Thank you, convener, and I thank the committee for the opportunity to give evidence on a second piece of NDR legislation today.
The Scottish Government is keen to ensure that non-domestic property valuations are better understood by ratepayers. The draft instrument that we are considering increases accountability in the non-domestic rates system ahead of the 2023 revaluation.
The Barclay review of non-domestic rates called for assessors to provide more information to property owners and occupiers when making rateable value calculations. The Barclay implementation appeals sub-group, which is an expert group that was set up to inform and advise Scottish ministers in respect of NDR reforms to the appeals system, specifically recommended that assessors should provide, alongside property valuations, the addresses of let properties, the rental evidence on which was used to inform the calculation of the basic rate to be applied to the property.
It proposed that four categories of property be covered in the first instance—standard shops, offices, warehouses and workshops—and that the list be expanded in the future.
We consulted on a draft instrument that sought to require that assessors provide that information in draft and final valuation notices in respect of revaluation. On one hand, some responses called for the proposed information-sharing requirements on the assessor to be expanded to more property types, or to more valuation methodologies. On the other hand, some raised a concern that, if the requirements were expanded, confidential and commercially sensitive information such as trading accounts or lease details could potentially be provided to third parties.
We considered that concern and, as a result, this draft instrument goes beyond the appeals sub-group’s recommendation. It requires that, for 32 categories of property that are valued using the comparative method and a basic valuation rate, the assessor must provide the addresses of comparable properties used to calculate that rate and state where that information can be accessed. Requiring that a list of addresses be produced only where two or more properties have been used for comparison for the valuation will avoid the risk that commercially sensitive information can be worked out indirectly.
I believe that our response to the consultation demonstrates our commitment to greater accountability in the rates system while ensuring that our reforms do not place an unrealistic burden on assessors. I hope that members will welcome that, given the points that the committee raised about assessor workload in its stage 1 report on the Non-Domestic Rates (Coronavirus) (Scotland) Bill.
We remain committed to greater accountability in the rates system and will explore how to expand on the information-sharing requirements in advance of the 2026 revaluation.
The draft instrument also contributes to modernising the NDR system by allowing for draft valuation notices to be sent electronically where that has been requested by the owner or occupier and has been agreed in writing between the assessor and owner or occupier.
I hope that members will support the draft instrument.