Like Sally Witcher, I am very pleased to be here. This is my first meeting with the committee.
You will know that the social security system at both United Kingdom and devolved level gives various payments that are designed to support people with the extra costs that they incur as a result of disability. I think that all members will be aware that the disability living allowance was the benefit that was in place for working-age people prior to 2013. At that point, a process began to replace the benefit with the personal independence payment at UK level and, in turn, PIP has now been replaced by the adult disability payment in Scotland.
The Scottish Government’s priority and, indeed, its mantra for the introduction of ADP, as with the other new disability benefits, has been to ensure a safe and secure transition of cases from the Department for Work and Pensions to Social Security Scotland. One of the things that has been central to the safe and secure transition project has been the maintenance of parity in the eligibility criteria for ADP and PIP. We have seen the same thing between the child disability payment and DLA, with the exception of people with terminal illness.
That essentially means that, when people transfer from PIP to ADP, they can easily get the same award without any complex reassessment of their entitlement. Where all that breaks down is that ADP is being introduced before migration from DLA to PIP has been completed. That leaves up to 38,000 adults in Scotland who are still in receipt of DLA. That is quite a significant problem from the point of view of the safe and secure transition, because DLA awards are made on a different basis to PIP awards and are therefore made on a different basis to ADP awards.
I will give a couple of examples of that. Many people have received higher awards when they moved from DLA to PIP because it is possible to receive the enhanced rate of the daily living component of PIP without having any overnight care needs, which is in contrast to DLA. On the other hand, quite a lot of people have lost money at that point of transfer because they are able to walk more than 20m, which rules them out of the enhanced rate of the mobility component of PIP, whereas they could have received the equivalent component of DLA.
Even the structure of the two payments differs. There are three rates of the DLA care component but only two rates of the PIP or ADP daily living component. I know that I am labouring this point a wee bit, but the crucial thing about the regulations is that they are necessary only because there is no simple lift and drop of cases from DLA to ADP in the same way that there is from PIP to ADP.
However, the Scottish Government still wants the migration process to be as seamless as possible. That is essentially why the regulations are drafted to envisage an interim award at the point of transfer being made at the same rate as the individual’s previous DLA award. Only once that has been done and a case has been transferred from DWP to Social Security Scotland will a redetermination be made, within one year, to get the individual on to the rate of ADP that matches up with their impairment and its effect on their mobility and their daily living, as opposed to the rate that matches their previous DLA award.
We said in our report that we think that that approach is broadly sensible. We probed the Scottish Government around its confidence that it has competence within the Social Security (Scotland) Act 2018 to award ADP on the basis of a previous award from the DWP rather than on Social Security Scotland’s evaluation of the individual’s impairment and its effect on their life. We were satisfied with the response that we received.
We suggested that the initial award to people who are transferring from the lowest rate care component of DLA be referred to as a transitional rate award rather than a lowest rate award to emphasise the temporary nature of the award. Ultimately, many of the people who receive that will not receive the daily living component at all, once they have been redetermined. We are pleased that the Scottish Government accepted that recommendation. We are also pleased that people with terminal illnesses are exempt from the two-stage process and will receive their full award from the point of transfer.
A number of issues remain. Although it is not stipulated in the regulations that this is the case, the intention is that, for the time being, the process will be used only to transfer people to ADP if they report a change of circumstances to the DWP or if they request to move.
When we received the Scottish Government’s response to our report a couple of weeks ago, there was still no decision on what the process would be for people who fall outside those groups and who are under 74 years old. That could be the same or it could be something different. We know that people who are over 74—that is, people who were 65 or older in 2013—will be on DLA even after their case transfers to Social Security Scotland, so the regulations will—Inaudible.
10:45
That aside, we are expecting that the issues that arise will probably be more process related rather than to do with the wording of the regulations. There is no getting away from the fact that this will be complex. People will be confused about what is going on. A challenge is trying to make people aware that they might be better off on adult disability payment, bearing in mind that those people have not realised at any point in the past nine years that they might be better off on PIP than they are on DLA, so they have not asked for a transfer up to this point. Will they know that it might be in their interests to ask for a transfer now?
Another challenge is ensuring that people understand that their initial award is temporary, especially those I have already mentioned who move from the lowest rate care component through to the transitional rate of the daily living component of ADP. That forms part of a wider issue about how Social Security Scotland will deal with the fact that, for the first time in its existence, it is facing the prospect of having to reduce or terminate significant numbers of existing awards.
Bearing in mind that the loss of a disability benefit has wider consequences for passported entitlements and, in some cases, for exemption from the benefit cap, that could have a significant impact on people’s lives and it will have to be handled carefully. There are communication challenges ahead, and there are relational challenges ahead for—Inaudible.—users.
We know that a review of ADP is coming and that there could be potential to kick some of those issues down the line by deferring redetermination—Inaudible.—but that is not what the regulations envisage, nor would that approach necessarily be risk free. You might raise expectations that the review would result in certain outcomes that are far from guaranteed. It could also be seen as being unfair to people who have already moved from DLA to PIP and then on to ADP and might have lost money in that process if others were protected from that.
By way of conclusion, moving a relatively small but not insignificant group of people on to ADP was always going to be a much bigger challenge than is the case for those who are already on PIP, no matter how that was approached. We hope that our report has helped to eliminate some of the issues. I am sure that, at the very least, it has eliminated some of the complexity.
As Sally Witcher said, we are happy to take any questions.