The Scottish Conservatives have repeatedly called for John Swinney to come to Parliament and face scrutiny on the crucial role that he has played in the shambolic ferry contracts. Every time that we have requested—[Interruption.] Scottish National Party back benchers do not seem to like this, but just imagine—[Interruption.]
Official Report · Chamber
Ferries (Construction Contract)
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Douglas Ross Con 9
- John Swinney SNP 9
- Alison Johnstone 8
The record
26 contributionsMembers! We are just beginning this session of First Minister’s question time, and I would be very grateful if we could hear the question.
Every time that we have asked for a statement, every SNP back bencher and John Swinney have voted against him coming to the Parliament. However, today, he cannot avoid the questions to which islanders and Scottish taxpayers need answers.
John Swinney signed off the ferry contracts that have, so far, cost £250 million and denied islanders the ferries that they need. Will the Deputy First Minister finally tell the Scottish public why he signed off the deals?
First, I note that I am answering questions today because the First Minister is still unwell with Covid. For many obvious reasons, I wish her a very speedy recovery. [Applause.]
I do not think that Douglas Ross is in the strongest position to question my engagement with the Parliament on key issues, because I gave a statement earlier this week, I answered questions last week and I handled a bill the week before. Unlike some Tory MSPs, you will not find me skiving off to the football for a few days when the Parliament is sitting. [Interruption.]
Members! We will have quiet, please.
As a minister, I carry collective responsibilities for the actions of the Scottish Government. The responsibility for agreeing contracts lies with individual portfolios—in this scenario, with transport. My role was to provide the necessary budget for building the ferries. After the final decision was taken, officials briefed me about the contract being awarded and assured me, on the basis of the contract, that the budget that I had approved in August 2015 did not require to be changed.
I know that the Deputy First Minister does not do this very often, but he spoke about a statement that he gave to Parliament and a bill that he took through Parliament, and neither of those has anything to do with ferries, which is what this Parliament has asked to hear from him about. On every occasion, John Swinney has not just refused to speak but voted against himself giving a statement to Parliament.
John Swinney’s fingerprints are all over the deal. Emails show that the Deputy First Minister confirmed that there were “no banana skins”. He was on calls with finance officials, who said that Mr Swinney “now understands the background”. His approval was essential. The contract was only “clear to award” after he signed it off, according to Scottish Government emails.
John Swinney charged ahead despite ferry experts warning against the contract, and despite legal advice that the SNP originally tried to cover up but could not redact properly, warning of the high risk of the contract being challenged and ruled ineffective. The SNP charged ahead despite the contract missing a key safeguard that is an industry standard, and despite the fact that the jobs at Ferguson were already safe and the yard had other options for work. [Interruption.]
Members! We simply are not going to shout from a sedentary position.
Mr Ross, please continue.
That just shows how SNP members want to push this under the carpet and for it all to go away. They do not want scrutiny over the quarter of a billion pounds that has been spent without a single ferry that the islanders were promised being produced.
The Government charged ahead, despite there being no agreed design for the ferries, and despite the fact that the Ferguson bid was the most expensive of them all. Can the Deputy First Minister explain to people across Scotland why he approved those deals despite all the evidence that suggested he should not?
I made it clear in my first answer that I carry collective responsibility for the actions of the Government. I therefore accept that those decisions were taken by the Government, but they were taken individually by the transport minister.
I will give Douglas Ross the benefit of the note that he has quoted from, which was from a senior finance official. It said:
“Just finished my call with DFM. He now understands the background and that Mr McKay has cleared the proposal.”
That is the complete sentence that Douglas Ross is missing. The decision had been taken, and I was being briefed that there was no change to the budget that I had already sanctioned. Why is that answer not good enough for Douglas Ross? He has been given that answer on countless occasions.
As for his points about the Government not wishing to undergo scrutiny on this issue, it was looked at by a parliamentary committee, by Audit Scotland and by another parliamentary committee, and it has been the subject of a range of questions at question time. When Douglas Ross looks at all the papers, he will see that the contract arrangement demonstrates that the Government was taking action to deliver ferries for the island communities that require them, and we were taking decisions to protect employment on the lower Clyde. That is a record that this Government is determined to defend.
The Government would have to be pretty determined to defend a record that has not built any ferries and that has left islanders without ferries.
Honest John has missed the second sentence—
Mr Ross, we will desist from using nicknames in the chamber. We will call people by their first names and surnames.
Sorry.
John Swinney read out a sentence from an email, but he refused to read the second sentence, and I wonder why. The second sentence says:
“So the way is clear to award.”
That is the conclusion of the email that reveals the Deputy First Minister’s involvement. It was escalated to the Deputy First Minister on 9 October 2015 at 17:15—[Interruption.]
SNP members do not want to hear this, but the email saying that the way to award was clear was sent only after the matter had gone to John Swinney.
Why did the SNP really sign off on this deal? It was not to save jobs, because we know that the jobs were safe. It was not the cheapest deal for taxpayers; it was actually the most expensive. It was not the most secure contract; it was the most risky. It was not backed by experts; they warned the Deputy First Minister and others against it. However, against overwhelming evidence, John Swinney signed off the deal anyway.
It seems obvious to everyone what happened here. The Scottish National Party wanted the political praise for keeping the yard open ahead of an election, so it ignored all the alarm bells. It looks an awful lot like the SNP made a dodgy deal, and now it is trying to cover that up. Can the Deputy First Minister—[Interruption.]
Can we please hear Mr Ross’s question?
The Deputy First Minister is trying to listen, despite some of the comment behind him. Can he really tell the public that there was no political motive behind the award of the contract?
There was no political motive behind the contract. The objective of the Government was to ensure that the ferries that were required would be built, and that is what we are concentrating on achieving. We were also determined to ensure that employment on the lower Clyde was supported with contracts from the CalMac Ferries network. For Mr Ross to say that, somehow, the yard could stay open without any contracts is for him to deny the physical reality of the way in which a yard would be run.
I point out to Mr Ross that Audit Scotland went through the procurement process and indicated that that process, which resulted in Ferguson’s becoming the preferred bidder, was entirely standard. On that basis, the transport minister took the decision to award the contract, and, as the note says about me,
“He now understands the background and that Mr McKay has cleared the proposal.”
Read the next sentence.
Mr Ross is trying to invent something else. What I have explained to Parliament, consistent with my—[Interruption.]
There continues to be quite a lot of heckling, and I would be very grateful if members could resist the temptation to do so, as I would very much like to hear the Deputy First Minister.
Consistent with my obligation under the ministerial code of conduct to give truthful answers to Parliament, I am making it clear to Parliament that the memo that Mr Ross has quoted from was simply recording the fact that I had been briefed about a decision that another minister had taken and that, therefore, the way was clear to award the contract, because I had been briefed, the budget was in place and Mr Mackay’s decision could stand.
Douglas Ross can go around smearing and inventing all the information that he wants, but the people of Scotland will see through his grubby tactics today.
What the people of Scotland can see is that quarter of a billion pounds of taxpayers’ money has been spent on two ferries that have so far not sailed, which were promised by the Government to the islanders who desperately need them for their connectivity. For the Deputy First Minister to respond in the way that he has done undermines what those communities need right now.
It seems that the ferry deal was the best deal for the SNP, not the best deal for Scotland, and that ScotRail is going the same way for commuters as the ferry deal has gone for islanders. Just a month after the Deputy First Minister’s SNP Government took control of our railways, one in three train services has been cut.
Earlier this week, in a rare move, business groups, including the Scottish Tourism Alliance, Scottish Financial Enterprise, the Scottish Chambers of Commerce, the Scottish Retail Consortium and the Institute of Directors, united to warn of the harsh impact that their members face as a result of the ScotRail cuts. Delays, last-minute cancellations and service reductions are causing real problems for passengers across the country.
Next week, our national men’s team will play its biggest match for more than two decades. The tartan army will need to get to and from Hampden on ScotRail. Will the Deputy First Minister’s Government have got a grip of the situation by then? If not, when can people expect to have the rail service that they need?
When we look at the specific questions that Douglas Ross has put to me on the Ferguson’s issue, it is abundantly clear why a statement by me to Parliament was unnecessary, because he had nothing of any substance whatsoever to put to me.
I have been a member of the Parliament for a long time. The assessment has often been made that, when a political leader changes the topic of their question during First Minister’s questions, that is an indication that they are in trouble. That is exactly where Douglas Ross is.
Mr Ross knows full well—[Interruption.]
Members! Please continue, Deputy First Minister. People are following the proceedings and would like to hear them.
Mr Ross knows full well that negotiations are under way between the employer—ScotRail—and the trade unions to resolve the industrial dispute that is limiting services. That dialogue is under way, as it should be.
He asks about the Ukraine match. We obviously want more services to be in place to deal with the Ukraine match. I am confident that ScotRail will have additional services in place to ensure that the specific requirements of access to Hampden will be addressed. Announcements will be made about that in due course.
I suspect—[Interruption.]
Mr Ross!
I suspect that the degree of agitation from Mr Ross today is an indication of the depth of the trouble that he is in. I do not think that anything that I say today will satisfy Mr Ross. He is going to doubt what I say and question my integrity. I am giving Parliament honest answers, which is more than can be said for the Prime Minister, Boris Johnson, who Douglas Ross is prepared to support.
In this meeting
Everything on 26 May 2022 →- General Question Time Questions · 1
- Women’s Safety (Public Transport) Questions · 4
- ScotRail (Proposed Cuts) Questions · 12
- Rail Services (Driver Shortages) Questions · 4
- Childcare Sector Omicron Impacts Fund Questions · 4
- ScotRail Services (Cowdenbeath) Questions · 4
- Economic Development (North-east Scotland) Questions · 4
- Transmission Network Use of System Charges (Increase) Questions · 4
- Ferries (Construction Contract) First Minister’s Questions · 26
- Rail Services First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Falklands War First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Census 2022 First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Nursing and Midwifery (Staffing) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Electricity Bill (E.ON Energy) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Bariatric Surgery First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Fornethy House Residential School (Survivors Campaign) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Scottish Bus Week First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Food and Drink Prices and Shortages First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Waste Burning First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Cost of Living First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Falkland Islands Members’ business · 19
- Constitution, External Affairs and Culture Questions · 1
- Scotland’s Census 2022 Questions · 6
- Listed Buildings (Consultation) Questions · 6
- Northern Ireland Protocol Questions · 7
- Ukrainian Refugees (Settlement) Questions · 4
- Ukrainian Refugees (Services) Questions · 6
- Ukrainian Refugees (Welcome Hubs) Questions · 6
- Ukrainian Refugees (Risk to Female Refugees) Questions · 5
- Drug Deaths Statement · 29
- Social Security Benefits Debate · 99
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 18
- Correction Procedure · 1
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.