Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Ancient, Native and Semi-native Woodlands (Protection) (PE1812)

Wednesday 23 March 2022 Citizen Participation and Public Petitions Committee About 09:30–10:15 Petitions 54 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

54 contributions
Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Good morning. I welcome everybody to the fifth meeting in 2022 of the Citizen Participation and Public Petitions Committee. Before we turn to consideration of the petitions that are before us, I note that today is the second anniversary of the first Covid-19 lockdown and is a national day of reflection.

As the Presiding Officer has said, the global pandemic has taken so much from so many. Parliament stands shoulder to shoulder with all those who have suffered, those who are grieving for loved ones, and those whose lives have been changed forever. Throughout the pandemic, we have seen communities respond with care and understanding, which should give us all hope for the future.

Accordingly, we will pause later this morning, at 12 noon, to join in with the minute’s silence. I warn members about that, as we could be at any point in our proceedings, depending on the progress that we have made.

Item 1 is consideration of continued petitions. Petition PE1812, which is on protecting Scotland’s remaining ancient, native and semi-native woodlands and woodland floors, was lodged by Audrey Baird and Fiona Baker on behalf of Help Trees Help Us. We heard from the petitioners in an evidence session a fortnight ago.

The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to deliver world-leading legislation giving Scotland’s remaining fragments of ancient, native and semi-native woodlands and woodland floors full legal protection before the 26th United Nations climate change conference of the parties. Obviously, the petition was lodged before COP26.

When we considered the petition on 9 March, we took evidence from the petitioners and from a range of interested organisations. Today, we will take evidence from Màiri McAllan, who is the Minister for Environment and Land Reform. Welcome, minister. It is nice to have you with us. The minister is joined by Doug Howieson, who is interim head of operational delivery at Scottish Forestry. He has an honorary season ticket to the committee, having participated in the round-table discussion on the petition a fortnight ago.

Jackie Baillie was sadly unable to join us a fortnight ago, but she is joining us remotely today. I will invite her to comment when we have heard what our witnesses have to say.

We will go straight to questions. The round-table session was fascinating, lots of themes emerged from it, and there was a lot of commonality. There were some areas that the committee had not considered quite so much in our earlier review, and the petitioners submitted a comprehensive portfolio of photographs that particularly illustrated the effect of invasive species in our native woodland.

In the most recent progress report on “Scotland’s Biodiversity—a Route Map to 2020”, the targets for native woodland were identified as areas in which “insufficient progress” has been made. People are wondering what the Scottish Government is doing to enhance efforts in that area.

Màiri McAllan SNP The Minister for Environment and Land Reform · Clydesdale
link

It is good to be with you all to discuss this really important topic, as reflected in the number of signatories to the petition. I share their views on the importance of the issue.

I will split your question into two parts. The first relates to our efforts on new woodland creation and the native component of that, and the second is about the actions that we are taking to protect, restore and grow the remaining natural and semi-natural ancient woodlands.

The Scottish Government’s woodland creation objective is to manage our woodlands for the number of co-benefits that they can provide for the country. That spans economic and environmental opportunities, as well as social opportunities. Our challenge is to manage their creation in ways that reflect all those things.

We have ambitious targets for creation that reflect our ambitious climate change targets. We also have targets within that. For example, we had a target that, as a minimum, 3,000 hectares of all woodland planted in Scotland should be native broad-leaved woodland. We have been meeting and exceeding that target and therefore have taken action to increase it. We have moved the floor from a minimum of 3,000 hectares to a minimum of 4,000 hectares.

In our biodiversity strategy, which is currently being worked on, we have committed to look at the evidence, to see whether that target could be more ambitious still. We also carry out other activities. For example, the forestry grant scheme has supported 12,000 hectares of native planting in the past three years. That is about efforts to create, and if we think about—

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Could I ask a question, because that is interesting?

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

The petitioners are concerned about the native content in new forest planting. It is interesting to hear that the Government is seeking to increase the percentage of native trees. What is the balancing act in that? It would be helpful if people could understand why it is not all native. What calculation is made in determining the percentage that can be native species?

Màiri McAllan SNP Clydesdale
link

That is an excellent question, and something that officials and I grapple with all the time. We are in a fortunate position in that woodland can deliver across many objectives, such as carbon sequestration, biodiversity growth and socioeconomic outcomes, including the creation of good jobs in rural areas.

The types of woodland that we create have to be balanced across that. For example, we need to plant fast-growing commercial species, because they provide the greatest opportunity for carbon sequestration, and allow us to prop up the successful timber industry, which supports many jobs in rural Scotland. Then there are the types of trees that support our biodiversity objectives: native broad-leaved trees that will help us to reverse the decline in biodiversity.

There are other objectives that we build into the picture. For example, there is a requirement that 10 per cent of new woodland should be open space. That serves the socioeconomic objective of supporting wellbeing, as it allows people to spend time in forests and to enjoy the health and wellbeing aspects that come with that. We must start from a position where woodland can deliver, and we have to judge how best to match the objectives with the types of trees that we grow and the types of forests that we develop. All that is underpinned by the United Kingdom forestry standard, which is about all those things and managing forests for their multiple values.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

I interrupted you, but thank you for that helpful clarification.

Màiri McAllan SNP Clydesdale
link

That was very much about new woodland creation. I have previously thought hard about woodlands that already exist, and even more so before coming in today, and I admit that it is a complex set of rules and regulations that determines the protection of ancient and native woodlands. For example, we have a system of sites of special scientific interest where native and ancient woodlands of a particular size or antiquity are protected by those environmental designations. If there was an application to fell something in an SSSI, felling permission or an SSSI consent would have to be sought.

The Forestry and Land Management (Scotland) Act 2018, which strengthened the relevant legislation, provides for the management of potential felling of those woodlands. Again, that means that any felling between 0.1 and 0.5 hectares would have to get felling permission.

Both of those routes therefore take us to felling permission, and we might ask in what circumstances felling would be allowed in our ancient woodlands. Ultimately, there are very few circumstances in which felling of any ancient woodland would be approved. The regulations are in almost the strongest possible terms without providing for a total ban. You can understand why there is not a total ban when you consider the exceptional circumstances in which felling might be approved. Doug Howieson can correct me if I am wrong, but it could be in relation to breaking up the canopy of the forest to allow light in to support the woodland floor and growth of the ancient woodlands. It could also be about removing invasive non-native species.

There is a very robust, albeit complex, web of protections, which, when they operate correctly, should absolutely protect our ancient woodlands. However, there are threats. I am sure that we will come on to this, but there are threats from overgrazing, invasive non-native species and climate change generally. I will pause there, but we can come on later to talk about how the Government is trying to rise to some of those challenges.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Yes, some of those themes will emerge. You talked about when the protections operate, and one of the petitioners’ questions was about whether they work and are applied. They see the forthcoming natural environment bill and the Scottish biodiversity strategy as opportunities for further protection through legislative routes. The question is whether that is envisaged at all and whether in preparing for those initiatives, as you have said, regulations could be improved if things are applied and work well in the current framework. Is there an evidence trail to show that what is there is doing the job that it is meant to do, and if not, is the Government contemplating something more?

Màiri McAllan SNP Clydesdale
link

Yes. Although I remain open-minded to all and any suggestions about how we strengthen and improve the protection of our ancient woodlands and rise to emerging challenges, the system as it stands, including the environmental designation and the forestry and land management route, where operating correctly, ought to be sufficient. There is a whole series of protections but we are not complacent. The Government is trying to identify all the threats to those incredibly precious trees and woodlands and we are taking action across the board.

09:45

I am particularly pleased to see the development of national planning framework 4 and some of its provisions for protecting our woodlands. They are explicit planning laws that will determine what happens throughout Scotland. The draft, which is being consulted on, says:

“Development proposals should not be supported where they would result in any loss of ancient woodlands, ancient and veteran trees, or adverse impact on their ecological condition”

or if they would have

“adverse impacts on native woodlands, hedgerows and individual trees of high biodiversity value”.

When it comes to potential felling or removal, a suite of rules is in place that ought to protect our woodlands. When that does not occur, Scottish Forestry has enforcement powers, which were strengthened in 2018 so that, for example, we would not need a successful prosecution for Scottish Forestry to step in and undertake restocking.

When the rules operate, they ought to protect woodlands, but we are always looking for new ways to do that such as through NPF4 and our work on deer and invasive non-native species, which we can come on to.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

In an evidence session two weeks ago, I asked a question about how NPF4 would help to protect ancient woodlands. One of the witnesses said:

“National planning framework 4 is a tremendous opportunity that we must not lose ... We cannot afford to take risks or to have weak legislation that creates loopholes.”—Official Report, Citizen Participation and Public Petitions Committee, 9 March 2022; c 12.

In the evidence session, the witnesses said that they did not think that the language in NPF4 was strong enough to allow planners to make recommendations that the law would back them on. Is that the case? If so, will you change it?

Màiri McAllan SNP Clydesdale
link

That is a really good question. In so far as I can, I am taking an active role in the development of NPF4 to ensure that a whole range of objectives in the environment portfolio are facilitated through it. The protection of our woodlands is one of those objectives.

I said previously that the legal landscape is complicated, but I do not think that it is vague or ineffective. There are good reasons why, for example, you will not currently find in law a ban on the removal of certain trees in woodlands, although there are examples, which I mentioned, of when works might need to be done to support the woodland’s conservation as a whole.

We need planning documents to be direct and explicit, but we must be able to apply them right across the country, and the narrower the language in the documents, the more difficult it becomes to apply them. Having said that, I will repeat what the current draft of NPF4 that is being consulted on says. It says:

“Development proposals should not be supported where they would result in any loss of ancient woodlands”,

which is very pointed for a planning document. I am pleased about that. However, I am, of course, working with stakeholders and, if they think that the language needs to be strengthened, I will be an advocate for that.

As it stands, NPF4 is clear and unequivocal. We must now look at all the other pressures that bear down on our ancient woodlands, including deer, invasive non-native species, climate change and wildfires. I am happy and comfortable that, across the piece, we are trying to rise to those challenges. NPF4 is still in draft and is a moving document.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

In the evidence session two weeks ago, witnesses said that there is a lack of data on where ancient woodlands are. The Scottish Government is committed to a national register of ancient woodlands. Can you update us on where that is? If local authorities and planners do not know where an ancient woodland is, how can they protect it? Will the register be created quickly so that local authorities and planners know where the woodlands are and can protect them?

Màiri McAllan SNP Clydesdale
link

David Torrance is absolutely right that one of the first points in anything is identifying location, conservation status and threats. Developing the register of ancient woodlands is in our programme for government, and we will be taking that forward through the summer. It will be a parallel exercise with the biodiversity strategy.

There is a number of existing registers or archives showing where ancient woodlands and native, natural and semi-natural woodlands are. However, for the reasons that David Torrance gave, it is important to bring those together so that local authorities and all those who have a responsibility for looking after them know exactly where they are.

However, it is also important that we know where ancient woodlands exist in relation to landowners. I would like to see that knowledge down to very small pockets, because everything requires to be conserved. We can use that knowledge to support, encourage and incentivise landowners even more than we already do. I hope to see that being developed in the summer.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

I am sorry. We would be happy to hear from Doug Howieson again. You contributed to our discussion a fortnight ago. Would you like to come in on any of the points that we have touched on so far?

Doug Howieson Scottish Forestry
link

Yes. I just want to provide some evidence for that answer. The Planning (Scotland) Act 2019 placed a requirement on local authorities to create a forestry and woodland strategy. NPF4 uses local development plans to emphasise the need for local authorities to develop forestry and woodland strategies.

Within those strategies, they also identify ancient, semi-natural and native woodlands. NatureScot and Scottish Forestry are consulted on the establishment of the forestry and woodland strategies. That process, which the minister has been encouraging us in, helps to drill further into the identification of native, ancient, semi-natural woodlands, and to ensure that they are afforded additional protection through the creation of forestry and woodland strategies connected to local development plans, where they do not already exist. Some good things are therefore being taken forward through NPF4 that will help with that.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

Are local authorities up to date in relation to that planning legislation? If they have not done what you have just described, planners will just decide yes or no. How does the Government check that they have managed to create those strategies?

Doug Howieson Scottish Forestry
link

We have close relationships with all local authorities in Scotland, and Scottish Forestry and NatureScot are statutory consultees for all developments of the type that we are discussing. We are fairly certain that local authorities are aware of that requirement and the need for it.

The second thing to say is that the native woodland survey of Scotland is available on the Scottish Forestry map browser. Local authority colleagues, who generally employ forestry specialists, are aware of the need for this, and of the need to drive it forward.

I think that only two or three local authorities in Scotland have not prepared a forestry and woodland strategy, and they are undertaking that task now.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

One of our committee members, Paul Sweeney, joins us remotely.

Paul Sweeney Lab Glasgow
link

That was an interesting introduction, minister.

In the previous evidence session, it was identified that the Woodland Trust has already done an exercise to investigate the extent of ancient woodland in Scotland and has identified that it amounts to about 5 hectares in total. Will the Government give a commitment to undertake to protect all of that under an SSSI designation as quickly as possible?

Màiri McAllan SNP Clydesdale
link

I am not going to make a commitment like that in this forum, because I am not a scientist or an ecologist who would be tasked with considering the characteristics of woodlands throughout Scotland and determining whether they ought to be protected under an SSSI or special area of conservation designation. As a Government minister, I am not going to pre-empt the views of scientists and ecologists in that regard. However, I can commit to being open minded to all suggestions about how we can strengthen the protection of ancient woodlands and rise to all the challenges that are bearing down on them just now.

I listed some of the challenges, but I would like to go into a little more detail. Deer pressure is accepted across the piece as one of the greatest threats to ancient woodlands. The issue has been described well to me. We have ancient trees but, because of activity on the ground over decades and centuries, as grazing has increased, the saplings that the trees have tried to produce have been consumed. The grandparent tree is left, but the rest of the family has not managed to become established, because of the overbrowsing by deer. Dealing with that issue is critical if we are to protect and grow trees.

Clearance of invasive non-native species—in which we are investing heavily—is also critical, as is combating wildfire, which is a threat to our woodlands. I will take through the Parliament a separate piece of legislation on grouse moor licensing, as part of which I will consider the licensing of muirburn. Given that we are due to have warmer summers, you can imagine the immediate threat that is posed by fire ripping through the countryside.

I will not commit to the SSSI point just now, Mr Sweeney. It would not be appropriate for me to do so. However, I commit to doing everything that I can to protect the precious trees and woodlands that we are talking about.

Paul Sweeney Lab Glasgow
link

Thanks. I should clarify that the Woodland Trust has identified that most pockets of ancient woodland each cover fewer than 5 hectares; they are isolated fragments and do not cumulatively provide coverage across Scotland.

Our two petitioners talked about enforcement of tree preservation orders, citing a case in Argyll that was particularly problematic. There are penalties for tree felling—I think that they said that the penalty is £5,000 per tree—but in this instance, enforcement was delayed. Argyll and Bute Council did not enforce the tree preservation order in a timely manner, which permitted the landowner to clear the area for grazing. The petitioners have heard that the national authority—I think that it is Scottish Forestry; sorry, I am just trying to find the right page of the Official Report—will not enforce the order and basically just came to a gentlemen’s agreement with the landowner.

That raises a concern about the extent to which there is enforcement when ancient woodland is vandalised, even when protections are in place. Do you agree that such issues need further investigation?

Màiri McAllan SNP Clydesdale
link

The point about hectarage that you and the Woodland Trust make is a good one. The Forestry and Land Management (Scotland) Act 2018 strengthened the law to cover woodlands of less than 0.5 hectares. Doug Howieson will correct me if I am wrong, but I think that felling permission is required for areas of 0.1 to 0.5 hectares. As I said, there are very few circumstances in which felling permission would be afforded in relation to ancient woodland.

Enforcement is important. I know from my ministerial and constituency roles that concerns are frequently expressed about felling being undertaken without regard to the rules or the enforcement action that might be taken as a result. Such felling is criminal offence and can result in a fine of up to £5,000. We strengthened the rules in 2018 to provide that Scottish Forestry does not require a successful prosecution to make a restocking direction. Scottish Forestry can step in and take action where the landowner is not doing so.

However, despite all of that, I understand the frustration that people feel when they see things going on that are not in line with the rules. Doug Howieson, I and our teams try to respond proactively to such cases. When they are raised with us, we investigate the circumstances. I remain open minded to any ways that we can ensure that the rules are complied with across the board.

10:00

Paul Sweeney Lab Glasgow
link

An interesting theme arose in discussion with the petitioners at the previous meeting when we discussed potential comparators for the kind of protection that they would like for ancient woodland. The listed buildings programme and scheduled ancient monuments arose as a basis for considering how a new scheme of protection could be introduced instead of protection simply being from an SSSI, which might require a significant burden of evidence about particular horticulturally, scientifically or biologically significant characteristics. In effect, the forestry could simply merit protection on the basis that its amenity is important to the community or that it is known as an ancient woodland of native species rather than any other requirements.

Is there an opportunity to consider something akin to the scheduled ancient monuments programme or listed buildings programme under which communities could nominate for consideration areas of woodland that they want to be protected? When the listing system and protections for built heritage were introduced in the 1960s, it required a national survey, which was done by the Royal Commission on the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Scotland, to identify the national list of protected sites. Perhaps a similar survey could be undertaken for woodlands, given the national scale the pressure that is faced. Perhaps that could be an interesting benchmark to consider.

Màiri McAllan SNP Clydesdale
link

I will make a couple of points and then hand over to Doug Howieson, who can give a more technical overview of the existing rules and the extent to which they might already be akin to what you ask for.

You mentioned the community nominating woodlands that folks would like to be protected. I am enthusiastic about community involvement in the management and co-development of woodlands not least because any kind of development that is happening on people’s doorsteps ought to involve them and they ought to benefit from it. Also, as we move in the next 20 or 25 years towards our net zero targets, the way that we use Scotland’s land will change and I want communities to benefit from that. Therefore, I am always mindful of how I, working with officials, can build in greater community engagement, ownership and development.

On the question about to what extent the system that we have already is akin to the schedule of ancient monuments, I will hand over to Doug Howieson. I suspect that it is similar to, but dealt with differently from, some of the schemes that we have been talking about.

Doug Howieson Scottish Forestry
link

The minister said that there is a commitment to a new register of ancient woodland, which we will start to develop later in the summer. The last survey of ancient woodland dates back to the 1970s and was undertaken by the Nature Conservancy Council, so we now have a good opportunity to revisit with improved technology the distribution of ancient woodlands, as opposed to native woodland, in Scotland and, therefore, to provide a benchmark for further protection.

Where a site is designated as an SSSI, a special area of conservation—SAC—or a special protection area, it is afforded control or protection from NatureScot, whose consent is required for operations within those woodlands that could cause damage to, develop or protect them. That is very much akin to some of the protections that come from scheduled ancient monument status, so there are existing parallels within the regulatory system that I am happy afford similar protection, Mr Sweeney.

Felling permission is required on sites that are not designated. As the minister said, felling permission would rarely be provided in an ancient woodland, save for meeting specific requirements to protect, enhance and develop that ancient woodland. Our opinion is that the protections that we have in place provide what you are asking for.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

I am keen to bring in other committee members now.

Ruth Maguire SNP Cunninghame South
link

Good morning, minister. I welcome your comments about community ownership and development, which is important. It came across that the petitioners felt pretty disenfranchised by some of what had gone on, so it is really good to hear you champion community involvement.

We have heard from you and from stakeholders that the biggest threats are from deer and non-native species. Will you say a little more about what progress the Government is making on modernising deer management legislation? What is the Government doing, through work with landowners, to prevent the spread of non-native species into woodland?

Màiri McAllan SNP Clydesdale
link

You have described the two greatest threats that our woodlands face. On deer, I come back to the analogy about the grandparent tree standing alone in the forest, which brings the situation to life. We need to do something to allow the natural regeneration process, which our ancient woodlands are well placed to deliver, to flourish.

The Government received the recommendations of the deer working group and we responded last year. We committed to implementing the vast majority of the recommendations, save for one—because of welfare concerns, we do not support the recommendation on the close season for female deer. We can take non-legislative actions and we can take actions that will require primary legislation. We will take forward the non-legislative actions now through the biodiversity strategy, and we will have the natural environment bill later in the parliamentary session. I am not leading on that bill, but I expect it to contain any actions that need primary legislation. The issue is very much a focus for this session.

As with deer, dealing with invasive non-native species is laborious and requires boots on the ground for hard work to clear what is largely rhododendron. When I was in the west Highlands recently, I saw that consuming the forest floor. Our forestry grant scheme already supports landowners with funds to help with clearing rhododendron.

We are working with the Alliance for Scotland’s Rainforest as part of our commitment to protecting and restoring Scotland’s rainforest, and we are backing that with funds from our £500 million of investment in the natural economy. We have opened a nature restoration fund; I do not remember the exact figure, but I think that it is a multiannual fund of £60 million, from which £12.5 million is available this year. Bids are in for that and are being considered by NatureScot. I expect some of that to rise to the challenges of dealing with invasive non-native species; the bids will be confirmed in the spring.

Alexander Stewart Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Minister, you have talked about management and protection, which are vital. You have gone into detail in some of your answers. I will ask about the implementation of a number of policies that come into play. The whole idea behind protecting such woodlands is to ensure that they are sustainable and that they continue.

In our round-table session, people touched on resources—what is being spent and how that is being managed—which have implications for what can be achieved. Knowledge and enforcement are other aspects, and you have touched on enforcement issues. Resource has a massive impact on what you can achieve in the short to medium term. What is the Scottish Government doing to enhance that? How are you tackling that situation? Without the financial resource to manage the situation, it becomes unsustainable.

Màiri McAllan SNP Clydesdale
link

That is a really interesting point, which applies here, as it does across the piece in relation to many of the actions that we need to take when faced with a climate and nature emergency. Over the next generation and beyond, the magnitude of our task will be enormous, whether in relation to the natural environment, with the funds that it will take to do what we need to do, or in relation to homes and buildings or the decarbonisation of transport. The costs are eye watering, and the public sector cannot support that itself. We need to find ways of leveraging responsible private investment: that is a big factor of the resourcing question, because we cannot do it ourselves.

Going back to the point about community empowerment and community benefit, I am keen to ensure that private investment is responsible private investment, but it has to be leveraged, and we can do that through carbon markets. That applies to woodlands, as it does to peatland restoration, which is a really important action, although it is very expensive.

On a different subject, in the Government, we are trying to provide funding for peatland restoration that will bring confidence into the market, which will allow others to come in and support that work. That applies across the piece.

Alexander Stewart Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Given the timescales, are many of the existing policies that the Government has already advanced now at the stage at which they need to be reassessed? You spoke about resource. To make things happen, there perhaps needs to be a refresh as to what can be achieved. The situation becomes worse year on year. Given the amount of resource and staffing that are required, as well as the implementation, some of the policies that you put in place are just not fit for purpose in today’s society and in today’s market, when we are considering how we manage woodland. There has been an erosion in that area, and those policies might have had an impact on that.

Màiri McAllan SNP Clydesdale
link

I think that you are quite right. That is another aspect of the fact that we are dealing with an emergency. We can never stop, pat ourselves on the back and just say that what was good a year ago is still acceptable now. That will not be the case up to 2045, and it will not be the case beyond 2045. We need to keep reviewing what we are doing. A good example might be our targets for the percentage of our planting that must be native, which I talked about at the beginning of the evidence session. I mentioned that we had the 3,000-hectare minimum, which we were meeting and exceeding, so we raised that minimum. As part of our biodiversity strategy, we will now do an evidence-based assessment of that minimum to see whether it needs to be upped again.

We are always challenging ourselves to ensure that what we are doing is up to speed. If we are not sufficiently challenging ourselves, Parliament and the stakeholders we work with will challenge us. That is all the better, as we do not have time to mess about.

Alexander Stewart Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

The partnership working that is already taking place in some areas has been pioneering, but that is not the case across the piece in Scotland. Things are working well in some locations, but other communities have a long way to go to catch up. Do you feel that some communities are being left behind?

Màiri McAllan SNP Clydesdale
link

Yes, I think that they probably are. As MSPs, we probably all feel that, across the areas that we represent, there are some exceptionally active communities that are able to advocate on their own behalf and get organised, whereas there are others that are not able to do that. I think that we all need to address that disparity.

Last week, I visited Loch Arkaig with the Woodland Trust Scotland and the local community development group, which are undertaking a joint venture for the restoration of the woodland at Loch Arkaig. That is a prime example of communities that are really organised and doing exceptionally well, which you just talked about. You are also right to say that there are other communities that are less well organised, although not for the want of trying, I suspect. As I mentioned, I am really keen to ensure that communities are supported. I take that very seriously.

There probably is a lesson for us in how accessible much of this is. I talked about the complex networks of rules. I am comfortable that those protect the woodlands but whether they are accessible is a different question. The work that we are trying to do on the register should help to open that up and make it something that everyone can be involved in.

10:15

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

You made reference to all the things that you would like to do and the enormous public purse resource that that would represent. One of the things that the petitioners are seeking to encourage is the provision of incentives to landowners to protect natural woodlands on their land. Is that something that falls into the desirable but perhaps hard to achieve category, or is there potentially room to accommodate it?

Màiri McAllan SNP Clydesdale
link

We are already accommodating it through our forestry grant scheme. Doug Howieson will have more information on that at his fingertips. That scheme already supports landowners with funding to undertake management of their woodlands for conservation and other purposes. There are opportunities coming down the track to look again at how well we are doing that. For example, there is the design of post-European Union exit agricultural policy, and I hope to introduce a land reform bill during this session of Parliament. In all those ways, we can assess both the incentives that are available to landowners and the requirements.

A big part of the land reform portfolio is the land rights and responsibilities statement, which makes clear that with rights come responsibilities. In an emergency, perhaps we could do more to make clear to landowners their rights and responsibilities and our expectations about how land is managed.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Mr Sweeney wants to come in and then I will invite Jackie Baillie to make a statement to the committee based on what we have heard this morning.

Paul Sweeney Lab Glasgow
link

I have a quick point about something that was raised in the previous evidence-taking session. Since 1999, 270 woodlands have been lost or damaged by development, which is significantly more than in other parts of the UK—although, obviously, Scotland has more forestry coverage per hectare. Has a lessons-learned exercise been undertaken to understand why those 270 woodlands were lost and what can be done to arrest the cause?

I understand that one of the biggest threats is coniferous seeding and contamination that leads to conifers impinging on the ancient woodland sites. However, the forestry industry is exempt from the UK forestry standard on monitoring and addressing contamination. Do we need to put obligations on the forestry industry to do more to prevent contamination from conifer plantations?

Màiri McAllan SNP Clydesdale
link

Those are two important, technical questions. I will try to answer them, but I would also like to go away and get you a fuller answer. I will ask my colleague Doug Howieson whether there is anything that he would like to add. We will come back to you with a response that is detailed enough to reflect the questions.

I will quickly pick up on the point about the contamination by different species of trees and the extent to which that is a threat to our ancient woodlands. For our part, Forestry and Land Scotland, which manages the public forests and estate on behalf of Scottish ministers, is undertaking restoration on 60 per cent of the sites that they manage where there has been historical planting on ancient woodland. That often means removing the non-native species that are planted in and around an ancient woodland site to prevent that cross-contamination and to allow the ancient woodlands to develop as they naturally would.

I will now hand over to Doug Howieson and we will both come back to you with further detail in response to your questions.

Doug Howieson Scottish Forestry
link

Thank you, minister. Mr Sweeney, I think that the loss that you refer to is a result of deer and invasive non-native species, including the seeding in of conifer trees. That is how we understand and articulate that loss, as opposed to the built environment being placed on ancient woodlands.

Some of the proposals in NPF4 are a direct result of lessons learned; policy 34, which covers ancient woodland, is a good example of that. In the biodiversity strategy that is to be released later in the year, there will be evidence of those lessons learned and a statement of intent on that.

Scottish Forestry, Forestry and Land Scotland and NatureScot are working with the Alliance for Scotland’s Rainforest to pool resources as best we can to reverse some of the decline that you have eloquently referred to. We are doing things to understand that decline, to learn from it and to start to reverse it.

Màiri McAllan SNP Clydesdale
link

In the natural environment bill that we hope to introduce, we expect to include statutory targets for nature recovery and nature growth, akin to the climate targets, which I think we would all agree have been a turning point for action on emissions reduction. Within that, we are also committed to protecting 30 per cent of our land for nature by 2030. In both of those pieces of work—I am not leading on them; my colleague Ms Slater is—I will be arguing strongly for the inclusion of the greatest possible protection for our ancient woodlands.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Thank you very much, minister and Mr Howieson. Jackie Baillie, who has supported the petitioners in the development of the petition, has been listening to proceedings. Jackie, would you like to make a statement that the committee can consider along with the evidence that we have heard this morning?

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Yes, indeed, convener, and thank you very much for the time afforded to me at the committee. My apologies that I could not be with you when you last considered the petition.

As well as a statement, I also have some questions for the minister. To be frank, I do not doubt the minister’s good intentions, but the issue is that those good intentions are at odds with the direct experience of the petitioners. I acknowledge that the minister’s language was very careful; I think that she herself recognises that there is scope for improvement.

At the heart of this is the difference between what existing legislation and guidance says and the reality of the implementation of that on the ground. Let me be candid: people are not seeking permission to fell ancient woodland—they are just doing it. Reports have been made to Scottish Forestry, but enforcement action has not been taken. Reports have made to councils and they have been asked to put in place tree preservation orders, but, a year on, that has not yet been done. Does the minister accept that that all demonstrates that the existing framework is insufficient in terms of its practical implementation?

I hear what the minister and her official have been saying about what is coming—there is NPF4, the biodiversity strategy and other work—but there is a sense of urgency here that I am not sure is fully appreciated, because we are losing ancient woodland. There was very little of it left to start with and we are losing it at pace, so I am genuinely concerned about the timescale for this. I would therefore urge immediate action that could be taken now, while we are waiting for all the things that are coming down the track.

I very much welcome the register of ancient woodlands; nobody would dispute the value of that. I hear that it is starting in the summer but I did not hear from the minister when it will be completed, which is the key issue.

The committee was shown—and I am sure that the minister has seen—the images of non-native species such as conifers invading and effectively destroying ancient woodlands. The minister spoke about investing in removal. Just yesterday, the Scottish Wild Land Group reported its concerns about the Highlands, in particular, and modern commercial forestry practice. It said:

“There is also the ever-increasing problem of non-native conifers, particularly Sitka spruce, seeding out of these plantations and beginning a takeover of the wider landscape. If no action is taken, in a hundred years or so the hills will no longer be open moorland but transformed into spruce forest.”

We have heard about New Zealand removing non-native conifers, where they have seeded in ancient woodlands and elsewhere. The minister spoke about investing in removal. What is the scale and pace of that? My fear is that what is being done is simply insufficient.

Finally, but perhaps most importantly for me, is the impact on local communities. Tax haven companies, such as Gresham House, are taking advantage of the tree-planting programmes that are encouraged by the Government in Scotland. They are about tax avoidance funds for wealthy clients, not preserving the environment. Those companies outbid local communities for land. Farmers are concerned about the loss of productive land, and haulage lorries thunder through small roads in tiny villages, but their concerns are simply swept aside. Therefore, I was really encouraged to hear the minister’s comments about ownership, management and co-development. Those are absolutely the right sentiments, but I need to know what, practically, is going to happen. There was no mention of that in any legislation. Will you give communities the right to buy on a first-refusal basis before any of those companies come in? Those are the practical things that might make a difference.

Without fail, everybody agrees that ancient woodlands are particularly important for Scotland and that they contribute to our biodiversity. Nobody disagrees with any of that. It is clear to me that there is a need for a much more robust action to match the minister’s and Government’s good intentions, so that we actually see that work on the ground. That is not just about legislation and guidance, but about enforcement action.

I am grateful to the committee for considering the petition and to the minister for taking the time to respond today.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Thank you, Ms Baillie. I do not think that it would be quite right for members of the Parliament who are not members of the committee to cross-examine the minister, but, if the minister would like to say anything to the committee before we draw the session to a conclusion, we would be very pleased to hear that.

Màiri McAllan SNP Clydesdale
link

If you do not mind, I will use this opportunity to respond to Ms Baillie’s points, all of which I note and think helpful.

She asked about some specifics, and I will start with the community engagement point. I have been in post for approaching a year, which I can scarcely believe. In that time, I have tried to stress the community element of the portfolio. Officials and I have been working with the Scottish Land Commission to understand exactly how best we can embed community engagement, development, management and ownership within our ambitions for woodlands. Of course, I hope to take forward a land reform bill in this session. As well as continuing Scotland’s land reform journey, specifically, I will be trying to rise to the challenge of what are colloquially termed “green lairds”. We are all conscious of that issue, as the value of Scotland’s natural capital rises in the climate emergency.

Ms Baillie asked about what action is currently being taken on clearing the ancient woodlands that are potentially planted with other species. I am not sure whether I said this before, but I confirm that FLS, which manages land on behalf of Scottish ministers, is currently undertaking restoration of 60 per cent of plantation on ancient woodland sites—PAWS—and I expect that to increase when it is possible.

Ms Baillie made a point about the extent to which the forestry grant scheme is supporting those who could readily afford to undertake work in any case. I will correct this if I am wrong, but I think that, in recent years, 60 per cent of all the scheme’s grants have been for projects of fewer than 20 hectares. For example, we have a real focus on working with farmers, to help them stitch woodland into their farming business. Therefore, there is a focus on the smaller players as well, although, in the support that we offer, our mantra is “right tree, right place, for the right reason”.

Finally, I understand the point about the extent to which everything that we have discussed today—and what the Government is doing—feels at odds with what communities are experiencing, because, as I said, in my constituency capacity, I have experience of that occasionally being the case. However, in this role, I see the national picture and, when I look at the national picture, I am comfortable that the rules, as they are, are robust.

However, as with anything, there are circumstances in which people will not comply with the rules. Very frequently, when that happens, people get in touch with me and Forestry and Land Scotland. We try to get actively involved, often by visiting sites to see what is happening and what we can do to help.

Doug Howieson and I discussed this before coming to the meeting today. We would like to offer visits—with Doug, NatureScot officials or a local conservancy officer—to any sites where Jackie Baillie and her constituents would like us to see what has potentially gone wrong in that circumstance.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

I thank the minister and Mr Howieson for their time this morning. It has been an incredibly helpful discussion.

Do members agree that we will consider at a subsequent meeting the evidence that we have heard this morning?

Members indicated agreement.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Members are content with that, so we will have a short suspension to allow everyone to regroup.

10:31 Meeting suspended.

10:38 On resuming—

  1. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 54
  2. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 40
  3. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
  4. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  5. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
  6. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
  7. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 9
  8. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 10
  9. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
  10. 11:15 New Petitions Petitions · 9
  11. 11:15 New Petitions Petitions · 7

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.