Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

ScotRail

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 10 February 2022 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 9 contributions · 4 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

9 contributions
1. Douglas Ross Highlands and Islands) (Con
link

Like the First Minister, I pay tribute to Her Majesty the Queen and her incredible service over the past 70 years. I was in the chamber yesterday when my colleague Stephen Kerr led a debate on that subject and I was pleased that almost every member who participated in that debate was able to recognise the incredible service of Her Majesty the Queen.

With regard to the statement that we have just heard from the First Minister, Scottish Conservatives have urged for weeks that young people should no longer be forced to wear face coverings in classrooms for seven hours a day. Young people’s education has been unnecessarily disrupted for far too long. Finally, after weeks of refusing to budge, the Government has U-turned and, although that is welcome, it has taken far longer than necessary.

However, today, I will ask about another pressing issue. Earlier this week, ScotRail confirmed that it is going ahead with planned cuts to 250 services across Scotland from May of this year. In April, the Scottish National Party Government will take charge of Scotland’s railways. Will the First Minister commit today to cancel those cuts?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

First, in response to Douglas Ross’s comments about my statement a few moments ago, I say that the fact that he has been urging that change for weeks is not a demonstration that he has been right; it is a demonstration of his deep irresponsibility. Had we made the change weeks ago, we would have done so at a time of soaring infection rates among school-age children and put school-age children and those who work with them in schools at greater risk. Secondly, had we done it before today, we would have been acting against expert and scientific advice, so it would have been the wrong thing to do. We are doing it now at the right time and in line with advice, and that marks the responsibility of the Government, in contrast to the irresponsibility of the main Opposition.

On the issue of ScotRail, first, I welcome the Minister for Transport’s confirmation yesterday that ScotRail will come into public ownership on 1 April; that upholds a manifesto commitment of this Government, which was overwhelmingly elected just under a year ago. We will continue to do what ScotRail is already doing—making sure that we have a railway that is fit for the future.

Travel patterns and the numbers of passengers have substantially and significantly changed in the course of the pandemic, so the pattern of rail services needs to reflect that, but we also need to keep that under review. Therefore, although we are still in a period of hybrid working, as people begin to go back to the office and passenger numbers increase on our railways, we need to ensure that the timetable and routes that are serviced by ScotRail remain fit for purpose. The Government will take on that responsibility to make sure that we have a railway that is fit for the future and is of the type and quality that the public have a right to expect.

Douglas Ross Con Highlands and Islands
link

The First Minister welcomed the transport minister’s statement yesterday. Does she also welcome what the transport minister said about those cuts being “not acceptable” when they were announced in her local area? I am interested to see whether the First Minister agrees with that previous comment from her transport minister.

The problem is that the Government says that it wants more members of the public to use public transport, but it does not do enough to improve services or bring down rising ticket prices. What is the use in nationalising services if the SNP is just going to do the exact same thing as ScotRail? The First Minister has just accepted that she will continue with the cuts that ScotRail is planning. If the First Minister will not change those cuts that are planned, will she at least guarantee that, when the Scottish Government assumes control of ScotRail, not one further service will be cut?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

First, let us talk in terms of reality rather than the mischaracterisation and misrepresentation that we have just heard. The timetable—[Interruption.] I know that Douglas Ross will not want to hear this, but I will persevere in answering the question. The timetable, which was initially supposed to add 100 extra services compared with December 2021, is now adding nearly 150 services, following the consultations. From May 2022, ScotRail will operate around 2,150 daily services, providing almost 600,000 seats.

However, the key point is that I am not sure whether Douglas Ross or anybody else in the chamber is suggesting that there should not be changes to ScotRail timetables to reflect changes in passenger usage. We saw a significant and substantial change in that during the pandemic, and that change will continue to some extent after the pandemic. Usage of services might also revert to being more like it was before the pandemic, and the timetable will need to adapt to that. That is the sensible and responsible approach to take.

We will continue to take steps to keep rail fares affordable. That will be one of the key benefits of public ownership in the years to come. I will end this answer with a reminder that rail fares on average are significantly lower already in Scotland than they are where the Conservatives are in power in England.

Douglas Ross Con Highlands and Islands
link

The First Minister urged me to listen to her answer—which I did—but it had nothing to do with the question that I posed to her. She went on for quite a while after I asked whether she would commit to guarantee that her Government will not cut any services, but there was nothing about that in her answer.

To defend the changes that are coming in May based on what was happening in December 2021—well, we know what was happening in December 2021: the First Minister was warning about the tsunami of cases and urging people not to go out of their house or to work. It is not fair to compare December 2021 with the situation that we are in today.

All that the First Minister is doing is replacing ScotRail with SNP rail. There will be a different owner but the same problems, and while public transport services are being cut, her Government has turned against drivers as well. She has abandoned plans to improve roads, and now she is putting in the workplace parking tax, without any cap on the amount that people will be forced to pay. When it was first proposed, organisations such as the Educational Institute of Scotland, the Scottish Police Federation and Unite the union warned about the costs that would fall on teachers, police officers, care staff and shift workers. All those warnings were completely ignored by Nicola Sturgeon and her Government.

This week, the Scottish Retail Consortium said that the workplace parking tax is

“a recipe for extra cost and complexity”,

and today the AA is warning that

“workers are going to be hit with . . . levies of as much as £1,000”.

People are already on the brink, with bills increasing and the cost of living rising. Why is the Government in favour of a costly workplace parking tax at the same time?

Alison Johnstone The Presiding Officer · Lothian
link

Before the First Minister responds, I remind colleagues that I would very much like to hear both questions and responses.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

Many people in this country are right now on the brink because of benefit cuts and tax rises that are being imposed by the Conservative Government at Westminster and because of its complete failure to respond appropriately or accordingly.

Let me address the points on ScotRail first. What I guarantee is that, when the Scottish Government takes ownership of ScotRail, we will operate a timetable that is reflective of the usage of the railways by passengers. That is about the real-world running of a railway that is fit for purpose.

Secondly, we will continue to ensure that we have affordable rail fares—we will take action to ensure that they are affordable. Let me remind Douglas Ross that rail fares right now are, I think, 20 per cent cheaper on average in Scotland than they are in the rest of the United Kingdom. I would suggest that that is a good foundation on which to build.

Let me turn to the workplace parking levy. I remind Douglas Ross that it gives a discretionary power to local authorities. They do not have to use it if they do not want to or if they do not think that it reflects their local circumstances. Of course, I would remind Douglas Ross that, in the Tories’ last local government manifesto—although I grant that this was before he was leader of the Scottish Conservatives—they said:

“We need to empower councils and give them a renewed sense of meaning and purpose.”

We are giving discretionary powers to local authorities and what do we have? The Scottish Conservatives opposing it and moaning about it.

The second point is that the workplace parking levy is simply giving local authorities in Scotland a power that local authorities in England have had for a decade and more, which is allowed to them by the Conservative Government. Not for the first time, there is a deep hypocrisy at the heart of Douglas Ross’s question.

Lastly, here we are again. All parties across the chamber are, rightly, signed up to our climate change objectives and our net zero ambition, and we need to get people out of cars. We need to get people on to public transport, which is why public ownership of the railways is a good thing and why free bus travel for under-22s, which has been introduced by this SNP-Green Government, is a good thing. We will not just set the targets but take the action to help meet those targets, and we will leave Douglas Ross and his colleagues whining as usual on the sidelines.

Douglas Ross Con Highlands and Islands
link

Here is the difference between me and the First Minister: I want to empower councils; she wants to use them as a shield. Last week, she was using councils as her shield about chopping the bottom off doors and this week she is using them as a shield against her tax rises. It will be councils that are led by the SNP and the Labour Party that will introduce the car park levies, because I can assure her that Scottish Conservative councils will not.

The First Minister’s Government is anti-driver. She does not seem to understand that many people, particularly those living in rural areas, need their car to get to work. Instead of delivering better public transport to make up for the difference, her Government is going to nationalise the railways and make no improvements to the services. What can people expect from a nationalised railway service from the same Government that cannot even build a ferry, which launches ferries with painted-on windows and which sends ferry contracts to Romania instead of Port Glasgow? Are trains going to go the same way as ferries under the First Minister’s Government?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

First, on railways, this Government has connected or reconnected more of Scotland to the railways in the past number of years. Since 2009, the communities of Alloa, Laurencekirk, Armadale, Blackridge, Caldercruix, Conon Bridge, Shawfair, Eskbank, Newtongrange, Gorebridge, Stow, Galashiels, Tweedbank and Kintore have all been reconnected to the railways through the reversal of Beeching cuts. In the next three years, Reston, East Linton, Dalcross, Cameron Bridge and Leven will all follow in being reconnected to the railways. This Government has a record to be proud of and we will build on that record.

Going back to the workplace charging issue, I think that, from listening to Douglas Ross, it is quite clear what his approach is. He will empower local authorities—if he ever gets the chance, which I humbly suggest is unlikely—only if they then do exactly what he instructs them to do. That is not empowerment. We have given powers to local authorities. It is up to them to judge whether and to what extent to use them, in line with their local circumstances. That is empowerment.

We will get on with improving public transport and meeting our net zero targets. That is why people continue to put their trust in this Government.

  1. Point of Order Procedure · 2
  2. General Question Time Questions · 1
  3. Renewables (East Lothian) Questions · 6
  4. Examinations (Content) Questions · 6
  5. Strategic Transport Projects Review (Ferries) Questions · 4
  6. Early Learning and Childcare Questions · 4
  7. Human Trafficking Questions · 6
  8. Universities and Colleges (Face-to-face Learning) Questions · 4
  9. Smart Meters (Island Communities) Questions · 5
  10. First Minister’s Question Time First Minister’s Questions · 2
  11. ScotRail First Minister’s Questions · 9
  12. Oil and Gas Windfall Tax First Minister’s Questions · 7
  13. Animal Welfare First Minister’s Questions · 2
  14. Ferries (Ferguson Marine Engineering Ltd) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  15. Trinity Tower (Support for Households) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  16. LGBT History Month First Minister’s Questions · 6
  17. Football (Protection of Women and Girls) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  18. Restoration of Peatland (Net Zero Targets) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  19. Delayed Discharge First Minister’s Questions · 4
  20. Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services (Waiting Times) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  21. Face Coverings in Schools First Minister’s Questions · 2
  22. Early Learning and Childcare (Funding) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  23. Online Pimping Members’ business · 20
  24. Constitution, External Affairs and Culture Questions · 1
  25. International Development Programme (Climate Change) Questions · 8
  26. Brexit Freedoms Bill (Engagement with UK Government) Questions · 8
  27. International Development Programme (Vaccines) Questions · 7
  28. Forced Adoption (Access to Records) Questions · 6
  29. Referendum Bill (Legal Advice) Questions · 9
  30. Brexit (Impact on Policy) Questions · 4
  31. Brexit (Relations with European Union) Questions · 5
  32. Civil Service (Independence Policy) Questions · 6
  33. Professional Qualifications Bill Bill debate · 9
  34. Budget (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 138
  35. Health and Care Bill Bill debate · 2
  36. Decision Time Decision time · 10

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.