I am a survivor of 10 years of conversion practices and speak on behalf of Brave Network Melbourne and Sexual Orientation & Gender Identity Change Efforts—SOGICE—Survivors. I am also part of the research team at La Trobe University that has been working on a research project in the past year.
I apologise that I will probably speak a little bit quickly because there is a lot to get through, so speak up if you need me to slow down or repeat anything.
I acknowledge the Wurundjeri and Bunurong peoples of the Kulin nation as the traditional owners of the unceded and colonised lands from which I speak with you today. I pay my respects to their elders past, present and emerging.
I will give a bit of background about the state of Victoria. It has about 6.5 million people. The religious composition is important to note because it is distinct from that of the UK, Scotland or other parts of Australia. It is 40 per cent non-religious, a bit under a quarter Roman Catholic, only 9 per cent Anglican, about 5 per cent evangelical, Baptist or Pentecostal and then a range of other faiths in slightly larger proportions than you might find in other states in Australia.
It is important to note that Victoria is distinct from New South Wales, of which the capital is Sydney, where there are some fairly large, well-known evangelical movements such as Hillsong and the Anglican diocese of Sydney, which have a much smaller presence in Victoria.
I will refer to the SOGICE Survivor statement at several points. Sexual Orientation & Gender Identity Change Efforts Survivors produced a statement in 2018 in response to misinformation being circulated by the media about the experience of conversion survivors. The statement gives a history and explanation of conversion practices in Australia as well as recommendations and has been used widely by Governments in Australia and around the world. It was developed using participatory policy development approaches and included a range of multifaith voices. Our website also includes media guidelines for journalists who are interviewing survivors and reporting on conversion practices. I will briefly run through the core content of the statement, as it provides background to the legislation.
First, we call conversion ideology an ideology not a theology. We see it as a pseudoscience blended with theological aspects. Many tenets of conversion ideology are mentioned in the statement but I will mention the core five.
First, humans are born with the potential of developing into heterosexual people whose gender identity reflects their sex assigned at birth and, secondly, if a person is same-sex attracted or gender diverse, that can be caused by factors such as abuse, neglect, inappropriate parenting dynamics or even the demonic.
Another tenet of the ideology is that same-sex attracted, trans and gender diverse people should live celibate lives or seek healing for their sexual brokenness—the word “brokenness” is a commonly known term among people who have experienced conversion practices.
The ideology also claims that, through consistent, long-term devotion, spiritual mentoring, the avoidance or suppression of queer influences and on-going practices that I will mention in a moment, a person can experience change in their sexual orientation or gender identity or can overcome the causes of, or drivers behind, the same-sex attraction or trans identity and that they can remain celibate—that would be the suppression aspect.
Another way that we characterise conversion ideology is that it is a set of false and misleading claims about the origins, causes and dysfunctional nature of, or solutions to, LGBTQA+ attraction or identity.
The definition of conversion practices on the SOGICE Survivors website is a bit different from that in the Victoria legislation. It is:
“Any formal or informal practice, activity or treatment (in any setting) that seeks, or is used, to suppress, eliminate or change a person’s sexual or romantic orientation, gender identity, or gender expression, where that change is deemed necessary due to the instigator’s belief in or adherence to conversion ideology”.
I will run through a bit of background to how we define practices. These definitions of practices have been adopted widely in Government policy in Victoria.
We use the word “practices”. We find it more helpful than the word “therapy”, as most practices do not resemble therapy in the common use of the word. The main reason for emphasising that is not because the practices are not therapeutic, even though many people claim that that is the best reason for using the word “practices”. We say that the most important reason for using the word “practices” is that using the word “therapy” might prevent some survivors from realising that they are survivors because they might not recognise what they went through as being therapy, particularly if it was in a quiet, gentle prayer context.
We also find the word “torture” to be somewhat inconsequential in survivor discourse. We do not feel that it should or should not be used; we just do not think that it is relevant in the context of a global north, developed country even though some people have experienced conversion practices in a way that resembles torture.
We also feel that conversion practices are not so much about the form—prayer, talk therapy or group work—as they are about the ideology and intentions present behind whatever form the practices take. We note that, often, conversion practices are disguised as prayer or talk therapy. We often say among survivors in Victoria that conversion practices look like a pseudoscientific talk therapy session with “Dear Lord Jesus” at the beginning and “Amen” at the end.
Conversion practices are distinct from non-consensual surgeries for intersex infants in this context, although some global critique exists on that issue. One major jurisdiction—Malta, which is probably the only jurisdiction to investigate that area of law—has passed two separate pieces of legislation and Victoria is considering doing the same.
We also note that conversion practices are distinct from conversations that are based on seeking advice or guidance, seeking to clarify a theological position or asking genuine questions based on concern. Those would not be conversion practices.
Conversion practices usually take place in pastoral care settings that mimic or look similar to talk therapy or modalities that, if used in a psychological setting, would be regulated by our peak health regulators in Australia and subject to the code of ethics held by the regulatory body.
In relation to the terms coercion and consent, we find that it is deeply problematic and ambiguous rhetoric to use such terms in the way that we have just heard in recent evidence, particularly as we find that those terms are usually used in discourse created by people in favour of conversion ideology. Perhaps a more accurate term is that conversion practices usually involve misinformed consent or consent that has been obtained through fear or the fear of being rejected from a community. Either way, it is not informed consent. Participation usually comes through internal drivers within the person as a result of having internalised conversion ideology as well as a bit of community influence, so coercion is a fuzzy term in this context. Voluntary participation does not really equate to consent or non-coercion.
Next, I will look at some myths and areas of confusion. The idea that any queerphobic message or action is automatically a conversion ideology or practice was shared by people from a range of diverse cultural and religious backgrounds. We would say that even though religious homophobia, biphobia and transphobia can be painful for queer people, including queer people of faith, they do not necessarily equal conversion practices and ideology, which are a subset of religious queerphobia.
Conversion practices and ideology are often seen as western constructs. Again, we would say that we have seen conversion practices and ideology manifested in most major faith communities in Victoria. They are distinct but they still cause similar harms, regardless of the culture or the faith.
Another misconception is that the harms caused by conversion practices and long-term exposure to conversion ideology are the same as the harms caused by general religious queerphobia. Again, we would say that conversion practices and ideology cause a unique combination of harms that have been found to leave significant damage in survivors.
There is also a misconception that conversion practices have developed separately in Muslim, Jewish, Roman Catholic, Protestant, Eastern Orthodox, and other major faith communities and that they incorporate different methods, resources and ideology. However, we have found that conversion practices and ideology are remarkably similar, regardless of the faith tradition, even if, on the surface, they appear different. The practice might look a bit different, but usually the ideology is somewhat similar. In Victoria, we have seen that often, conversion proponents across faiths have colluded with each other and even shared resources, manuals and guides.
The last misconception I will cover is the idea that conversion practices primarily occur in isolation or in paid healthcare settings, whereas we have found that the vast majority of conversion practices occur in unpaid religious contexts, particularly in “pastoral care” settings and in faith communities in which conversion ideology is regularly communicated.
On the screen now is an infographic that our team developed with Amnesty International. I will not run through it, but it proved to be extremely helpful in helping folks to understand some of what I have just been talking about in a simple infographic form and I am happy to share it with you.
I am a steering committee member of the Brave Network, which is Australia’s survivor support and advocacy group. We use trauma-informed approaches to support survivors of conversion practices and facilitate safe spaces for survivors to discuss and deconstruct their experiences. We support queer people of faith to tell their stories in the media, in churches and at public events and we host confidential and private spaces for leaders from various faith backgrounds to discuss some of their questions and meet survivors in a safe environment.
What has worked in supporting survivors and in our advocacy is helping survivors to understand the ideology that they have ingested and been immersed in over time. Many survivors do not understand that what they have been immersed in is an ideology and not necessarily time-honoured traditional theology.
We make sure that we set boundaries for journalists so that survivors do not find themselves sharing such deep information from their lives that they become triggered and retraumatised afterwards. We also create opportunities for allies and affirming faith leaders to network with each other for solidarity, because often they are our strongest supporters.
Tim Jones will speak in a moment about our national conversion ideology and practices research project. Survivors were involved in that project and the research is probably one of the most significant pieces of work in Australia so far relating to conversion practices and ideology.
On the screen, there is a diagram that has been useful in helping to explain the prevalence of different types, contexts and settings of conversion practices in Australia. The size of each square or rectangle equals the weighting of prevalence. For the vast majority of survivors, conversion practices have taken place in contexts that we call unpaid, informal or religious settings and have been carried out on adults. There is a much smaller prevalence of paid, informal or religious practice settings, such as cash in hand to a pastor or minister who might pray with the person.
11:45
In the middle of the diagram, in orange, there are programmes. You might be aware of some of those programmes, which are more popular in the United States and were popular, in the past, in Australia. Again, there are paid and unpaid programmes, which are perhaps led by a non-profit organisation. On the left, there are practices that are delivered to minors; again, those are informal or religious practices and programmes. At the bottom of the diagram, in blue and also in the grey bar for adults, there are regulated settings, which are formal practices that might be delivered by a regulated professional such as a psychologist. We meet very few survivors who have been through conversion practices in regulated health practitioner settings.
We also find that a significant driver of conversion practices is a system of referrals, inducements and networking. It might not be clear where a person goes to when they are directed by their church community to undergo conversion practices, but we know that there is usually a pastor, representative, minister or someone in the church or other faith community, who has made a referral of some kind or is the person to go to when people want to refer someone to conversion practices. We also find that advertising, such as pamphlets, flyers, leaflets and posts on social media, drive the conversion movement.
Virtually all conversion practices breach a range of business, consumer, professional and health sector codes or standards, but there is little to tie that together in one legal instrument, and that is the strength of the Victoria legislation. I will not read through all the text that is on the screen now, but it is safe to say that most conversion practices incorporate false and misleading claims about the cause of a person’s queer identity and the potential outcomes from treatment or practices, as well as therapeutic fraud regarding the non-existence of evidence for the false claims of the efficacy of conversion practices. In most religious denominations in Australia, that misinformed consent aspect of conversion practice is an ideology breach of pastoral care guidelines. The failure to refer a queer person to competent, confident and affirmative treatment—such as a psychologist referring someone to another person—is considered a breach of the code of ethics for psychologists in Australia. There is a range of other types of false and misleading claims and false representations.
The foundations of the legislation in Victoria and advocacy in recent years have been: at least 50 survivor-led articles over several years in major online, print, radio and television; 15 years of survivor support groups in Victoria through two major organisations; trans document equality legislation, which was passed a few years ago; and, in 2017, a fairly high majority of 65 per cent of people in Victoria voting yes in a marriage equality vote—or plebiscite or chook raffle, as some of my friends called it.
In 2016, Victoria passed health complaints legislation—the Health Complaints Act 2016—which gave power to investigate to a health complaints commissioner, but the commissioner found that her powers were insufficient to address conversion practices, that conversion practices required tighter, dedicated legislation, that conversion ideology was central to harm and that gaps existed in current consumer health and human rights legislation and for regulatory bodies in dealing with conversion practices. As well as consumer affairs legislation in Victoria, we have the consumer affairs regulatory body, Consumer Affairs Victoria, which investigates false and misleading claims in trade and commerce, including paid and unpaid services that are offered.
We also have a code of ethics in Australia for psychologists. The code of ethics for the function, engagement or application of conversion practices in Victoria requires an Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency—AHPRA—registered practitioner to refer a patient or client onwards if they are unable to treat that patient competently, confidently and affirmatively. Affirmative treatment does not mean agreeing with what the patient or client says; it means treatment that is free from predetermined intention or agenda and is practised in a manner that enables informed consent.
We also have substantial evidence in Victoria—and there is more coming. In 2019, there was the Victorian Government consultation. There were also funded research projects in 2016 and 2020, as well as a literature review, focus groups, and several interviews that were part of the latest research project. Putting that together, one of the things that survivors advocated for was legislation that covered that funny-coloured diagram that I showed earlier; members can see that towards the left and middle of the screen at the moment. On the right, we added on to that diagram the intervention that we wanted to see in the legislation. We wanted to see a civil scheme that had power to investigate; criminal penalties; and a restriction placed on removing a person from Victoria to go to another jurisdiction where conversion practices are not curtailed through legislation. We also wanted to see the Government commission research, community education and survivor support.
When we looked at other states in Australia as well as in the United States, we saw that most legislation focused very narrowly on regulated practices delivered to minors, and usually focused only on criminal penalties in those contexts. We found that doing so, in essence, gave licence for the other contexts of conversion practices to proliferate. For example, unpaid informal conversion practices delivered to adults can continue without the practitioners experiencing the fear of Government intervention, because there is legislation that a lot of effort has gone into that covers only regulated practices delivered to minors.
In Victoria, we have a law that has avoided that, and covers most of the things that advocates wanted. The objects of the legislation—which I will not read through in detail—outline a definition of conversion practices and the intentions behind the legislation, which are in line with the SOGICE Survivors statement, research, and advocacy.
I will quickly read through the intentions of the Parliament, as outlined in the act. They are:
“to denounce and give statutory recognition to the serious harm caused by”
conversion practices; to affirm that queer people are not “broken” and that queer identity and experience do not constitute
“a disorder, disease, illness, deficiency or shortcoming”;
and to affirm that “change or suppression practices”—as they are called in the legislation—are
“deceptive and harmful both to the person subject to the change or suppression practices and to the community as a whole.”
The definition of a “change or suppression practice” in the act is
“a practice or conduct directed towards a person, whether with or without the person’s consent”—
which we have already discussed—
“(a) on the basis of the person’s sexual orientation or gender identity; and (b) for the purpose of”
change or suppression or inducing the person to undergo change or suppression. It also lists examples that include but are not limited to psychiatric or psychotherapeutic practices, prayer-based practices—including exorcism, deliverance or religious practices—and giving a referral.
The exclusions are really important, because they pretty much blow out of the water many of the things that we heard from some of our lovely previous givers of evidence. Exclusions include, first, any practices that support or affirm a person’s gender identity or sexual orientation—which is, I guess, obvious—and, second, the practice or conduct of a health service provider that is, in the health provider’s reasonable professional judgment, necessary to provide a health service or to comply with the legal or professional obligations of the health service provider. That means that, if they are not making false or misleading claims according to consumer law and are providing competent, confident and affirmative treatment that allows the making of informed consent according to the code of ethics, they are fine to ask as many investigative questions as they would like to. That includes asking investigative questions relating to the nature of the person’s gender identity or a child’s gender identity. Those exclusions are therefore quite sufficient to deal with some of the concerns that are often raised by health practitioners and psychologists, particularly those working with young trans people.
It is important to note that the legislation is primarily focused on the civil scheme that is currently being assembled and is under development by the Victorian Equal Opportunity and Human Rights Commission. The criminal elements and penalties in the legislation are—in many ways—really just a very small part of the legislation. We feel that the civil scheme is the primary innovation of the legislation.
First, it empowers VEOHRC—which is the acronym for the commission—to commission and undertake research and education, including community education, and to be a front door for referrals, survivor-led and trauma-informed interaction with survivors and referring people to support. It has a much stronger focus on voluntary processes and facilitated outcomes. However, it can also make investigations and issue enforceable undertakings.
The indicators for investigation are still in development, although Brave Network has advised the commission that it should include or make reference to the presence of ideology and issues relating to duty of care. In other words, if a community, person or body is investigated and it is found that conversion ideology is regularly being communicated, you can be pretty sure that the practices are occurring somewhere nearby, if in secret.
The criminal penalties are based on the Crimes Act 1958 and the principles of negligence—in other words, duty of care—and injury or serious injury beyond reasonable doubt, measurable and confirmed by a suitable expert. For engaging another person in a change or suppression practice in which duty of care is owed, there are penalties for injury, including psychological injury, and serious injury, and members will see the figures with regard to imprisonment on the current slide. There is also the strict liability offence of advertising paid or unpaid conversion practices and a penalty for taking a person from Victoria to undergo change or suppression practices. Finally, failure to comply with a notice or to produce evidence during an investigation under the civil scheme can be converted into a criminal offence and penalty.
I am almost finished, convener. With regard to opposition to the legislation, there was significant backlash from organised conservative religious groups such as the Australian Christian Lobby, but the rhetoric that was used was found not to be relevant when one looked at the detail of the legislation. Unfortunately, there was also opposition from conservative representatives of the Australian Medical Association, many of whom made recommendations about exemptions that found their way into legislation. I guess that, in the media and public-facing environment, one or two appeared neutral or at least amenable to conservative supporters, and we were a bit disappointed by that duplicitous representation by medical bodies.
Concerns about the legislation fell into two major categories, the first of which was that a person might go to jail for praying with queer people. However, for someone to be sent to jail, they would need to have caused injury or serious injury that was grounded in intent and was not inadvertent or unintentional. Moreover, neither providing advice nor informing someone of a theological position come under the scope of the legislation, as they are not intended change or suppression practices. Prayer must in and of itself be intended as part of the change or suppression practice. In other words, even if the minister, pastor or rabbi leading the prayer held a belief in relation to conversion ideology, their praying with someone for guidance would most likely not come within scope of the legislation, if they did not share that belief during the prayer. A conversion practice or the person delivering it would be investigated under the civil scheme only if there were evidence that the practices had resulted in something serious or were systemic, for example, if a person were delivering conversion practices to 20 or 30 people who all then came forward to make a report to the civil scheme.
The second concern that was raised was that health professionals would not be free to treat trans kids properly, which is an issue that I have already touched on. We can see that as long as a health professional complies with the code of ethics they are allowed to ask investigative questions. If a trans child is being treated by a person under a predetermined agenda, that person is already in breach of the code of ethics in Australia, and the legislation is really just adding another layer to that.
Making fraudulent claims about causes, origins or the supposed dysfunction of queer people and identities is already covered under consumer law and health complaints legislation in Victoria, and this legislation simply adds more targeted penalties and the civil scheme, which allows for improved education and research.
I have already mentioned the concerns of the Australian Medical Association, and it must also be noted that many of the organisations and psychologists who provided support for the legislation behind the scenes did not come forward to defend it. It was often left to survivors to do so and to speak directly to community forums, which was painful and excruciating.
As for the legislation’s passage through Parliament, it cleared the Scrutiny of Acts and Regulations Committee—or SARC—of the Parliament of Victoria, having been found fully compliant with the Victorian Charter of Human Rights and Responsibilities, which, I might add, is a fair bit stronger than the European convention on human rights. It passed the Lower House of Parliament in December 2020 by a margin of 37 to 0—the Opposition did not vote. However, the Opposition did vote on the legislation in the Upper House earlier this year, and it still passed by a margin of 27 to nine, with several crossing the floor to vote in favour.
I acknowledge the groups of brave survivors who worked tirelessly over many years for the legislation, and who threaded the needle many times with politicians, bill writers and public servants to get the wording, definitions and exclusions right.
12:00