Thank you and good morning. I begin by extending my thanks to the committee for inviting me to give evidence on Scotland’s first framework for tax. I understand that the committee is keen to learn more about the framework’s purpose and content, which I am very happy to discuss.
The framework builds on the Scottish approach to taxation, which was the subject of an inquiry by the Finance and Constitution Committee in the previous parliamentary session. It seeks to capture the key components of good tax policy making and to reflect the principles and processes that underpin our approach to tax, as well as our programme of work. In short, it is about our identity in relation to tax policy, what we are trying to do and why we are trying to do it.
As the committee will be aware, the Scottish approach to taxation is based on Adam Smith’s well-recognised four principles for a good tax system—proportionality, certainty, convenience and efficiency. We have added two further principles to demonstrate our commitment to engaging and collaborating with stakeholders on tax policy and to underline our firm approach to tackling tax avoidance activity.
Those principles remain a core part of the framework, although we have strengthened the final principle to capture what is described as “effective” tax policy making. That includes a firm approach to tax avoidance—our resolve on that remains the same—but it recognises the importance of effective policy design and delivery as the first step in reducing the scope for avoidance practices.
In developing the framework, we wanted to build on those principles by setting out, as clearly and accessibly as possible, a fuller explanation of how we make tax policy in Scotland and how we sequence it around the Scottish budget process. In doing so, we expect to realise a number of benefits.
First, the framework will demonstrate our commitment to openness and transparency, which are key ingredients of any good tax system. Secondly, it will lay the foundation for a process of continuous improvement using feedback from stakeholders and policy evaluation to ensure best practice in how we design and deliver tax policy. Thirdly, it will support our efforts to align the tax policy cycle, as far as possible, with the Scottish budget and United Kingdom fiscal events, which are of critical importance to the development of devolved and local tax policy. Fourthly, it will enable us to be up front about our priorities and programme of work for this session of Parliament. Events and circumstances can change rapidly, and that can change the context within which we take tax policy decisions. Covid-19 is a profound example of that. However, it is important that we set out our intentions for taxpayers and businesses, particularly in times of volatility, and that is what we have done. Finally, it will demonstrate our desire for a more open, mature and informed debate about tax policy in Scotland, which is something that I know that the committee is committed to.
The framework is intended for a range of audiences. Our ambition was to make it as accessible and as easy to understand as possible. It is written concisely; jargon is minimised or explained, which is not an easy task in this area; and it sets out the extent of our powers and how the revenue that we raise contributes to the Scottish budget.
Communicating clearly on tax and engaging the public on tax policy is a priority for the Scottish Government. However, improving public understanding of tax cannot be achieved by Government alone and I am keen to work with the committee and all other interested stakeholders on initiatives that can help achieve that.
In that spirit, I take the opportunity to thank all those who contributed to the framework’s production. We sought engagement with a wide range of stakeholders including tax professionals, business representatives, third sector organisations and the general public, and we also carried out a two-month consultation process last September and October. The incredibly valuable and constructive feedback that we received made a positive contribution to the framework’s final version, which was published on 16 December last year and was warmly welcomed by stakeholders. I genuinely believe that we have a product that has been co-produced, and I am extremely grateful to all those who contributed for their expertise and advice.
I will end by looking to the future. As I hope will be clear, the framework acts as a foundation for tax policy in Scotland. Aspects such as the programme of work chapter will need to be refreshed to reflect changes to our work, and we plan to revise that chapter around the mid-point of this parliamentary session. Our intention is for the framework as a whole to stand the test of time and, indeed, to be built on further, acknowledging that one document can never be a silver bullet for every issue or challenge that we face.
The framework demonstrates our commitment to good guardianship of our devolved and local tax powers, including a sustained commitment to continuous improvement. Indeed, that is why, for example, we have published an evaluation of the changes made to income tax in 2018-19 alongside the framework. It is also why we will work with the Parliament on reconvening the devolved taxes legislation working group, which will allow for more detailed consideration of how we can improve the way in which we consult and make legislation on devolved taxes.
As I said at the outset, the framework provides a foundation for the design and delivery of tax policy in Scotland, with policies that support the recovery, national outcomes and our pursuit of a fairer, greener and more prosperous Scotland for everyone, and I look forward to discussing it with the committee.