Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Petitions

Literacy Standards (Schools) (PE1668)

Wednesday 4 May 2022 Education, Children and Young People Committee About 11:45 Petitions 12 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

12 contributions
Stephen Kerr Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Our next petition is PE1668, on improving literacy standards in schools through research-informed reading instructions. The petition, which was lodged by Anne Glennie, urges the Scottish Government, first, to provide national guidance, support and professional learning for teachers in research-informed reading instruction—specifically, systematic synthetic phonics—and, secondly, to ensure that teacher training institutions train new teachers in research-informed reading instruction, specifically systematic synthetic phonics.

Our committee papers provide an outline of the action that was taken on the petition during session 5 by the Public Petitions Committee and the Education and Skills Committee. The session 5 Education and Skills Committee was undertaking an inquiry into initial teacher education and the early phase of teaching. Ahead of the formal evidence sessions for its inquiry, the committee agreed to take evidence from the petitioner to allow the broader issues raised by the petition to be explored. It also agreed that the session would include a focus on any issues that could inform the inquiry.

The session, which was set for 18 March 2020, did not take place, as a result of the Covid pandemic, and the committee was unable to restart its inquiry on ITE owing to other work that it undertook on scrutinising the response to the pandemic.

Do members have any comments on the petition?

Kaukab Stewart SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

From an educationalist’s point of view, we need to consider the issue very carefully. Directing methodology and pedagogy is a tricky area. From what I can see, the petition asks us to do that and to go down a certain route. I have taught synthetic phonics for over 30 years, but I have also taught the other methods. At the moment, in initial teacher education, they are trying to use a variety of those approaches. I am not commenting on whether they are doing it well enough.

There are technical flaws to synthetic phonics, because there are issues about pronunciation and how neurodiverse kids come into it. It also does not solve the issue of dyslexia. I wonder whether those issues are all behind that work. Obviously, I was not there during the previous session, but all of those issues have come to me, so, as much as I would love to get stuck into this, I wonder what our role is. Is it our role to direct the way that we teach reading and roll that out? That is what the petition is looking for, and I am not sure that that is our role.

Stephen Kerr Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

I am not sure that politicians should be getting involved in that.

Stephanie Callaghan SNP Uddingston and Bellshill
link

I agree, because mandating local authorities, headteachers and teachers to teach in a specific way is quite concerning. I have neurodiverse children, and having a wider range of options means that we can work with what is best for children as individuals.

Michael Marra Lab North East Scotland
link

I am conscious that we have received some evidence—through the Ken Muir report on initial teacher education and discussions around it—that some forms were put in place almost a generation ago and have been replicated elsewhere, but we have not kept them up to date. I know that we have a full work programme for the next year at least, but, perhaps later in the session, after we have been through the legislative process, the subjects that are dealt with in the petition might be addressed in a future inquiry. That is not on the immediate horizon, but I am sure that it would come up if there was another discussion about initial teacher education. The committee might want to have that discussion at some point, and I certainly think that there would be grounds for doing so.

11:45

Stephen Kerr Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

With regard to the petitioner’s expectations, it is only fair to say that we are not going to get to this specific aspect of education policy any time soon—not within a year, at least—because of the inquiries that we already have under way. You mentioned the Ken Muir report. On top of that, we have a growing number of legislative requirements, which will also take up our time.

Ruth Maguire SNP Cunninghame South
link

Notwithstanding our obvious interest in initial teacher training, the right thing—based on what Kaukab Stewart has laid out—might be to close the petition.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

I will be brief. Michael Marra’s suggestion was about embedding the activity in another body of work or another inquiry that the committee might pursue during the parliamentary session. That is what the previous committee agreed to do, and it found the opportunity to do so. Obviously, however, we do not have that opportunity during this session.

“Never say never” is the point that Mr Marra is making, I suppose, but the convener’s point is about not giving a false expectation that things might happen any time soon. I therefore agree that we should close the petition. However, our knowledge of the wider issues that the petitioner would seek to have raised does not disappear with that closure. If there is another inquiry that we can tack those questions on to, we should do so, by all means. Nevertheless, at this stage, rather than having things drag on without being able to fulfil the petitioner’s expectations, I agree that closure is probably the best thing.

Stephen Kerr Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

I tend to agree with what you have said. I will bring Michael Marra back in, in a minute. To be fair to the petitioner, we are not likely to get to this in the immediate future. As I said, I cannot see over the brow of the hill, but I do not see us getting into that policy area in the work of the committee in the next year at least. I therefore think that the best thing to do is to be completely on the level and say that we should close the petition but that, should we get to the subject of initial teacher education, we would have an institutional memory of the petition and could revisit it at that time.

Michael Marra Lab North East Scotland
link

I am content with that, convener. It sounds like a reasonable approach. The committee is pretty clear.

Stephen Kerr Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Are we content to close the petition?

Members indicated agreement.

  1. 09:30 Scottish Attainment Challenge Inquiry Evidence session · 138
  2. 11:30 Petitions Petitions · 5
  3. 11:45 Petitions Petitions · 12
  4. 11:45 Petitions Petitions · 3
  5. 11:45 Petitions Petitions · 20

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.