Thank you for extending an invitation to come to your committee today. It is very welcome. I will refer fairly extensively to notes, because this is such a complex issue and I do not come from a forestry background, so I need some prompts.
Over the two years since we submitted our petition, we feel that the case has been successfully made on an international stage for the world’s old-growth woodlands to be protected in order to stem biodiversity decline and global warming. Sadly, however, deforestation of old-growth woodland continues unabated here in Scotland and across the world to meet growing demand for timber products from big economies such as those in China and England.
The tragedy is that most minds and hearts have not yet been won over by the case to save woods and trees for the future or for people who are losing their homes and their countries from flooding and so on from rising sea levels and indeed for the very survival of earth’s habitable ecosystem.
For our local community, the ancient bluebell wood that gave rise to our petition two years ago is essentially our ground zero. The committee has photographs of that ancient bluebell wood before and after a bike track was built in it. In order to protect the wood, we feel that we need to identify the immediate threats to it. We cannot protect it unless we know what the threats are. That is the basic process that we are going through now; we are trying to identify the threats within a mile’s radius of the wood.
The key points that we would like you to try to keep in mind are that Scotland has only 1 per cent of its ancient woodland cover; that is down from 80 per cent land cover 5,000 years ago. England has about 3 to 4 per cent of ancient woodland left. The term “ancient woodland” is not a legal term and does not bring any automatic legal protection. Most of Scotland’s ancient woodland has no special designation, such as a site of special scientific interest, and therefore no legal protection.
In response to our initial petition, NatureScot wrote that, at present, more than half of Scotland’s woodlands with a special designation
“are in unfavourable and declining condition”
and en route to eventual loss, and that so far the status
“of designated woodlands, and their priority for intervention and incentives is important, but has not been sufficient to prevent the decline and loss described”.
NatureScot went on to say that the
“decline and loss is very likely to be worse in non-designated natural woodlands”,
which includes our woodland.
Heads of Planning Scotland wrote:
“Specific national legal protection for Scotland’s remaining ancient, native and seminative woodlands and woodland floors would be a long overdue start.”
It went on to say:
“short of (properly enforced) statutory protection these assets will remain at risk and continue to be degraded.”
In addition, and with regard specifically to the threat that is associated with commercial forestry, which is what seems to have brought us to the stage at which we have been invited to appear before the committee, around 16 per cent of Scotland is already covered in monoculture commercial forestry. Some areas, including Dumfries and Galloway, are 25 per cent afforested—I suspect that it is something similar in Argyll and Bute. The vast majority of forestry is non-native and invasive, and half of all forestry is one species: the highly invasive Sitka spruce.
In 2012, Sitka was blacklisted in Norway and Norwegian scientists labelled it an ecosystem engineer, because of its ability to spread rapidly: it grows to be three times bigger than native trees and it changes the soil and water acidity to suit its requirements.
We understand that Scotland is a net exporter of timber, so we already have enough timber to meet our population’s needs and still sell some. When people in commercial forestry slam the United Kingdom for having the second biggest deforestation footprint in the world after China, they are actually talking about England.
The most recent United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change
report, which was issued just last week, includes a section on concerns about geo-engineering. Specifically, the IPCC is most concerned about the planting of the wrong trees in the wrong places, where they degrade water quality and soil and reduce biodiversity and indigenous plants and animals.
We feel that our local community in Argyll is powerless to stop the destruction of our immediate local environment. We described that powerlessness in our most recent submission.
Thank you.