioner asks that there be a representative on the recruitment panel. That is a matter for the commissioner, based on the sensitivity of the recruitment. For example, there was an independent panel member for the recent CMAL recruitment, and there will be one for the forthcoming David MacBrayne Ltd recruitment. The minister will sign off the recruitment panel.
Typically, the recruitment panel has a representative from Transport Scotland on it, who represents ministers as the shareholders’ interest in the recruitment. If it is considered appropriate by the ethical standards commissioner, there is also someone who represents the commissioner’s office, and a third panel member might ensure that there is diversity in the panel and that it contains particular skills and expertise. For example, when we are looking for someone with particular maritime knowledge or other skills, one of the panel members will reflect that requirement, so that we can adequately test it through the recruitment process.
In recent rounds of CMAL recruitment, we have sought to include island representation on the panel so that there is a fair assessment of the candidates’ understanding of issues affecting island life. We have been supported in that process by Malcolm Burr, who is the chief executive officer of Western Isles Council. He has brought a great deal of insight to the assessment of applications and has offered us invaluable advice on improving how we market and increase awareness of the opportunities that exist.
We run the process that is set out by the commissioner’s office. We advertise, we accept applications, we sift the applications and we test at interview. The panel makes recommendations to the minister, who has an opportunity to meet candidates should she wish to do so. Ultimately, it is a ministerial appointment, but those steps and measures are in place to ensure that the process is as transparent and inclusive as possible and to ensure that, although every one of these appointments is unique, there is consistency and transparency in how we appoint.