I am a professor of healthcare law at University College London. That is my day job but, since April 2020, I have been working with the Ada Lovelace Institute on its projects on the use and governance of vaccination passports.
A key point is the need for clarity on how it is thought that vaccination certification will help society to recover from Covid. There are two main ways in which it might do that. Certification might be a protection measure to try to reduce the spread. If so, we might expect not only vaccination certification but the use of negative test status and proof of previous infection as indicators as to whether it is likely that an individual will pass on the virus. Even if such measures are put in place, that will not make things entirely safe. We know that, even with vaccination passports and testing, about 10 per cent of attendees at the Cornish Boardmasters festival—about 5,000 people—caught the virus.
If vaccination certification is about protection, we need to ensure that it is an effective way of protecting the community from the spread and to be clear about why the particular areas that the proposed scheme focuses on are seen to be more dangerous and so more amenable to increased safety. That is the first way in which it might be useful to use passports.
The second is that passports could operate as an incentive in order to increase vaccination rates. As the committee will know, the vaccination programme in Scotland has been very successful. Vaccination rates are very high among the whole population, but there is an argument that they are lower in the 18 to 29 age group, and most of the proposed venues for certification seem to be popular with that group. In that group, 76 per cent of people have had a first dose, but only 62 per cent are fully vaccinated. However, that group has not had as much time to get vaccinated as others have had.
Vaccination certification could incentivise that group to get vaccinated, but it is also possible that it could increase distrust of the vaccination programme, so it is important to understand why people are hesitant about being vaccinated. The scheme could also give a false sense of security if it is thought that vaccination reduces the need for people to take other protective measures, such as hand washing, social distancing and mask wearing.
Key things came out of the Ada Lovelace Institute’s work on whether vaccination passports were effective in relation to those two main arguments in their favour. We also identified a number of concerns in terms of segregation, stigma and social exclusion, particularly in groups that already suffer other forms of exclusion. I am sure that the other witnesses will say a little bit more about that.
The final point from the Ada Lovelace work is the importance of being very careful about the proportionality test that we need to apply. We cannot really talk sensibly about vaccination passports in the abstract, but we can talk about their use in particular contexts and at particular times.
Scotland’s scheme is focused on particular areas. A sunset clause is proposed, which the institute supports. That would ensure that passports would not be allowed to merge into the infrastructure in the long term. A regular review process is also proposed.
The committee might need to think about whether there are relevant factors around background community infection—the replication rate. There is a reduction of cases in Scotland. That might reduce the need for introducing vaccination certification. That seems to be an important calculation in terms of the work that the Government needs to look at.