Cabinet secretary, can you explain why the Scottish Government is using the process that it appears to be using? I am not sure that I fully understand the technical implications of the issue, but the Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee has drawn it to this committee’s attention.
What appears to be happening, unless I have misunderstood it, is that the Scottish ministers propose to engage in what the DPLR Committee described as
“an unusual or unexpected use of”
delegated powers
“conferred on ... Ministers”
by using a power in section 84 of the Criminal Justice (Scotland) Act 2003 to substitute provisions in section 14 of the same act, as amended by the Victims and Witnesses (Scotland) Act 2014. That is not clear, but I hope that it is accurate.
In other words, it appears that delegated powers are being used to expand the scope of ministers’ delegated powers. The DPLR Committee concluded that, while that is “within vires” and is therefore, in its view, lawful, it is nonetheless, as I have just said,
“an unusual or unexpected use of”
delegated powers.
The DPLR Committee went on to say that that is
“something the lead committee”—
namely, the Justice Committee—might wish
“to raise with the relevant minister when taking evidence on the instrument.”
I am therefore raising it now, to get on the record the Scottish Government’s explanation of why it is using that rather convoluted procedure. I hope that I have understood and summarised the points correctly.