Throughout the crisis, decision makers were quite clear that there was no way that they could fully compensate businesses for the income that they would lose as a consequence of some of the public health measures. For example, the Cabinet Secretary for Finance was quite clear that the £10,000 and £25,000 grants that were delivered in Scotland were not meant to fully compensate businesses for their lost revenue, but they would mitigate the immediate pressures that businesses were facing. Anecdotally, we know that many businesses exhausted their cash reserves and that Scottish businesses took on about £4 billion in debt through the Government-backed coronavirus business interruption loan scheme and the bounce back loan scheme. It is obvious that businesses had to borrow because the other mechanisms to support them were not sufficient.
I accept that there was a need for money to reach businesses quickly and, for the sake of pace, some elements of targeting were lost. The economic data produced by the likes of the Bank of England and others seems to show that the economic burden of the crisis was felt disproportionately by small and medium-sized businesses as opposed to their larger counterparts.
That is why we are arguing that, as we enter the recovery phase, government at all levels should focus on helping small and medium-sized firms, which support every second private sector job in the country, to get back on their feet, simply because we do not think that local communities will recover until their business communities are firing on all cylinders.
09:45
Looking to the future, obviously, we are talking about rates today, and our view is that, in the next financial year, additional support specifically for small businesses outside the scope of the small business bonus scheme might be necessary. We also think that, as Governments make tax and spending decisions, we need to give local and independent businesses time to recover, to pay down their debts and to grapple with the challenges of, for example, rising energy bills and other increases in overheads, which other witnesses have spoken about, and not clobber them with tax rises. For instance, there is some concern that the increase in national insurance contributions will have a disproportionate impact on small businesses. That is why we want the Chancellor of the Exchequer to announce an expansion to the employment allowance when he stands up in Parliament tomorrow.