Thank you for the opportunity to give evidence. It has been an interesting conversation and a lot of the issues have come out this morning.
As we know, the benefits are multiple—they are outlined in the guidance that was issued in 2018. In 2012, I participated in a social return on investment research study in Aberdeen that looked at the benefits of allotments. To pick up on something from the earlier conversation, that showed that, for every £1 that was invested in community growing sites, there was an £8 return.
There is clearly a massive benefit, but undoubtedly there are barriers. We have already had the discussion about finance, both in terms of revenue and capital. Aberdeen City Council spends more on allotments than we make on them, so there is a deficit in our revenue budget. How we manage that and what we do about the pricing of allotments is a decision for politicians, but there is an impact. When we look across all the other things that our grounds services and other services need to do in relation to biodiversity, climate change, land management, engaging communities and so on, we see that it is a multiple and complex problem. The word “maintenance” is raised constantly whenever we talk about what we will do with our land and how we will engage communities on the use of our land.
Then there is the question of capital. There is not a lot of money swilling around for public authorities, and it is diminishing. We can access money from outside, but a lot of that has, rightly, been directed towards investment in relation to climate change and biodiversity and not necessarily food growing opportunities. We face capital and revenue finance issues.
On the other side, we have a limited number of people who can work in the area. Again, that is a revenue budget issue but, as our waiting lists increase, there is a need to manage that process, which then takes away from delivering further allotment sites and supporting communities in delivering those sites. That resource is getting thinner as demand increases. I think that we have one dedicated officer in Aberdeen who works on allotments, and that is a relatively new thing.
There has been a lot of conversation about engaging communities, the community asset transfer process and so on. That is complicated. We need to provide that umbilical cord for communities—I think that that term was used earlier—but that requires resource from our assets teams and community learning and development teams, but they also need to provide that resource in relation to lots of other community issues and not just food growing. There is a complicated process that probably puts off communities from delivering more sites for themselves—there are issues of fear, continuity and so on. A lot of resource goes into supporting communities to bring forward proposals, but it is not always there to hand hold them all the way through the process.
Planning has been mentioned, and more can be done in that regard. It is getting better, and I think that the new local development plans will take a stronger role in protecting and delivering more sites. Certainly in Aberdeen, we are building that into policy. We have built it into developer obligations negotiations, and we need to put more pressure on developers to deliver sites through master planning and site delivery. The new local development plans will help with that process, but there will be a lag before we see delivery on the ground.
There are issues of money, council resources, communities, developers, planners and so on. There are multiple and complex problems.