link
The third item on our agenda is consideration of four public petitions that have been referred to the committee. PE1845 is a petition for an agency to advocate for the healthcare needs of those living in rural Scotland; PE1890 is a petition to find solutions to recruitment and training challenges for rural healthcare in Scotland; PE1915 is a petition to reinstate Caithness County Council and Caithness NHS Board; and PE1924 is a petition to complete an emergency, in-depth review of women’s health services in Caithness and Sutherland.
The Citizen Participation and Public Petitions Committee referred the petitions to our committee after doing its own scrutiny of them, so that they can be considered as part of our work on health inequalities. Colleagues will remember that we did a substantial review of, and inquiry into, health inequalities. The common theme that runs through all the petitions is rural healthcare, which we routinely address in our scrutiny of the health service and which came up as a particular issue during our health inequalities work.
We need to have a discussion about what to do with the petitions. Some of the petitioners have already met the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Social Care, for example—I am talking about the final petition, on an in-depth review of women’s health services. Members will also be aware that the Citizen Participation and Public Petitions Committee has already done some work on the petitions. In fact, we have a member here—David Torrance—who is also on that committee. He might want to tell us about some of the work that has been done.
Before I open up the discussion, there are some options to consider in relation to what we want to do.
The first option is to invite a selection of rural health boards to give evidence on the issues raised in the petitions and to follow that up with either a letter to, or a session with, the cabinet secretary. Obviously, that option will take the most time, and we need to decide whether we have time for that. We will not be able to do that this side of Christmas, because our scrutiny of the National Care Service (Scotland) Bill will take up all our time right up until Christmas.
The second option is to proceed directly to inviting the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Social Care to give evidence on the issues raised in the petitions, given that a lot of evidence has already been taken and we have already done quite a lot of our own scrutiny of rural healthcare in our equalities work. I should point out that the cabinet secretary has already spoken to the Citizen Participation and Public Petitions Committee about the issues that are raised in the petitions.
The third option is to take evidence via correspondence. We could write to rural health boards and the cabinet secretary to seek evidence on the issues.
The fourth option is to close some or all of the petitions.
It would be really helpful to hear from David Torrance about some of the scrutiny work that the Citizen Participation and Public Petitions Committee has already done. This is not revenge for him passing the petitions on to us. I genuinely want to know what level of scrutiny there was at that committee.


