My sense of the vaccination certification scheme and of vaccination certificates more broadly is that they are a double-edged sword. How they work is a function of social trust. In areas of high social trust, where people believe that the vaccination certification schemes are there to help them and are a public health intervention, by and large, they give the vaccine indifferent—those people who are not anti-vaccine but who have not got around to it—a good reason to get vaccinated. When you introduce such schemes, there is quite often a surge of people getting vaccinated, and that is certainly true in France.
However, in countries and communities in which there is low social trust, such schemes can have a different impact because they lead to a sense of compulsion and a sense that the vaccine is mandatory, in effect. When you try to impose things on people, you get psychological reactance and people reassert their autonomy, and it also undermines their relationship with authority. Indeed, we have data to show that, in individuals and communities with a high level of trust, the prospect of vaccination passports increases the intention to get vaccinated, whereas in those communities with a low level of trust, such as the black community, it not only can have no effect but can increase opposition.
The evidence paper that we have been given slightly understates the problem. It says that a scheme might not have much effect among those who have a low level of trust, but it could actually lead to greater opposition. The issue of social trust is therefore a major problem.
The second issue is what it does to other behaviours. Early on in the pandemic, when vaccines were first introduced, there was some data to suggest that those who were vaccinated were given an illusion of immunity and invulnerability, and they increased their risky behaviours. What you get on one hand, from vaccination, you lose on the other, through an increase in risky behaviours, so messaging is important.
That has a number of practical implications. First, the broader context in which you introduce vaccination passports is critical. They work only when you are doing other things to increase social trust, especially around vaccination. It is important not to see vaccination passports as your sole strategy for increasing vaccination. They must be seen in the context of increasing the ease of getting vaccinated, including by ensuring that there are vaccination stations in schools, colleges, universities, workplaces and communities. Secondly, you must engage with people—listen to their concerns, take those concerns seriously and address them.
There are other things that you must do to increase trust, one of which, for instance, is to have a clear set of criteria for the end of the scheme, otherwise you will feed into those narratives that say that it is about controlling us and that it is the thin end of the wedge of identity cards. You need a clear set of criteria for when the scheme will be taken away, to show that it is temporary. It would also help to have an option for a conscientious objection, if you like—a procedure by which people do not have to get a vaccination passport if they do not want to. Not many people would be likely to take advantage of that, so I do not think that it would be a major problem in terms of numbers, but it would show that the passport was not going to be imposed on people—that they would not have to sign up to it. Those issues are critical in how you introduce such a scheme.
The other point is that messaging is absolutely critical. It is really important to say to people that vaccinations do not make them invulnerable—vaccinations make you safer; they do not make you safe. As I say, if behaviours change following vaccination, the advantage of vaccination will be undermined.
Finally, although the evidence document is very impressive, as I have indicated, it understates the risks and the importance of messaging. It also understates the alternative. One of the points that the document makes—it is not made prominently, but it is a really important point—is that vaccines are crucial for making us safer but they are not enough on their own. We need other measures, such as improved ventilation and improved hygiene. Indeed, the research on even larger events in indoor spaces shows that, if there is proper ventilation and hygiene, levels of transmission are very low.
Therefore, vaccination passports are a double-edged sword, because they create problems and alienate people from authority. There needs to be much more emphasis on making venues safe—necessarily safe—and having clear criteria for their opening. I do not think that vaccination passports should be an alternative to closure—it should be vaccination passports or safe venues. Indeed, perhaps we should have vaccination passports and safe venues. There is not enough emphasis on that aspect in the document or in the discussion more generally.