Thank you very much for the opportunity to speak to the committee today. I do not want to say that I am nervous, but I am slightly overwhelmed about being the only community representative here. As you know, my colleague Kirsty Henderson from PLACE Edinburgh had to send her apologies—she is a key worker and could not get additional time off work to attend the meeting. It is a shame that there are not more community voices being heard in these meetings, but I will do my best to represent the communities that I have spoken to about the issue.
You asked whether a short-term let licensing system would help to deal with the negative effects of short-term lets. The licensing scheme as a whole is to be hugely welcomed. It has taken such a long time to get to this point. I know that it has been under consideration for a number of years now, while short-term lets have continued to operate. A lot of the elements of the scheme will have a positive impact, not least in relation to health and safety issues around individual properties and ensuring that properties at least meet the requirements of private tenanted long-term lets. That is absolutely critical.
The licence will be really useful if complaints need to be made, as people will be able to find out who owns a short-term let, even though that will be via the local authority. We know that the current system is not working. At the moment, there are only two potential routes to go down for someone who has a complaint. One is via the police, through some sort of antisocial behaviour measure, although by the time things are investigated, the people who have caused the nuisance have gone and the owner of the short-term let can disclaim all knowledge of the behaviour. The other is via the planning system, which is hugely overburdened.
Licensing is a positive step that is to be welcomed, but there are elements of the Inaudible. put out in October by the cabinet secretary which hugely water down its potential effectiveness.
One element is the need to have the natural names of the owners available. It has never really been clear why owners’ names would not be freely available when they are available for houses in multiple occupation and on the Scottish landlord register. We are not quite sure what the difference is between short-term lets and those other types of operation, as they are all commercial operations. Given the Scottish Government’s move towards transparency around ownership through the register of persons holding a controlled interest in land and the land register more generally, it seems wrong that the provisions on making sure that natural names are included and publicly available have been taken out. That is a real concern for us.
The overprovision element is absolutely essential. Planning control area orders will not address the issues around overprovision, particularly in places such as Edinburgh and in some rural communities, such as Skye, Mull and Tiree, the east coast of Fife and so on. PLACE Edinburgh and Community Land Scotland believe that the removal of the overprovision powers shows a fundamental misunderstanding of the scope of the new short-term let control areas in planning legislation. We welcome the powers that have been included, but they only remove the materiality check—the check on whether the change of use of a dwelling house is material and would require planning permission.
Short-term let control areas can only be used to tackle the overprovision of short-term lets by denying a property planning permission if there is a supporting policy in a council’s local development plan, and an LDP can be changed only every five years. The City of Edinburgh Council has put into motion the process to put the policy into its LDP—Inaudible.—the short-term let control areas, which control overprovision in any sense.
The overprovision policy needs to be reintroduced into the legislation and the licensing scheme to give local communities and local authorities the ability to control the number of short-term lets in very specific areas where they are causing a problem. I will give some examples. In cities such as Edinburgh, huge numbers of short-term lets have hollowed out communities. In places such as Mull, Skye and Tiree, huge numbers of short-term lets have impacted massively on the availability of affordable housing stock, particularly for young working families. People are being made homeless and are not able to return or move to those areas—thereby addressing the issue of depopulation—as a result of the huge numbers of houses that are being taken out of permanent residential use and made short-term lets.
If people can rent out their property for £500 a month to a local family—a family that provides important services and sends their kids to the local school—or let it for £1,000 a week as a short-term let, it is a no-brainer which option they will choose.
The market is completely uncontrolled and the overprovision policy needs to be put back in to enable local communities and local authorities to manage the issue.
I have gone on a bit, but those two points are really important.