We have circulated a private draft paper with some suggestions for the work programme. I do not want to take any decisions on the content of that paper today. Its purpose is to inform members and to stimulate suggestions. We can put any suggestions into a final draft, for decision making at the next meeting.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Hugh Henry only · show everyone- Hugh Henry Lab 34
- Bruce Crawford SNP 9
- Dr Winnie Ewing SNP 7
- Margo MacDonald SNP 6
- Dr Sylvia Jackson Lab 5
- Irene Oldfather Lab 4
- Dennis Canavan Ind 4
- Stephen Imrie Committee Clerk 3
- Cathy Jamieson Lab 2
- Allan Wilson Lab 2
- David Mundell Con 2
Hugh Henry’s contributions
34 contributionsAny thoughts?
We can bear that in mind.
I hope that members will have suggestions about priorities.
We will make those decisions at the next meeting. Today we have the opportunity to suggest any topics that we think have been left out and should be included in the final draft. Dennis Canavan's suggestion that we should reword the paragraph headed "Consultation" is well made. We will try to do that in the final draft.There is a difficulty with human rights matters. I am advised that issues relating to the European Court of Human Rights are outwith the committee's remit. I think that we will find ways from time to time in which to consider some of those issues, but we will need to think about that carefully.
That would depend on what the issues were. The standing orders state:"The remit of the committee is to consider and report on—proposals for European Communities legislation;the implementation of European Communities legislation; andany European Communities or European Union issue."Where something is an issue for the European Communities or the European Union, we can consider it, but if it is something for the European Court of Human Rights or the Council of Europe, we cannot. I would hazard a guess that most of the issues that they address will also be for the European Communities or the European Union, and that would be the way we would look at it.
It would be hard to imagine that a matter for the Council of Europe or the European Court of Human Rights would not be a matter for the European Communities or the European Union. The standing orders do not include the bodies that you mention, but I think that we can be flexible when required; if there is a problem, no doubt the lawyers will tell us. We can get advice on that, but it should not delay our work programme, and we will deal with any obstacles when we meet them.
I know what you are saying on the broader suggested programme.
That is clear—for example, we will have an item later on the EU budget, but it is obvious that, although we are asking people to comment on that, it is too late. We need to get into the process earlier, a point that Winnie Ewing made at previous meetings. We could strengthen that.
We will consider whether there is another way of wording that.
If we decide that those issues are priorities, whoever considers them will no doubt wish to take those details into account. We should not try to write a detailed report now. The paper contains suggestions for consideration only. Are you broadly in agreement with those topics?
No, they are not prescriptive.
We are not deciding today which issues we will take on. I repeat: we have a list of suggestions for members to consider. If members think of issues that are not identified in the paper, they should suggest them now and we can consider them at the next meeting. However, Dennis Canavan, Cathy Jamieson and others have already suggested that some of those topics are so large that we would find it difficult to cope with them, to address your point, Margo. However, we will consider them and we will not be prescriptive. The paper suggests the type of issues that might be considered, but, no doubt, once rapporteurs have been appointed, other issues will be raised. We will try to be as specific as we can, but we do not wish to be prescriptive.
We will discuss that at the next meeting. The committee clerks are still working on agriculture and fisheries issues, which will include forestry.
Yes.
We will need to be careful. At previous meetings, we expressed the aspiration to be involved in some of the broader issues, not just to refer things to the relevant committee. If we say that all education-related items are a matter for the Education, Culture and Sport Committee, or that all enterprise items with a European dimension are a matter for the Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee, we will narrow down our role. This is all about getting the appropriate balance and the appropriate working relationship with other committees. I think that Sylvia Jackson is making a slightly different point.
There will be occasions when we want to work with other committees—there is an item later in today's agenda on which I will suggest that we work closely with the Justice and Home Affairs Committee. What we have attempted to say in this document is that it is legitimate for this committee to assume a broader advocacy role in European matters. Our role should not be purely reactive, or limited to giving views on matters that are put before us. We want to encourage a better understanding of the European agenda. That means that we must foster debate and engage actively with and promote European issues. We probably need to use a stronger word than dissemination to indicate the direction that we want to take.Do Sylvia or Margo have anything specific to suggest for the draft?
We will reword that.
I am struggling to understand the change to the paper that will encapsulate your comments.
The concluding paragraph of section 5 states:"Please also note that consideration of the role and remit of other subject committees of the Parliament needs to be taken before agreeing the list of issues". We will have to return to that debate, but there is nothing to stop us as a committee saying, "Here is the broad objective that we believe is important from a European perspective. We want to know what you, as another committee, are doing to assist in achieving that objective." That is not inconsistent with what we have said; it does not mean that we will do all the work—other committees will do some of it. When we come to appoint rapporteurs, some of those issues will be taken forward.
We will see whether we can add that. We will also consider Cathy Jamieson's comments.
Yes, we could do that.
The paper is not meant to resolve all the details immediately. After we have set the broad objectives, we will start to allocate work. As part of the process, we need to consider how we engage with other committees and how they can help us to fulfil our broad objectives. A number of useful suggestions have been made about where the emphasis should be and about some of the detail. We will have another chance to go through the document when the paper is redrafted. Is there anything else?
Stephen Imrie suggests that it could be done through all those bodies. The other issue that needs to be considered is the fact that we have a different role from the Scottish Executive. While we appreciate the co-operation that the Scottish Executive has given us so far, not only in Edinburgh, but in Brussels, there will be times when it is appropriate for us to have access to our own support. At some point, we may need to consider having a representative office in Brussels so that we can get independent analysis and information. Perhaps we could work in partnership with COSLA, helping it to invest in or expand the work that it does. I do not want to belittle the work carried out by the Scottish Executive, but we need to recognise that there will be times when our roles have to be different. We may need to put down a marker and come back to this issue. A discussion with COSLA could be helpful.
I hesitate to inundate the committee with a huge volume of information, not all of which will be relevant. We may occasionally need to examine the work of the European Parliament, the European Commission and the Committee of the Regions to get advance warning of what is relevant. The committee should discuss its relationship with a range of organisations and how we can feed into them.
We have agreed that we will ask for a document that indicates what all the different bodies in Scotland, the UK and Europe do. At some point, it would be helpful for someone to take us through that. Today, I gave Stephen Imrie a flow chart produced by the Local Government International Bureau in London, which shows the decision-making process in Europe. It will be to the good if, as part of our learning process, we have another discussion about this so that we can begin to find out when decisions are made and—as Irene Oldfather says—to feed information in from the Commission, the Parliament, the Committee of the Regions and others. Dennis Canavan's point can be covered by that.
If we can agree the detail of the document, we could start to look at that. If we cannot get round to it, it would need to slip to the meeting after next.
Yes, I have given some thought to it and—in the spirit of the Parliament—we will be as fair as we can. The priority is to agree on the principles and programme and—if necessary—to take a step back and agree on the principles of how we allocate the work. It will not help if we squabble over who does what. At the same time, we need to agree on the process.
I have seen you in action before, Bruce. I know exactly what you mean.Is there anything else that has not been included? I echo the comments made by members of the committee in thanking Stephen Imrie and the members of his team for their work. We will try to tidy this up and produce a paper for consideration at the next meeting. We will also make some suggestions about the allocation of the rapporteurships. Some people have already expressed an interest; they will not always be accommodated entirely, but we will try to do so as much as possible.
Sorry?
I am puzzled, Winnie, because we have at least twice asked committee members to express their interest. It is possible that that has not registered, but everybody has had the opportunity to express an interest. I will say it a third, if not a fourth time. The fact that people have been asked to express their interest does not mean that any decisions have been made.
We suggested that people could express their interest in broad terms. It is rather petty to start making complaints about that, as everybody was in the same boat. The people who responded have clearly used some initiative, but that does not mean that they will get the area in which they have expressed interest. The suggestion was an attempt by the clerks—quite rightly—to gauge people's interests. I do not think that it was jumping the gun.
We discussed it more than once, Winnie. I am sorry.
Let us leave it at that—we are quite clear about what we have asked. The intention was to try to extend some courtesy and to engage members. If that has not worked, that is unfortunate. The committee will make the final decision at a future date.
In this meeting
Everything on 23 Nov 1999 →- Scottish Parliament European Committee Tuesday 23 November 1999 (Afternoon) Committee business · 2
- Priorities Committee business · 55
- Work Programme Procedure · 78
- Scrutiny Committee business · 70
- Plant Health (Scotland) Amendment (No 2) Order 1999 (SSI 1999/129) Subordinate legislation · 1
- Convener's Report Procedure · 19
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.