The starting point is that, at this stage, Social Security Scotland does not measure its overall error rates. We highlight in the report the need for it to build up the capacity to do that and start publishing the information.
To go back to your initial question, we do not know from our overall assessment whether error and fraud rates in the benefits that Social Security Scotland administers are in line with, or vastly different from, the DWP’s experience.
For the benefits that Social Security Scotland administers for the DWP, it relies on the United Kingdom-wide figures that the DWP prepares. That is the basis for our qualification in the report. Importantly, Social Security Scotland does not yet do the necessary work to undertake its own estimates. It is building up the capacity to do that, in the way that we have set out in the report.
Separately, Social Security Scotland does some targeted work to look at high-risk areas. It goes in to see whether the front-line processing has picked up what needs to happen in those areas, and, where there has been error or suspected fraud, whether that has been dealt with at the front line. If it has not, the agency corrects at that point. That is targeted, risk-based work, but we are unable to extrapolate the results to cover the overall population because it is focused only on high-risk areas.
From our perspective, the key point is that, at this stage, Social Security Scotland cannot tell the committee or Audit Scotland what its overall error rates are for the benefits that it administers directly. We make it clear in the report that it is important that Social Security Scotland begins to build up the capacity to do that.