One of the main issues that we have a concern about is children’s access to justice and the right of children to an effective remedy and to challenge such decisions—to challenge their being removed from their families and, as is often the case, placed many hundreds of miles away, in an entirely different system, and then being deprived of their liberty and having to face all the rights restrictions that happen there.
There is nothing in the regulations that we consider would be good enough to allow such children to challenge that, so it is immaterial whether the Scottish ministers would seek to uphold the commitment made by the placing authority from England. I think that there is a real difficulty as regards the rule of law with the Scottish ministers taking public authorities in England to court. We might enter into a bit of a debate about constitutional law on that particular remedy. It is the absolute absence of the child’s voice in any of this that is of most significant concern.
A lot more must be done. The regulations are not good enough, as Nick Hobbs said. It is absolutely the case that the minimum standards need to be achieved. Scotland has incorporated the UNCRC into its law, so we should at least be taking the maximalist approach that we can take on rights protections in the regulations. We should not be making new law that allows children’s rights to suffer in this way, and that is our principal argument against the regulations as they stand.
Many concerns have been expressed across the legal profession on remedies and so on, and the Supreme Court raised an interesting and important point. Such placements are inadequate, but they are happening and children are being exported out of England into Scotland. That is not being done through our system. There is a mechanism whereby it could be done through our system, but English authorities are choosing not to use that mechanism; they are choosing to do it through the inherent jurisdiction of the High Court. Such placements are happening because of the lack of suitable placements in England. Scotland will be able to provide a better care service for English children, but it must be the same better care service that our Scottish children are entitled to.
There must be parity, and the regulations and the process and procedure of what has been happening for two and a half years give no parity or consistency for such children from England, who are being discriminated against. There needs to be a much more robust understanding of the fact that the child must be involved in the decision-making processes. Although we are aware that cases have gone to the Court of Session to have the authorisation from the English High Court, many cases have not been taken to the Court of Session. In that sense, the regulations would prevent an incentive if you want such placements to continue.
We must remember that many of the children are placed before any legal action is taken, without any planning. Many of them are placed on an emergency basis. The difficulty that we have seen with the Court of Session cases is that no children have been represented since the initial case. No child is represented in the court, so the court does not hear the voice of the child. That cannot be right when we are incorporating the UNCRC into Scots law. The rights to an effective remedy and to participation are probably fundamental here.