The independent forensic expert group recognised that conversion therapies have
“no medical or scientific validity”,
that there is no sound scientific evidence that conversion therapy in any form is effective in changing LGBTQ+ identities, and that there is
“no medical justification for inflicting on individuals torture or other cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment or punishment.”
We note that there is a united call across the LGBTI sector in Scotland and the rest of the United Kingdom for an end to conversion therapy. We also note that, as the committee has seen in the responses to the call for views, NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, the memorandum of understanding on conversion therapy coalition—the MOU coalition—the Royal College of Psychiatrists, the Royal College of General Practitioners, the Mental Health Foundation, the Equalities and Human Rights Commission, the Scottish Human Rights Commission, Children in Scotland, Amnesty International, the Human Rights Consortium Scotland, the Humanist Society Scotland, the National Secular Society and many religious bodies, including Sukkat Shalom Edinburgh Liberal Jewish Community, the Religious Society of Friends, known as the Quakers, and many smaller Christian denominations, are all in favour of a comprehensive ban.
We hope that the committee will consider holding a private evidence-taking session if there are survivors who need such privacy. Several survivors responded to the call for views. One said:
“I am a victim of a form of conversion therapy. I have struggled with my mental health and made attempts to take my own life. I do not want other ... LGBTQ+ people to go through what I did at school. It is hard to believe that conversion therapy can and does still happen ... Being cast out and isolated had a deep and long lasting impact on me ... Some LGBTQ+ people can be extremely vulnerable and feel isolated because we are already part of a minority and pressure to fit into a religious community can be a powerful driver in people feeling like they should change or suppress the fact they’re LGBTQ+.
I have been so damaged by prayers”.