I will take a bit of time to lay out some of the provisions, in order to make it easier for members to ask questions.
The Prisons and Young Offenders Institutions (Coronavirus) (Scotland) Amendment Rules 2022 Scottish statutory instrument extends for a further six months—to 30 September 2022—the application of certain modifications that were made to the prison rules, in response to the coronavirus pandemic, by the Prisons and Young Offenders Institutions (Scotland) Amendment Rules 2020 (SSI 2020/122).
When I appeared before the committee in September to discuss those powers, I spoke of the need to ensure that the prison service was able to take all necessary measures as we approached another winter during the pandemic.
Of course, neither committee members nor I could have predicted the rapid emergence of the omicron variant only a few months later. That has left no doubt that it remains the case that the Government must ensure that the prison service can deploy precautionary and protective measures as necessary in response to the on-going and unpredictable pandemic.
Therefore, it is essential to extend the flexibility that was afforded by the previous rule amendments, in order to ensure the safety of those who visit, live and work in our prisons. I need not remind the committee that prisons are complex settings, with a significant number of vulnerable people.
While the current rule amendments have been in force, the omicron variant has brought peaks of around 150 cases to the prison estate in January and staff absence rates of 9 per cent. We continue to see Covid cases across the prison estate and, as of Friday 4 March, last week, there were 126 positive cases among 11 prisons.
Consistent with the current SSI in force, some powers are being extended to 30 September. The first set of powers are those that allow governors to suspend or restrict—if necessary and proportionate—in-person visits, purposeful activity and recreation, in response to local outbreaks.
The second set of powers are those that provide for extended timescales in relation to the isolation of large groups of individuals, so that governors and local national health service partners have the means to comply with Public Health Scotland and Scottish Government advice. That includes isolation of those who are symptomatic or have been in close contact with a person who is symptomatic, those who are identified as close contacts of a person who is symptomatic, or those who are new admissions, where isolation might prevent a Covid-19 risk.
The third set of powers are those that enable governors to extend—from the normal seven days to up to 14 days—the period that a prisoner is on home leave, if prisoners advise that they or someone in their home has coronavirus or has developed symptoms of coronavirus.
Members will be aware that, in advance of laying the SSI, the Scottish Prison Service wrote to stakeholders to seek views on the extension of those powers, and those responses have been published on the SPS website.
I am aware that stakeholders and members have concerns regarding the impact on human rights, and that there have been recent calls for transparency in the reporting of why and how frequently the powers are being used in the estate. As I reiterated in September, those powers are being and will be used only as precautionary measures and as a proportionate and necessary response to localised outbreaks in the prison estate. Decisions on their use will remain subject to multiagency decision making and public health advice and remain subject to independent scrutiny by Her Majesty’s chief inspector of prisons for Scotland.
Despite the vulnerability of those in prison to the highly transmissible omicron variant, the powers have not impacted on the vast majority of the prison population since October, and the prison service is providing as full a regime as possible.
In her summary report on the Covid-19 pandemic emergency liaison visit report, which was published in January, the chief inspector of prisons for Scotland commented on the proportionate way in which restrictions have been applied. She said:
“the overwhelming impression was of a calm and orderly atmosphere in prisons, and regimes that were restricted but safe. It was also clear that prisons were working hard to provide more opportunities and reduce restrictions wherever possible”.
I am aware that Teresa Medhurst wrote to the committee last week, with a collation of high-level information on use of the current powers from October 2021 to February 2022, and I am sure that members found that helpful. The information set out the proportionate use of the powers in seven prisons for a variety of reasons in response to local outbreaks. As requested, Ms Medhurst has helpfully committed to provide the committee with further high-level updates on the use of the powers.
Lastly, governors are already under a legal duty to act compatibly with human rights legislation in the discharge of their functions and they can use those powers only where it is necessary and proportionate to do so. It is the SPS position that those amendments have a positive impact on the protection of human rights.
With regard to articles 2 and 3 of the Human Rights Act 1998, the rule changes are designed to help the SPS to prevent and reduce the risks of the virus spreading within the estate. Without those measures being available, the article 3 rights of the prison population could be engaged.
The SPS also recognises the potential that utilising the measures could impact on prisoners’ article 8 rights. However, its view is that the powers can be and are being applied proportionately, in order to have the least possible impact on prisoners’ article 8 rights, and therefore they do not breach those rights.
The draft instrument provides for precautionary powers that are essential to the Scottish Prison Service’s continuing response to all unknown eventualities of the pandemic, whether nationally or locally. The emergence of this winter’s new variant has shown that we cannot be complacent, given the vulnerability of the prison setting to coronavirus.
On the assurances that have been given that the measures are being applied proportionately, their effect, and the effect of other measures, is demonstrated by the levels of Covid incidence in prisons, which are certainly much lower than many of us feared they could be when the pandemic started.
With that, I am happy to take members’ questions.