To reply to Daniel Johnson’s comment regarding a typical child who potentially has autism spectrum disorder or ADHD and using visual cues as they are a visual learner, I absolutely agree that such strategies are great, but how do we resource them? At the end of the day, they need to be resourced, and they take additional time for teachers. As Ken Muir said, initial teacher education lasts for 36 weeks or whatever, with 18 weeks on a placement. There is a lot for a person to take on board.
However, health and wellbeing is factored into the curriculum for excellence and the national improvement framework, so we all have a duty and responsibility in that regard. Regardless of whether someone is a teacher, a member of support staff or any other member of staff, we should all have an awareness that children will present differently. We are not all born the same way. We all think differently, and we are independent. For children with additional support needs and potentially autism spectrum disorder, their brains are just wired differently. It is not that they cannot do the work; we just need to find an alternative way to switch on that little light bulb and to support those children.
It is not fair to simply dismiss the work that teachers do, or to say, “Well, not all teachers do those things.” We must recognise that a phenomenal number of teachers in Scotland think outside the box and go above and beyond what is expected of them in a school day to support children and young people in their learning.
09:30
We need to think about how we build that collective shared practice, for want of a better term, so that it can be widely recognised as a potential strategy for support. We have the national improvement hub, where Education Scotland stores a lot of its strategies and information for teachers to access. It is open to all. We need to ensure that practice is consistent and that there are places that teachers can go to get information.
On Ross Greer’s point, there is a lack of understanding about co-ordinated support plans. To be honest, not many parents even know that such plans exist—they assume that the child’s plan covers everything. As I said earlier, I travelled across Scotland prior to the publication of the report in order to gather views from parents. When I asked, “Do you know what plan your child has?” the majority of parents said, “No. What is it?” because the plans all have different names. The plan for their child could be a child’s plan, an individual education plan, an additional support for learning plan or, in Falkirk, a form 4 action plan. On the rare occasion that I heard a parent say that they had applied for a co-ordinated support plan, they said that the experience had been challenging and horrific and that there was no joined-up approach.
Parents can see that, regardless of a child’s additional support needs, there are a lot of issues with the CSP. I am very much aware that the co-ordinated support plan is about to be reviewed. Many parents will find that their child meets the first four criteria for the plan, but what always trips them up is the question of what is classified as significant. What does that mean for a parent or a child, an education authority or the wider partners that are involved in the multi-agency approach? In order to move forward, that needs to be clear.
As was mentioned earlier, funding is an issue. I agree with what Andrea Bradley said about whether there could be a holding pattern. If there is a commitment to a CSP, the funding essentially follows the child, whereas all the other plans, although they tick the boxes and put in place support strategies and recommendations, are not legally binding and can therefore be removed at any point.
As parents, we find that the process is a challenge—it becomes a battle or fight. To be quite honest, as a parent, you feel like a washing machine on a rinse-and-repeat cycle. Every year, you go through the same situation—you set out what your child’s issues are and hear, “That’s great—we’ll put something in place.” It then comes down to the fact that the funding is not ring fenced so the support goes, or you lose the member of staff who understands your child. With regard to the questions from Daniel Johnson and Ross Greer, there are multiple factors at play.