No, I think that I remember it.
The process has been incredibly confusing. The fact that we are sitting here on 2 March, discussing the issue, when the change has been in place since 14 February, is testament to that. That is how the stakeholders feel. We are moving to managing fisheries by campaigning as opposed to by data, science and process, which sets a very worrying precedent.
Bally Philp talked about whether the trawl fisheries have had an impact. To be honest, we need science to prove what is happening in the area, but we have a lower than 1 per cent bycatch rate, which I believe is the lowest bycatch rate in the EU. Our fleets are very selective. They have 300mm square mesh panels to ensure that they do not catch fish, and we have observed that on trips.
The science on baseline stocks is very poor. Bally Philp is right: what will we compare the improvements with? If we close the area, how will we compare what happens with what happened previously? We have very limited survey information about what happened previously. In relation to the science behind, or rationale for, the change, the New Economics Foundation’s report talks about the work by González-Irusta and Wright, but we are comparing the Clyde with the North Sea and Iceland. We are talking about very different types of fishery.
We should definitely be looking at what is happening in Northern Ireland and how fishermen there have been engaged in relation to the cod box. Northern Ireland has tried to develop a system that offers the right protections and that continues to monitor the science.
It is important to say that, in the initial consultation, Marine Scotland indicated that its preference was for a rollover of what has happened for the past 20 years. There is currently a review of how we manage fisheries. For this year, that indication was very misleading to a lot of people who would have responded to the consultation, because they thought that there would be a rollover. They did not know that any of this was coming; they were completely blindsided. We are told that the change fits in with the agenda in the Bute house agreement. We need to know what is happening.
Bally Philp mentioned the BRIA process. We should have very detailed socioeconomic analysis of what the change will mean to small communities. As I said, we are talking about very small boats—even the boats in the mobile fleet are small. We are not talking about industrial trawlers. The communities are so reliant on those boats. Nobody has considered the three boats that I mentioned, which have absolutely no income. There has been no compensation. A proper rationale and engagement are essential, as is science. We cannot keep forgetting about that area.
I will give a practical example. About two and a half years ago, we held a scallop survey, which was done only as the result of a cancelled pelagic survey in relation to the North Sea. The survey allowed some science to be done on the west coast, and it showed that the Clyde has some very healthy scallop stocks. That is a different area, but the survey gave us a far better idea of what was happening, and it was done only as a result of a cancelled survey in relation to the North Sea.
We need reliable data sources. Fishermen are willing to help in any way that they can in working with neutral Government scientists to ensure that we do not have such processes, which blindside people and lead to a loss of trust. I cannot justify what has happened.