That is an important point. Cameron Garrett has been a helpful and good member of the NQ group, and it has been good to see him on a weekly basis, alongside colleagues from the Scottish Youth Parliament. Indeed, we commissioned the Scottish Youth Parliament to deliver our learner panel this year. There has therefore been a variety of involvement. I have, of course, had a number of discussions with Cameron Garrett and others in the SYP. I am keen to understand and to take all appropriate steps to ensure that our engagement with young people is as good as it can be.
There are two issues with respect to the appeals process—one around the operation of the NQ group more generally and one around the particular issue that Cameron and SYP colleagues felt so strongly about that Cameron said what he said.
Larry Flanagan highlighted some of the issues in relation to the NQ group. It is a large group with a lot of loud voices and strongly held views. Gill Stewart highlighted the issue of our having to work through some of those complexities and come to agreement, which was sometimes difficult during the course of the year. I think that Larry alluded to that. We have agreed with the Scottish Youth Parliament that we will increase the number of young people on the NQ group this year, which is in train. The number and variety of voices is important, so we will do that. That was good feedback, which we are taking on board.
In relation to the appeals issue specifically, with the enactment of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child and, of course, the Priestley review, and through discussions with Government, there was an expectation that we would introduce a learner right of appeal this year, which we thought was important.
As the committee will know, although appeals previously absolutely involved young people, they were initiated by the school or college; indeed, in previous years, the final decision on whether to institute an appeal was taken through the school or college. This year, we were met with a different set of circumstances in relation to the alternative certification model and the expectation—which was perfectly reasonable—that we would have a learner right of appeal. We thought that it was important that we consulted on that, so we undertook a public consultation on the appeals process this year.
There was a lot of discussion, including learner panel discussion. I attended the learner panel discussion about appeals and, in particular, the symmetry or otherwise of the appeals process—that is, whether appeals should be able to result in not only an upgrade but also, potentially, a downgrade, as well as the grade remaining the same, or whether there should be asymmetry in that the grade should be able only to go up or stay the same. In addition to that, there were issues with respect to exceptional circumstances, which I am happy to go into if the committee wishes.
We had lots of discussions about that. The issue went through the SQA’s governance processes—it went to our board and through our qualifications committee. There were also lots of discussions about it with the Scottish Government. We decided that the appeals process should be symmetric—that is, that grades could, in principle, go up or down or remain the same. Obviously, that position was not supported by the SYP and Cameron Garrett.
However, I was keen to highlight to Cameron that we took the feedback from young people very seriously. There were lots of discussions about that both with them and more widely. We took the decision on the basis of fairness, recognising that it was an evidence-based process. We felt that, if we saw evidence that an award had been given incorrectly as a result of an appeal, we needed to take action. We took the decision on that basis after much consideration.
11:00