Thank you, convener; I welcome that.
All the regulations that are coming our way are, largely, the right thing to do but, as Morecambe and Wise said, they are not necessarily in the right order. We have worked on the DRS for a while now, we think it is the right way to go, and we have supported it for four or five years. We are, however, struggling to get to the endgame, and I know that the minister is considering delaying it. We hope that she delays the implementation of the DRS because some parts of the industry are ready to go, but some are not. The DRS cannot be delivered in parts; it has to be the whole thing.
Our best estimate of the right time to go with the DRS is September 2023. That will still give the industry a problem, because England and Wales will not be ready until late 2024, which could give rise to the potential fraud that I alluded to. If cases are more than £4 more expensive in Scotland than in England, we will start to see people trying to make money on that.
Again, EPR is the right thing to do. We are largely supportive of it, but we still cannot get Governments—and when I say Governments, I probably mean Westminster but I am also talking about some part of the Government in Edinburgh—to say whether the DRS is part of an EPR scheme. We have been waiting for two years, or perhaps three, for a VAT ruling from Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs.
I talked about getting things in the right order. We have EPR coming in between Scotland’s DRS and England’s DRS, which is really confusing and will be a problem. We also have single-use plastics in the background. Although it does not impact on EPR and the DRS, the plastics packaging tax comes in next April, and to avoid a plastics packaging tax, we need to be able to use recycled content of up to 30 per cent. In the business for which I work, we are already doing that, and lots of other businesses are already doing it. However, as pressure is put on more and more people to use at least 30 per cent recycled material—which is the right thing to do—they will not have the material to use, because the DRS will not be up and running.
You can start to see the disconnect. The DRS should be up and running to provide the good materials that will allow people to move to recycled material content. It is all directionally right, but it is in the wrong order. That is how I would sum up the situation.