Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Remit

Tuesday 26 February 2002 European Committee Committee business 89 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

89 contributions
Irene Oldfather Lab The Convener · Cunninghame South
link

Item 2 on our agenda concerns the committee's external relations remit. A paper has been circulated to members. It is fairly straightforward and outlines the position that we want to encourage the Procedures Committee to take in relation to extending this committee's remit. Members will recall that we discussed at our previous meeting how we could push that along. The clerks have produced a paper, which I hope we will agree to and refer to the Procedures Committee today, which should expedite matters.We have with us Alison Coull, from the Scottish Parliament directorate of legal services, who will be able to answer any questions. However, the paper is fairly straightforward and I hope that we will be able to agree it. It gives effect to our discussion of how formally to extend our remit.

Dennis Canavan Ind Falkirk West
link

I agree in principle with the proposed change to standing orders, which would extend the committee's remit to allow us to deal with broader aspects of external relations rather than only European Union matters. However, I am not sure about the wording for the proposed changes to standing orders. I presume that that wording comes from the Procedures Committee—is that the case?

Irene Oldfather Lab The Convener · Cunninghame South
link

No. The paper was prepared by our clerks and legal advisers. The intention is to forward the paper to the Procedures Committee. Alison Coull, the legal adviser who assisted with the preparation of the paper, is willing to answer any questions.

Dennis Canavan Ind Falkirk West
link

I am not sure that the wording of the proposed changes is ideal. The paper proposes the addition to rule 6.8 of standing orders of a new paragraph 1(d), referring to"the development and implementation of the Scottish Administration's links with Europe and countries outside Europe".First, what is meant by the Scottish Administration? Do we mean the Executive, or do we mean the Executive and the Parliament?Secondly, on links with countries that are outside Europe, it is almost as if we are relegating those countries to an inferior status. If we are to draw a distinction between our existing role and our proposed extended role, that distinction should not be between European countries and countries that are outside Europe. Surely the distinction should be based on the European Union, because there is a difference between countries that are in the European Union and those that are in Europe. I hope that I am not being pedantic in commenting on those matters. I would prefer us to develop and implement the links that the Scottish Executive and the Scottish Parliament have with the European Union and the rest of the world.

Irene Oldfather Lab The Convener · Cunninghame South
link

I call Lloyd Quinan, followed by Colin Campbell then John Home Robertson.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

Colin Campbell had his hand up before I did.

Colin Campbell SNP West of Scotland
link

To talk about countries in Europe—or the European Union—and the rest of the world does not at first seem to be prescriptive, but what about international organisations? Are we entitled to, or do we wish, to foster relationships with international organisations per se?

Colin Campbell SNP West of Scotland
link

As it happens, I was not thinking of NATO in particular. Can we talk directly to the World Health Organisation, the United Nations or the European football association, or whatever it might be called? I draw a distinction between such organisations and nations or countries.

Irene Oldfather Lab The Convener · Cunninghame South
link

I will let other members make their points before we ask the legal adviser for guidance.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

I share Dennis Canavan's reservations. I also share Colin Campbell's concern that the word "countries" seems prescriptive—I would prefer to use the word "structures", unless there is an agreement or concordat between the committee and the Executive that clearly lays out what is meant by "countries". That is an important point, because we need to deal with pan-national structures as well as countries.

Irene Oldfather Lab The Convener · Cunninghame South
link

It is important that we do not stray into reserved matters. However, I accept the points that colleagues have made about the limited definition and about the use of the term "Scottish Administration". I will ask the legal adviser about that in a moment.

John Home Robertson Lab East Lothian
link

The convener has just raised the point about which I was worried when I first read the document. What does the term "Scottish Administration" mean? Does it refer to the Executive or to the Parliament, or to both? That should be made clear.I am not really bothered about the references to countries and whether they are inside or outside Europe. I presume that "countries" is a collective term that could mean any collection of countries. I would have thought that, under that definition, we would be able to look at the Executive's discussions with international organisations. However, we need legal guidance on that point.

Alison Coull Scottish Parliament Directorate of Legal Services
link

I will try to deal with all the points that have been raised, starting with those on the reference to "Scottish Administration".The standing orders are drafted on the basis that the committee would scrutinise the Executive's role in international relations, rather than scrutinise any role that the Parliament might have in that area. "Scottish Administration" is the legal term that covers the Scottish Executive's ministers and civil servants. The term "Executive" is often used to cover civil servants and ministers but, under the Scotland Act 1998, the correct term is "Scottish Administration". That is reflected in the Parliament's standing orders, which talk about committees having the power to scrutinise any aspect of the Scottish Administration's policy. Therefore, the legal point to note is that that definition covers the Executive's ministers and the civil servants.

Alison Coull Scottish Parliament Directorate of Legal Services
link

Yes.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

When is the Parliament's international relations work scrutinised and by whom, if that is not done by the European Committee?

Dennis Canavan Ind Falkirk West
link

The issue is interesting. I am grateful to the legal adviser for telling us the meaning of the term "Scottish Administration". I did not realise that such a distinction was made. I thought that the term "Scottish Executive" covered ministers plus civil servants, but apparently it does not.

Alison Coull Scottish Parliament Directorate of Legal Services
link

Colloquially, the term is used to cover ministers and civil servants.

Dennis Canavan Ind Falkirk West
link

That is interesting. Does it include the Parliament?

Alison Coull Scottish Parliament Directorate of Legal Services
link

No.

Dennis Canavan Ind Falkirk West
link

A department of the Parliament deals with external relations. We will discuss that next week with Paul Grice, the Parliament's chief executive. All sorts of activities are being undertaken. I have complained in the chamber and elsewhere that decisions about the Parliament's external relations with other Parliaments have been taken rather clandestinely, rather than openly and democratically. Important issues of accountability are raised, and I would like the European Committee to have some responsibility for overseeing the work of the external liaison unit of the Parliament and the external relations function of the Scottish Administration.

Irene Oldfather Lab The Convener · Cunninghame South
link

Is there a precedent for parliamentary committees scrutinising Parliament officials?

Irene Oldfather Lab The Convener · Cunninghame South
link

Technically, the external liaison unit is attached to the Presiding Officer. Is that unit really the Presiding Officer's cabinet? Perhaps Stephen Imrie can shed some light on the matter.

Stephen Imrie Clerk
link

In the internal parliamentary structures, the external liaison unit is in the office of the chief executive, who is the Clerk to the Parliament—that is, Paul Grice's office. The unit supports the activities of officials, including the Clerk and people like me, in external relations. It also supports the Presiding Officer and the Deputy Presiding Officers in their functions. The members of that unit are parliamentary officials and not civil servants in the way that the term has been used before.

Irene Oldfather Lab The Convener · Cunninghame South
link

Will Alison Coull shed light on the question that I asked? Is there precedent for parliamentary committees to scrutinise parliamentary officials rather than members of the Executive and civil servants?

Alison Coull Scottish Parliament Directorate of Legal Services
link

I am unaware of any such precedent. The job of the committees tends to be scrutiny of the Scottish Executive's policies.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

The Equal Opportunities Committee has discussed the Parliament's hiring and firing policies. The issue is not whether we will set a precedent, but whether we are performing the functions that are required of proper scrutiny. We have found a gap that requires to be filled. I advise the committee not to consider precedent, because we have discovered an arm of the Administration and of the Parliament that is not being scrutinised.

Irene Oldfather Lab The Convener · Cunninghame South
link

The unit is not an arm of the Administration in the sense of the Scottish Executive, but it is an arm of the Parliament. Is it a parliamentary committee's responsibility to scrutinise another part of the Parliament? I need to take legal advice on that, because I am not sure whether that is our responsibility. Perhaps Alison Coull will assist us.

Alison Coull Scottish Parliament Directorate of Legal Services
link

I have had a chance to look at standing orders. The Equal Opportunities Committee's remit covers the observance of equal opportunities in the Parliament which, I presume, is why it has considered that. I do not think that any other committee has a role similar to that, so it would be unusual for a committee to undertake such scrutiny. However, the Equal Opportunities Committee has a role in examining the Parliament.

Dennis Canavan Ind Falkirk West
link

Surely it is the case that the servants of the Parliament—the parliamentary officials—are, whether they are in the external liaison unit or any other part of the Parliament's administration, accountable to the Parliament as a whole?

Irene Oldfather Lab The Convener · Cunninghame South
link

I would have thought that they are accountable through the chief executive.

John Home Robertson Lab East Lothian
link

They are accountable also through the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body.

Irene Oldfather Lab The Convener · Cunninghame South
link

Yes, they are accountable through the corporate body as opposed to a parliamentary committee. That is my assumption.

Dennis Canavan Ind Falkirk West
link

The corporate body is, in a sense, a parliamentary committee that is accountable to the Parliament as a whole. The European Committee is a parliamentary committee and we must report to the Parliament as a whole. Our membership is approved by the Parliament as a whole; therefore we are accountable to the Parliament as a whole. I do not see any legal or constitutional difficulty in saying that we should have some responsibility for monitoring the work of the external liaison unit, provided that whatever we report is put to the Parliament as a whole for approval or otherwise.

Irene Oldfather Lab The Convener · Cunninghame South
link

We are straying into technical issues about the chief executive's role in controlling his staff and relaying matters back to the special corporate body.

Sarah Boyack Lab Edinburgh Central
link

The matter is not mentioned in the brief because the ambit of the brief is a change to standing orders in the light of the new external affairs remit, first for Jack McConnell and now for Jim Wallace. The remit was a first. We are getting into thinking about how to make different parliamentary officials accountable. It is not really the officials that Dennis Canavan seeks to make accountable, but the work of the Parliament. There is an issue about how the Presiding Officer exercises his functions. Dennis Canavan is shaking his head, but we have discussed the matter before, when Dennis brought it up. We have a choice. If we want to go down the route that Dennis suggests, we will have to discuss the matter for another couple of months, because we could not make the decision unilaterally at this meeting.The drafting of the remit meets our broad requirements. Dennis Canavan raised a wider point about how Parliament works, which came up in the Commonwealth Parliamentary Association meeting before Christmas. That is a different issue from scrutiny of the Administration.

Irene Oldfather Lab The Convener · Cunninghame South
link

The matter is for the Procedures Committee. We are expressing an opinion. We asked for the briefing paper so that we could push things along by agreeing the committee's position and sending a statement of that position to the Procedures Committee. I want to push on with that because, otherwise, we will have to reopen the whole issue. I would rather agree today to extend our remit to take on the role that we originally wanted to extend it to include, which is scrutiny of the Executive.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

When we find that there are gaps and spaces we should not rush into doing things just because we want to get on with them. I do not agree that we would be setting a precedent. The change to the Equal Opportunities Committee's remit was based on its recognition that it could not carry out its functions if it ignored equal opportunities issues within the Parliament and its structures. We have discovered exactly the same hole.The matter has nothing to do with the responsibilities of the chief executive. The chief executive has responsibility for the external liaison unit on a purely mechanistic managerial basis. The external liaison unit involves itself in a great number of things on behalf of the Parliament—that means on behalf of us—but there is no scrutiny of it.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

I have not finished.Rather than simply going along with what we currently have for the sake of time—by which we are not hugely pressured—it is vital that we get things right. We are in the first session of the Parliament and there is an unquestionable requirement for scrutiny.

John Home Robertson Lab East Lothian
link

Dennis Canavan raised a fair point about ensuring that there is scrutiny and co-ordination of external decisions by the Parliament or on behalf of the Parliament by the Executive or the external liaison unit. However, we are dealing with a separate area. The draft amendment is intended to give the committee the authority to scrutinise matters beyond the external affairs element of the minister's functions as he described them to us. That seems logical.We are still waiting for a reply from our legal adviser on a question that we raised about whether the term "countries" includes international organisations. I assume that it does.

Alison Coull Scottish Parliament Directorate of Legal Services
link

Yes. I think that the point was summed up at the beginning of the discussion. The definition is wide enough to cover groups of individual countries.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

What is the definition of "countries"? Scotland is a country. That may sound pedantic, but the issue is important. It is all very well to talk about countries, but many people do not recognise countries.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

What definition are we using? Is a country defined by the people who live in a geographical area or by people who wish to live in a geographical area? Is a country a member of the United Nations? We should remember that this is a legal matter and a decision will be binding.

Alison Coull Scottish Parliament Directorate of Legal Services
link

I think that the intention is for a fairly flexible interpretation of what a country is. The standing orders are a legal document, but they are not in the same category as legislation. They are internal working rules for the Parliament. In general, a purposive interpretation would be given to them. If the committee has specific concerns about how the term "countries" is determined, I am happy to go away and reconsider the matter in the drafting.

Sarah Boyack Lab Edinburgh Central
link

When we are scrutinising work, it is up to us to decide what we think countries are—that is a reasonable way of operating. We should either accept the proposed changes and ask further questions about who will scrutinise external affairs work, as exercised by the Presiding Officer, or kick everything into touch and reconsider the matter. We do not have much of a choice. I raised the issue of timing because, at the previous two meetings, members have been anxious to get on with scrutinising work in the Executive's external affairs remit.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

We have talked about the matter for about a year and have waited for proposals for at least eight months.

Sarah Boyack Lab Edinburgh Central
link

That is precisely why I raised the point.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

That is fine for you. We have dealt with the matter for quite a long time and I am not prepared to go along with something that does not satisfy the many hours of discussion that we have had in the past year.

Irene Oldfather Lab The Convener · Cunninghame South
link

To be fair, we have not discussed scrutinising the Parliament's external affairs remit—that is new. We have discussed scrutinising the Executive. It is valid to raise the matter and consider where the scrutiny function of the external affairs arm of the Parliament should lie. That is right and proper.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

At the beginning of the discussion, three people at the table did not even know who was running the unit or that we had one.

Irene Oldfather Lab The Convener · Cunninghame South
link

It is right and proper for Dennis Canavan to raise the issue and that we should discuss it. Do we want to return the paper? There is an assumption, given that we are meeting the chief executive next week—

Irene Oldfather Lab The Convener · Cunninghame South
link

On 20 March. There is an informal assumption that the committee will have a monitoring role. I think that the unit is happy to report to us and enter into dialogue with us. I do not see anything that would necessarily preclude us from continuing that scrutiny or monitoring of the external liaison unit informally. We have already arranged a meeting on that. I would be happy for that to continue informally, but do we want to send back the paper and change it?

Dennis Canavan Ind Falkirk West
link

Would there be strong opposition from other quarters within the Parliament if we were to suggest the addition of the proposed paragraph 1(f) to rule 6.8 of the standing orders? That would include the monitoring and co-ordination of the international activities of the external liaison unit of the Scottish Parliament. We could put that down as a marker, as we will discuss the matter with Paul Grice on 20 March. If in the light of that discussion the committee feels that there would be strong resistance to an additional paragraph and that insistence on its inclusion would delay the implementation of the rest of the changes to the standing orders, we might decide to withdraw the proposed amendment or not proceed with it at that point. We could perhaps keep it on the back burner for a future occasion.

Irene Oldfather Lab The Convener · Cunninghame South
link

That might offer some possibilities.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

As Dennis Canavan said, we have talked in black and white about having to send back the paper. We are talking about a proposed amendment to the standing orders; we can amend the amendment without sending back the entire paper. What Dennis Canavan suggested makes an awful lot of sense. If we are going to go down that road, can we consider the content of paragraphs 1(d) and 1(e) and get back to what we discussed originally—the development and implementation of the Scottish Administration's links with Europe and countries outside Europe? Will we consider the structures of that? I wish that I had your faith in the informal structures with which I have had no contact but of which you seem to be aware, convener. That is all very well at the moment, but we are setting precedents for others.

Irene Oldfather Lab The Convener · Cunninghame South
link

We are developing as we go along and I think that we are taking positive steps. We are bringing in the chief executive to discuss external affairs for the first time in the two and half years in which the committee has been operating. That is a positive development.I turn back to the matter in hand, which is the paper before us. Dennis Canavan has suggested that we add a paragraph to the standing orders. We had hoped that we could agree the paper today, finalise it and send it to the Procedures Committee. At our previous meeting, members were anxious that we should progress quickly. There is no question about that, but we have raised a point that requires clarification. I would not be averse to adding a sentence that refers to the Parliament's external liaison unit, sending the paper to the Procedures Committee and having further discussions next week.

John Home Robertson Lab East Lothian
link

We could have discussions about the drafting with the Presiding Officer and the chief executive. I am quite comfortable with what has been proposed; it is sensible.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

Why is the committee seeking the right to scrutinise? Do we wish to enter into discussions? I do not understand.

Irene Oldfather Lab The Convener · Cunninghame South
link

My view is that we have a role to scrutinise the Executive and civil servants. We have opened up a new discussion today about whether we have a role in scrutinising parliamentary employees. We might well do.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

The issue is the same for the Equal Opportunities Committee. The Rural Development Committee does not have to scrutinise parliamentary employees because, as far as I know, no one is farming on the roof of the building. However, the Equal Opportunities Committee had to consider the processes for hiring and firing people and the way in which we treat staff. In exactly the same way, we have discovered that an area that is part of our potential remit is not being scrutinised.

Irene Oldfather Lab The Convener · Cunninghame South
link

The matter is ultimately for the Procedures Committee to decide.

Irene Oldfather Lab The Convener · Cunninghame South
link

We can reflect our discussion today by adding a sentence referring to the external liaison unit of the Scottish Parliament and we can enter into further discussion with the Procedures Committee and the chief executive. I would like to have a clearer understanding of the legal situation on whether committees can undertake that sort of scrutiny of parliamentary employees.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

The Equal Opportunities Committee does that because it fits in its remit.

Irene Oldfather Lab The Convener · Cunninghame South
link

That is a policy issue, however; it is a wee bit different.

Sarah Boyack Lab Edinburgh Central
link

Perhaps it would be better to use the phrase "the external relations work of the Parliament", which sounds like the framework that is used on the equal opportunities side. It would refer both to the external liaison unit and to the general work of the Parliament in external relations. We need to think about the terminology. I would prefer a wider, catch-all phrase.

Dennis Canavan Ind Falkirk West
link

I agree. That is why I suggested that the additional paragraph should read "monitoring and co-ordinating the international activities of the Scottish Parliament". We might want to add "and its external liaison unit" to make the wording all embracing.

John Home Robertson Lab East Lothian
link

I anticipate difficulties with the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body, although I do not disagree with anything that has been said in the discussion.

Colin Campbell SNP West of Scotland
link

We all agree. We have brought the subject up—let the SPCB kick it about for a bit.

Irene Oldfather Lab The Convener · Cunninghame South
link

I am concerned about whether a parliamentary committee is entitled to scrutinise activities of the Parliament. As Colin Campbell says, we have uncovered something that needs consideration. However, I think that we should proceed with caution.

Alison Coull Scottish Parliament Directorate of Legal Services
link

The issue is new. The proposed new standing orders were drafted on the basis of the committee's discussion about scrutinising the affairs of the Executive. I would want to consider the wording of any suggested additional paragraph in detail. I would like to be clear about any legal implications arising from adding the point about scrutiny. I would have to take it away and think about it.

Irene Oldfather Lab The Convener · Cunninghame South
link

That is only fair. Does the committee agree that Alison Coull should take on board the comments that have been made today, with the proviso that we inform the Procedures Committee of our discussion and of Dennis Canavan's suggested amendment and that we need to investigate the legal implications?Members indicated agreement.

Colin Campbell SNP West of Scotland
link

This is really pedantic, but it stems from the fact that I am on the Subordinate Legislation Committee. Could we include a footnote directing people to a definition of "Scottish Administration"? If the revised standing orders go out to the rest of the world as they are, they will raise questions.

Alison Coull Scottish Parliament Directorate of Legal Services
link

Standing orders have tended not to include footnotes of the sort that are included in statutory instruments. However, there is a case for giving an explanation in a commentary with the standing orders.

  1. Scottish Parliament European Committee Tuesday 26 February 2002 (Afternoon) Committee business · 1
  2. Item in Private Procedure · 4
  3. Remit Committee business · 89
  4. Ozone Depletion (EC Regulation 2037/2000) Committee business · 3
  5. Petition Petitions · 15
  6. Convener's Report Procedure · 27
  7. Scrutiny Committee business · 12

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.