It would be fair to say that the licensed trade in general was the sector that was hit hardest in the past 18 months, except, perhaps, for the aviation sector. The businesses in our sector in Scotland are mostly locally owned small businesses that have had zero income for a significant period of time and then, when they were allowed to open, could do so only under restrictions. On average, they were trading at a loss for most of the time that they were open under restrictions, which means that they took less income than the amount that would be required to break even. That varied across the different subsets of hospitality. For example, a restaurant that usually closed at 11 pm and was, therefore, able to trade broadly as it normally would, might have been able to break even, but a nightclub that had to reduce its capacity by 50 or 75 per cent because of all-seated drinking would not have been able to break even, even when it was allowed to open during the restricted periods.
From the surveys that we have done across our membership, we know that the cumulative impact is that, on average, small business owners have taken on a huge amount of debt just to survive the pandemic—to keep their staff employed, the rent paid and the business afloat. For the smallest of pubs and bars, the numbers that we are getting back indicate that those small business owners have taken on debt that is roughly equivalent to three years’ worth of profits in normal times. In other words, they would have to work for three years for free, just to pay the money back. In cash terms, it will vary by the turnover and size of the premises, but a typical small pub or restaurant is likely to be somewhere between £60,000 and £80,000 in debt just now. The larger high street premises or nightclubs are in debt by more than £150,000 per premises. In order to stay afloat, survive and pay down that debt, those venues will need a clear run for years, without restrictions or any type of Government intervention that reduces their turnover or capacity, hence our immense concern about the approach that is being considered, which could have a serious impact on people’s attendance at such premises and, therefore, the turnover that they can achieve.
To say that, by and large, these businesses are in a precarious financial position, would probably be quite a dramatic understatement. They are just not in a position to survive any kind of shock to their income stream and cash flow. The policy that is being considered makes that kind of shock almost inevitable. We would certainly ask for a much greater degree of flexibility and much greater engagement and meaningful consultation with the sector to find workarounds for these problems, rather than having a policy that has been decided before all the implications have been fully thought through imposed on us in just 14 days’ time.