Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Petitions

Access to Justice (PE1695)

Thursday 14 January 2021 Equalities and Human Rights Committee About 09:00 Petitions 8 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

8 contributions
Ruth Maguire SNP The Convener · Cunninghame South
link

Our next item of business is consideration of public petitions. I welcome to the meeting David Stewart, who is attending to speak to petition PE1695, on access to justice in Scotland.

Paper 1 relates to correspondence from the Public Petitions Committee, which asks us to identify whether we are in a position to close petitions that have been referred to us before the end of the parliamentary session. If a petition is not closed before the end of the parliamentary session, it will carry over to our successor committee in the next session. If a petition is closed, petitioners can lodge a petition in the same or similar terms in the next parliamentary session.

The note by the clerks outlines our anticipated work programme for the remainder of the session. Members will wish to take account of that in considering what action to take on the petitions that are before us.

Are members content that, in considering the petitions and our response to the Public Petitions Committee’s correspondence, the response is issued between the committee clerks? I see that members are content with that.

We will now turn to the referred petitions. I propose to consider first petition, PE1695, on access to justice in Scotland, to allow David Stewart to participate before he has to leave to attend another committee meeting. I refer members to paper 3 in our meeting pack.

We last considered the petition in March 2020, when we agreed to keep it open until the Scottish Government published its response to its consultation on legal aid reform in Scotland. That response was published in June. The Scottish Government has indicated its on-going engagement with stakeholders with a view to bringing forward legislative reform.

Before I invite comments from members, I invite David Stewart to say a few words on behalf of the petitioners.

David Stewart Lab Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you very much, convener. I thank all members of the committee for allowing me to speak again in support of petition PE1695 and for taking me early. I am a substitute on the COVID-19 Committee today, so I have to disappear very quickly.

Mr and Mrs Mundell have made a submission, which I received last night. With the convener’s permission, I will pass that submission to the clerks; perhaps it could be dealt with from there. Mr and Mrs Mundell hope to watch the broadcast on the live stream.

When I addressed the committee in March last year, I was very impressed and, indeed, comforted by the support for the petition that was shown by all members. I will summarise my remarks from the last time.

The simplistic answer to the question how ordinary families on a modest income seek redress and justice is that they have to go through the Scottish legal system. However, there are three problems with that answer. The first is that the vast majority of law firms will not deal with human rights cases. The evidence that I gave for that was that Mr and Mrs Mundell contacted more than 50 firms throughout Scotland without success.

The second problem is that even the law firms that deal with such cases deal only with prisoners’ or immigration issues.

Even if the first two problems are overcome, the third problem is that many law firms require substantial up-front payments. For example, one lawyer whom the Mundells contacted wanted an up-front payment of £25,000 before proceeding. At the time, that represented double the family’s annual disposable income.

Since the committee’s most recent consideration of the petition, Judith Robertson, who, as chair of the Scottish Human Rights Commission, is known to all members of the committee, had a meeting with me on Zoom to discuss the matter, for which I thank her. When I appeared before the committee last year, I quoted what she said at Westminster about human rights, and I will do so again. She said:

“It is difficult for anybody to take a case in Scotland. As I said, we have no power to support anybody to do that; in fact, we are expressly disallowed.”

I endorse the two statements that I made previously. As a Parliament, why do we not give the SHRC the power to take up human rights cases? As the convener knows, human rights are a Scottish Parliament responsibility, which is administered by the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body. Could the committee write to the Scottish Government? Given that the election is coming up in May, or at some later date, in my view, it would be an excellent manifesto commitment for all political parties to look at the issue.

In conclusion, although, on the surface, the petition appears very complicated, it is, in fact, not complicated. It is about enabling families who are on modest incomes to get to first base in our justice system.

Ruth Maguire SNP The Convener · Cunninghame South
link

Thank you. I invite comments from committee members.

Mary Fee Lab West Scotland
link

I thank Mr Stewart for his input and for the support that he has given to the Mundells in taking forward the petition. I am grateful for his input.

We have a number of options open to us. I am keen for us to write to the Government to seek an update on the legislative reform that it intends to carry out. I think that we have taken the petition as far as we can, so I suggest that we close it, seek an update from the Government on its legislative reform and notify the petitioners that, if that legislative reform is not satisfactory, they can raise another petition.

I also think that there is some merit in the suggestion that Mr Stewart made about the Scottish Human Rights Commission, so perhaps we could pursue that, too, if we are able to.

Alexander Stewart Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I acknowledge the work that David Stewart has put in on the petition, and I concur with what Mary Fee said about our writing to the Government—I think that it would be appropriate for us to do that. I also think that we should consider going down the avenue of the Scottish Human Rights Commission in the future.

Joe FitzPatrick SNP Dundee City West
link

I welcome the fact that the Government has indicated its intention to introduce legislative reform, and I concur with the points that others have made.

Alison Harris Con Central Scotland
link

I, too, agree with the comments that have been made by my colleagues.

Ruth Maguire SNP The Convener · Cunninghame South
link

If we agree to close the petition, we can still write to the Scottish Government and note the petitioners’ continuing concerns and the representations that David Stewart has made. The petitioners will have the option of submitting an updated petition in the same or similar terms at the start of the next parliamentary session.

It sounds to me very much as though the committee is of one mind and that we will close the petition and write to the Scottish Government to raise the concerns that have been expressed. I can see nodding faces, but I will wait for a moment in case anyone wishes to dissent from that position.

It is agreed that we will close the petition and write to the Scottish Government.

  1. 09:00 Interests Procedure · 3
  2. 09:00 Petitions Petitions · 8
  3. 09:00 Petitions Petitions · 3
  4. 09:00 Petitions Petitions · 4
  5. 09:00 Petitions Petitions · 4
  6. 09:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.