Thank you, convener.
The Procurement Bill is intended to reform the regulation of public procurement, primarily in the rest of the UK. The UK Government is keen to present it as a Brexit opportunity, but that ignores the fact that in Scotland we were able to reform public procurement while being a member of the European Union. The Procurement Reform (Scotland) Act 2014 placed a sustainable procurement duty on authorities to consider the economic, social and environmental wellbeing impact of a procurement exercise in their area. It increased transparency by requiring contracts to be advertised on one single portal and requiring that authorities publish a pipeline of expected contracts. The act also contained measures on community benefits, reporting and contracts for health and social care, all of which is compliant with EU rules.
Where the UK bill is most noticeably doing something different is in introducing new flexibility for buyers to design procurement procedures. It says that that will allow for a more responsive procurement system but will also mean that companies will potentially come across a new way of doing things every single time they bid, which will be different again from how contracts are awarded in the EU. We do not share the UK Government’s enthusiasm for dumping EU rules for the sake of being seen to do something. For the most part, therefore, the bill will have no practical effect in Scotland.
There are three specific ways in which the bill engages with the LCM process, however. First, it seeks to regulate the procurement activities of reserved and cross-border bodies operating in Scotland. That mirrors the approach to scope and extent in the Procurement Reform (Scotland) Act 2014, which excludes bodies exercising reserved functions, meaning that they are not covered by the sustainable procurement duty, for example. To that end, it is not unreasonable for them to be subject to this bill, but at present I cannot recommend that the Parliament consents to that, given the concerns that we have with other parts of the bill.
The second area in which the bill touches on devolved competence is cross-border procurement. Frameworks or similar agreements that are awarded under the new UK rules will not be compliant with the Scottish rules and devolved authorities in Scotland would not be able to use those arrangements. Similarly, UK bodies would not be able to use arrangements that are put in place under the Scottish rules. That is a practical issue that needs to be addressed, because buyers from both sides of the border co-operate with each other when it makes sense to do so.
The way in which the issue is addressed in the bill is unacceptable, however. The bill creates powers to address the issue through secondary legislation. Some of those are in devolved areas and are conferred on UK ministers without any requirement to secure the consent of the Scottish ministers before exercise. They are drafted very broadly, including a provision that would allow UK ministers to modify an act of the Scottish Parliament.
Finally, the third area in which the Procurement Bill touches on devolved competence is a power to implement international agreements relating to procurement. We agree that such a power is necessary. However, the power as presented is too broad and is conferred concurrently on UK and Scottish ministers with no requirement on UK ministers to secure the consent of the Scottish ministers before its exercise in devolved matters. There is no justification for that and I cannot recommend consenting to it.
It is a matter of regret that the UK Government did not engage with us more fully in the drafting of those elements of the Procurement Bill in order to arrive at a proposition that was acceptable. Had it done so, we could potentially have recommended consent. We remain in discussions with the UK Government about its plans and I hope that we may be able to secure some improvements, particularly on the practical issue of cross-border procurement, but we are not there yet. Therefore, for now I cannot recommend consent to the bill as it stands.