Thank you very much for allowing me to come in and support the petition.
The petition was been in existence for a number of years: it was lodged in 2013. We need to keep it live because things have not got any better. I know that constituents of some members who are here are saying the same thing to them.
In 2013, it was estimated that there were around 8,000 greylag geese—those are the Icelandic greylags—across the crofting counties. In Uist alone now, there are 8,000 Icelandic greylag geese, and they are now resident. At one time, they were just passing through, but they have become resident birds now, so they are a problem throughout the year.
Back in 2012, Scottish Natural Heritage, which is now NatureScot, established adaptive management projects. Adaptive management means doing a bit of culling, taking counts, doing a bit more culling and taking counts. That sounds like a very sensible approach but, after five years of a very successful pilot, it was decided not to continue with that. I could never understand the logic of that. Surely that is what a pilot is: something is tested and, if it works, it is done. However, something was tested and it worked, but it was not done.
Every year after the adaptive management schemes were stopped, the budget for control of geese reduced. It went down from just under £50,000 for the whole of the crofting islands—Tiree, Coll, the Uists, Lewis, Harris and Orkney. Just below £50,000 was used for the adaptive management projects, and that amount was reduced every year until it was finally decided in 2021 that no funding at all would go to the control of geese and NatureScot’s role would simply be advisory.
I just do not understand the logic of that. There did not seem to be a plan in place for continuing the control. We went and had a meeting with the minister and expressed our extreme concern about that, because we are at a point where crofters are giving up crofting because of the goose problem. That is not an exaggeration. We have said in the press that geese are protected but crofters are not, that crofters are now an endangered species, and so on.
In the islands, particularly Uist and Tiree, we have a really unique machair environment and a lot of traditional crops—landraces—that are not found anywhere else. The seed is available only on the islands. The minister announced that she would provide up to £50,000 towards goose management in the crofting areas. In her press release, she acknowledged that the machair is a very important environment, yet most of that £50,000 has gone to Orkney, which does not have the same machair. I am certainly not mocking Orkney, which also has a really big problem with greylags. It has about 21,000 birds, whereas Lewis and the Uists have about 8,000 and Tiree has the same sort of number. The Western Isles are getting £6,000 per island to control the birds.
Do tell me to shut up when I have to shut up. I have only a couple more things to say.
In Orkney, they are trialling a thing called corralling, whereby canoeists round up moulting birds, which cannot fly, and then qualified people have to catch them and administer a lethal drug to kill them. The cost of that works out at about £25 per bird. In the Uists and Lewis, we have had a shooting programme that cost about £8 per bird. Again, I am quite surprised by the logic of this.
NatureScot has let the situation get completely out of hand to a point where people are having to use corralling. No lethal method is nice, and of course the public perception is not nice. I add that crofters and the marksmen who do the work really do not like it. However, it is something that we have to do, because keeping the bird numbers down to a tolerable level is the only way that we are going to manage this. The minister said in her interview that she expects crofters and geese to be able to live alongside each other. We agree with that, but it will work only when there are manageable numbers.
It was estimated about five years ago that Uist, which is a good example, could tolerate 2,500 birds. The adaptive management scheme got the numbers down to 4,000 and we were still complaining then, but there are now 8,000 birds. The provision of £6,000 is not even going to make a dent in that. We are going to need £32,000 just to bring the number down to 4,000 by shooting them. I am sorry to throw all these figures at you, but I want to give you an idea of the proportions. I am sure that the Scottish Parliament information centre will have all the figures anyway. We need about £32,000 to bring the numbers down to the threshold of tolerability and we have only £6,000.
I urge you to keep the petition open particularly because, this year, NatureScot carries out its five-yearly review of the management programme. Therefore, it is timely to keep the petition open. We do not ask for the birds to be eradicated; we just ask for them to be reduced to a manageable level.
Thank you very much for hearing my argument.