Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 22 Reports

“The 2019/20 audit of Social Security Scotland”

Thursday 10 December 2020 Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee About 11:00–11:45 Evidence session 81 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

81 contributions
Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Item 4 is an evidence session on the section 22 report, “The 2019/20 audit of Social Security Scotland”. I welcome our witnesses from Audit Scotland: Stephen Boyle, the Auditor General for Scotland; Mark Taylor, audit director; and Carole Grant, senior audit manager, audit services. Mark Taylor and Carole Grant are appearing remotely.

I understand that the Auditor General will make an opening statement on the report.

Stephen Boyle
link

The report updates the committee on the findings from the 2019-20 audit of Social Security Scotland. It brings to your attention the appointed auditor’s qualified opinion on the regularity of the 2019-20 accounts. It also provides an update on the progress that Social Security Scotland has made on establishing its error and fraud management arrangements. The appointed auditor has given an unqualified opinion on the information that is reported in the financial statements, which means that he is content that they show a true and fair view and follow all relevant accounting standards and rules.

The qualification relates to the estimated levels of fraud and error of £14.8 million in carers allowance expenditure, which is 5.2 per cent of the total benefit. That expenditure is not in line with the relevant legislation.

Carers allowance is being delivered by the Department for Work and Pensions on the Scottish Government’s behalf, through an agency agreement. Social Security Scotland is reliant on the DWP’s estimates of error and fraud. It is important for Social Security Scotland to understand the levels of error and fraud in all the benefits that it administers. With a range of benefit delivery arrangements in place, the impact of error and fraud will remain an audit risk.

Social Security Scotland has strengthened its arrangements for the prevention and detection of error and fraud over the past year and has increased staffing in line with workforce plans. Further development is needed in some key areas, including on-going development of digital systems, guidance on determining residency and establishing the agency’s own arrangements for estimating and reporting on error and fraud within the Scottish system.

My report also looks ahead to issues and challenges for Social Security Scotland due to the Covid-19 pandemic. The agency is now responsible for a range of complex and high-value benefits, and the continuing impact of the pandemic increases uncertainty and financial risk in an already challenging environment. The implications of changes to delivery timelines, arrangements for benefit delivery and benefit eligibility and uptake rates will be complex to manage. Social Security Scotland has adapted quickly to the immediate operational challenges of the pandemic, allowing it to maintain the administration of benefits while addressing the safe working of its staff. We will continue to assess the detail of those arrangements through our audit work.

Mark Taylor, Carole Grant and I are happy to answer questions.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I would like to get more clarity around the error and fraud team. The section 22 report is about the levels of error and fraud in the system. Are we more or less comparable with the rest of the United Kingdom in terms of benefit fraud levels?

Stephen Boyle
link

The picture is undoubtedly complex. I will ask Carole Grant to give more detail about the progress that the agency has made in increasing the number of people whom it employs and how that is working in relation to error and fraud work.

In a UK context, error and fraud have always been a feature for organisations that make benefit payments. For example, the committee will be familiar with the fact that the National Audit Office has qualified the DWP’s accounts for 31 successive years due to levels of error and fraud in a range of its benefits.

Our assessment is that Social Security Scotland has made progress in relation to upskilling, recruitment and error and fraud activity, but that risks remain, particularly as—because of the pandemic—there is some interruption to the pace at which it becomes responsible for some benefits. However, error and fraud is a key factor that it needs to challenge. It would be useful for Carole Grant give a bit more detail about how that is working.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Before she does so, I am unclear from the report whether we have a firm figure for the level of fraud. Paragraph 25 of the report states that:

“Targeted sampling indicated that around 75 per cent of errors had already been identified and corrected.”

Paragraph 20 states that

“DWP and HMRC estimates of error and fraud ... range from 3.9 per cent to 9.4 per cent”,

which is a heck of a margin, given the figures that are being handled. Do we know what the level of fraud in Scotland is?

Stephen Boyle
link

No, we do not, although we would all like that level of precision. There will always be estimates of the level of fraud in relation to any benefit, and it is undoubtedly a complex area. However, we have better estimates this year, particularly in relation to carers allowance. As Mr Beattie and the committee may recall from our discussion last year, the estimated levels of error and fraud in carers allowance payments dated to back to activity in the mid-1990s. We have seen progress on that front this year, which allows us to be more certain about the levels of fraud in the Scottish system, and which has a bearing on the qualification that we put on the accounts.

Although we say that progress has been made, we have tried to quantify elsewhere in the report that, as the Scottish social security agency assumes more responsibilities during 2021, the levels of error and fraud are still estimates. That is important in relation to the work that Social Security Scotland has done with its own team to provide estimates that are reliable for the agency and around which it can target its activity to tackle levels of error and fraud.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I am just trying to get my head around that. Targeted sampling indicates that 75 per cent of errors are being identified, and the DWP and HMRC are looking at error and fraud rates that range between 3.9 and 9.4 per cent. I presume that that estimate comes after the sampling that indicates that 75 per cent of errors are being picked up. That would indicate that about 25 per cent of the errors and fraud that are taking place are rolled up somewhere in that very wide range of 3.9 to 9.4 per cent.

Stephen Boyle
link

The 3.9 to 9.4 per cent range covers the estimates against the individual benefits that are set out in paragraph 20; the estimates therefore vary depending on the benefit. I think that it would be helpful to pause for a second and allow Carole Grant to set out in a bit more detail how the intervention team is working and how that ultimately translates into the reliability of the estimates and what that means for—Interruption.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I would like at some point to better understand the wide range of figures and its implications for the sampling.

Carole Grant Audit Scotland
link

I am happy to come in on that point. As the Auditor General said, the arrangements for dealing with fraud and error in Social Security Scotland have been strengthened. Specifically in relation to the 75 per cent figure that has been quoted, the interventions team that has been established did a specific data mining exercise within which it found an error rate of 43 per cent; however, of the errors, 75 per cent had already been identified and were being addressed. That shows the difference between detailed data mining and the error detection rules and processes that are already in place.

11:15

We are seeing—and we need to see this—a move away from detection and towards prevention, in order to ensure that the amounts are paid correctly in the first place. Social Security Scotland is working on developing that approach further.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

For clarification, your starting point is that there is a 43 per cent possibility of error and fraud, which is eventually whittled down to between 3.9 per cent and 9.4 per cent. That seems extraordinary. Is that what you are saying?

Carole Grant Audit Scotland
link

No—you are picking up figures from different parts of the report that do not necessarily come together in that way. The 43 per cent that I mentioned related to a specific exercise in Social Security Scotland; it refers to the real errors that were identified.

The rates in the other paragraph of the report that has been mentioned are DWP estimates for the overall benefits system. We are talking about some specifics that sit alongside estimates for what happens elsewhere in the system.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Putting the other figures aside, you said that 43 per cent of benefit payments—the figure is presumably based on some sort of sampling—were found to involve potential error or fraud, and that proactive action had to be taken to bring that number down. That indicates a colossal level of error and fraud. Carrying out an on-going exercise to bring the figure down to what we would hope would be an acceptable level would be a significant task.

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

The starting point is that, at this stage, Social Security Scotland does not measure its overall error rates. We highlight in the report the need for it to build up the capacity to do that and start publishing the information.

To go back to your initial question, we do not know from our overall assessment whether error and fraud rates in the benefits that Social Security Scotland administers are in line with, or vastly different from, the DWP’s experience.

For the benefits that Social Security Scotland administers for the DWP, it relies on the United Kingdom-wide figures that the DWP prepares. That is the basis for our qualification in the report. Importantly, Social Security Scotland does not yet do the necessary work to undertake its own estimates. It is building up the capacity to do that, in the way that we have set out in the report.

Separately, Social Security Scotland does some targeted work to look at high-risk areas. It goes in to see whether the front-line processing has picked up what needs to happen in those areas, and, where there has been error or suspected fraud, whether that has been dealt with at the front line. If it has not, the agency corrects at that point. That is targeted, risk-based work, but we are unable to extrapolate the results to cover the overall population because it is focused only on high-risk areas.

From our perspective, the key point is that, at this stage, Social Security Scotland cannot tell the committee or Audit Scotland what its overall error rates are for the benefits that it administers directly. We make it clear in the report that it is important that Social Security Scotland begins to build up the capacity to do that.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

What about the 43 per cent figure?

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

When the agency has done its targeted work, it undertakes the corrections for the instances that it has come across. From those areas, it will learn what is happening around the processes so that it can correct and strengthen them. The figure of 43 per cent, with 25 per cent of errors not identified, is a small amount in the overall sense and helps the agency to understand—

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

You have now brought in a figure of 25 per cent.

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

I was referring to the fact that Social Security Scotland found 75 per cent of the errors at the front line, on the first go, which leaves 25 per cent—

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

So there is the 75 per cent within the 43 per cent, and the 25 per cent—

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

I am sorry—I am not following where the 43 per cent comes in.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

If I may interrupt, there seems to be quite a lot of confusion here about the figures, so I wonder whether Carole Grant could write to the committee and explain the matter a bit better. Might that be helpful?

Carole Grant Audit Scotland
link

Yes—I am happy to do that.

Stephen Boyle
link

Yes—we can do that, convener. I guess the point is that there is still a wide range of estimates within the level of benefits within Social Security Scotland and those that are provided on its behalf by the DWP. Social Security Scotland is making progress, but it is early days, in terms of its own capability, for it to undertake the level of fraud and error investigation that it will ultimately need to, once it assumes responsibility for all the benefits in its gift.

We are happy to come back to the committee on the specifics of how the methodology is developing.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Thank you, Auditor General.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Your report indicated that the error and fraud team was being expanded. You said that it would be up to 47 full-time equivalents by March 2020, and eventually 190 FTE. Did the agency achieve 47 FTE by March?

Stephen Boyle
link

We report that the team increased from 17 to more than 40 full-time equivalents by the end of March, with plans for further expansion. However, those plans will depend on how the pandemic has impacted on the agency’s ability to recruit over the period.

That work is a key part of the agency’s business, so it needs to, and has plans to, increase its capability. It is taking steps, although it has much to do to get to a place where it has all the ability and authority itself to undertake the level of error and fraud prevention work that it needs to do.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Are you satisfied that the training and policies that are being put into place are adequate and appropriate for what is required, and that the staff are properly supported and equipped for the job?

Stephen Boyle
link

I have a two-part answer to that question. The agency has made progress. At paragraph 22 of our report, we mention the strategies that it has implemented: the error control strategy and the counter-fraud strategy, as well as new arrangements for investigations, all of which are welcome. The agency had planned to engage with the UK Cabinet Office, drawing on its expertise around error and fraud prevention during the year, but those plans were interrupted as a result of the pandemic. Such skills transfer and knowledge transfer are key if Social Security Scotland is to build up its own capacity around error and fraud prevention during 2021.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Good morning, panel, and thank you for joining us.

The report says that there are “ongoing weaknesses” within the agency’s core case management system. Could you tell us what those weaknesses are?

Stephen Boyle
link

I ask Carole Grant to set out the progress that the agency has made on its digital infrastructure.

Carole Grant Audit Scotland
link

In our report, we pick up on the fact that there are manual controls within the system, which form part of the process of a minimum viable product in system development. I can confirm that audit testing during the year confirmed that the system controls were operating effectively. Manual controls are more reliant on individuals, and there is more risk of them not being consistently applied. That is why we would look for system controls to be in place. However, we identified the control environment to be operating effectively.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Are you expecting the system controls all to go digital at a certain point? Do we have a timescale for that?

Carole Grant Audit Scotland
link

We do not have a specific timescale. The system is being continually improved as part of the agile approach to system development and as new benefits come in. There is a continual learning cycle within that.

We would like to see some of the manual controls replaced with system controls. However, we are content with the overall control environment.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Does the digital system have any cost overruns? I am thinking back to other public sector information technology systems that did not go as well as planned.

Carole Grant Audit Scotland
link

I do not have any information on that. Does Mark Taylor have anything to add from the programme side?

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

The committee will be aware that we have reported on the progress of the overall programme a number of times. When we last looked in depth at that, the overall cost levels were not a challenge, but we said that it was important that the programme was able to set out its longer-term plans—there has been significant progress on that—and translate that work into cost plans, on which there has also been progress. As the Auditor General mentioned, we are considering our future work programme and we expect that continuing work on social security will be part of that. We will continue to update the committee as we do that work.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

There seems to be good progress being made. Do you foresee any challenges or issues coming down the line in relation to the digital system?

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

It is still a big job; clarity about the order in which things are done and the arrangements that are in place is fundamentally important in what is a very complex set of relationships, including the relationships with the DWP and a range of suppliers. There is much work still to do on all that, but we are not aware of any red flags at the moment. We will continue to do the detailed work that we have planned on that issue and will report to the committee in due course.

Stephen Boyle
link

I will briefly come in on that issue. At last week’s meeting, the committee took evidence from the Scottish Government on its major IT infrastructure projects, in which the social security digital programme features prominently. Social Security Scotland is included in the infrastructure that the Scottish Government is deploying around its assurance activity. There is a clear focus on the need for that to go well, but assurance activity is built into that process.

Graham Simpson Con Central Scotland
link

I want to be clear that, in relation to error and fraud in carers allowance, Social Security Scotland is reliant on the estimates from the DWP—is that still the case?

Stephen Boyle
link

Yes, that is still the case. Those estimates were updated during 2019-20. I mentioned the reliability of the estimates that had been in place, which dated back to the mid-1990s. Those were updated during the past financial year, which allowed it to be a more accurate assessment of the level of error and fraud.

Graham Simpson Con Central Scotland
link

Earlier, Mark Taylor said, I think, that Social Security Scotland is not yet in a position to publish its own error rate. Am I right in thinking that that is down to a lack of staff?

Stephen Boyle
link

That is a planned project and a planned growth that assumes responsibility for the range of benefits that are coming to Scotland. Part of that has been interrupted by the pandemic. We set out at exhibit 1 in the report—it may be helpful for the committee to look at the exhibit—the waves of benefits that have come to Scotland, what the anticipated timeline was before the pandemic and what it is now. Alongside your question about Social Security Scotland’s capacity to undertake error and fraud evaluation work, the pace of that work, as it has received competence to deliver the benefits, has also been slightly interrupted. Those things will happen in tandem. The agency has made progress and it has increased the number of people in its error and fraud team. The training and support that it had planned did not take place and will now happen during 2021. As the agency’s capacity grows, it will assume responsibility from DWP for that work.

Graham Simpson Con Central Scotland
link

If it has all those new people, what are they doing if they are not producing an error rate? What are they working on? Are they constantly doing training?

11:30

Stephen Boyle
link

It is more than that. We set out in paragraph 23 the main responsibilities that the team is undertaking. Investigations, training and recovery activity are all factors in the team’s work. As ever, if the committee wants more specifics, Social Security Scotland is well placed to provide an update on how the division of responsibilities is operating.

Graham Simpson Con Central Scotland
link

To be fair, that question is not for you; it is for Social Security Scotland.

At paragraph 11, the report says that there has been an estimated £14.8 million of overpayments in relation to carers allowance. How was that figure arrived at?

Stephen Boyle
link

I am happy to start, but I will ask Mark Taylor to say how we arrived at that figure. That builds on your previous question about use of the DWP’s estimates of the level of fraud and error related to carers allowance. The report talks about the split that is assumed between error and fraud rates. I will ask Mark Taylor to say a bit more.

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

The DWP’s fundamental process of measuring and estimating its error rates is based on a review of a statistically valid sample of cases. It investigates the circumstances of the individual cases for each benefit, including carers allowance, and then tries to confirm retrospectively the evidence base for the award of the benefit. On many occasions, that includes talking to the individuals concerned and obtaining proof of employment, income levels and other factors. There is quite a detailed review of that sample, from which the figures for the wider population at UK level are extrapolated.

As the Auditor General said, that had not been done for carers allowance for a long time; it has been updated only in the past year. We have relied on that estimate to provide an appropriate view on the level of error in Scotland. The figure of £14.8 million is about 5.2 per cent of the total spend on carers allowance this year. It is an estimate based on a UK-wide figure. We think that there is a clear enough case for that to be brought to the committee’s attention, because there is a material and significant level of non-compliance with the underlying benefit legislation. That is what we have reported in the audit and certificate.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

I will ask about the accounting. If you paid out £100 and estimated that £5 of that related to fraud or error, would you set up a recoverable amount of £5 and reduce that as you collected the money back or decided that it was irrecoverable. Is that what happens?

Stephen Boyle
link

Effectively. Mark Taylor will say more about that.

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

In a very broad sense, you recognise the expenditure of £100 until you identify the specific error or fraud of £5. You then identify that as a debt and collect it. Of course, not every individual case is identified so, alongside that, there is a set of provisions and estimates for the overall effect of errors. All that plays through into the aggregate spending figure. We have looked at the details and are happy with the overall accounting approach that sits behind the figures.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

Could you clarify that? If you pay out £100 and then estimate that £5 should not have been paid out, do you set up an amount recoverable for that?

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

To clarify, you account for the £100, because that is what you have paid out. That is the very short and simple version of what happens. Separately, when you identify specific overpayments, you set up a debtor for that overpayment and, in effect, reduce the £100 for the specific overpayments, but not for the overall—

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

Why would you not rely on your estimates of fraud and error rates and do that when you pay out, rather than deal with it on a cash basis when you get the money back later on?

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

It is largely because you do not expect to recover all of that.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

In which case, you would have a different—

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

You can only recover the specific debt that you have identified for individuals who have been overpaid, .

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

It seems that there is something missing. If you know that there is an error, based on your best estimates, the person looking at the financial statements would be interested to know how much of that you think that you will get back. You would judge that some of that will never be recovered, so you would reduce the amount. However, it seems that what is happening is an easy way of kicking the issue down the road until you find something and then taking the cash you get when you get it.

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

In essence, what you described is what happens. However, it happens in a very detailed way; I am happy to go into that.

The key issue that has been recognised is the amount of public expenditure cash that has been paid out—irrespective of whether that was paid out as a result of error and fraud. That figure is recognised as the cost to the public purse. When you recover that, you would recognise the recovery.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

That means you are losing control over the management, are you not? Social Security Scotland does not have to account for what it thinks the error rate is; it only lets the amount go down until it is collected—at which point, everyone is happy because some money is coming in.

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

That is absolutely the case, and it is why we are strongly of the view that it is important to measure and report on overall error levels. Our qualifying the accounts is one measure of that, but the most important one is the agency’s own assessment of error rates and what it is doing to manage them, and similarly what the DWP’s assessment is and what approach it is taking. We look to continue with that message.

Neil Bibby Lab West Scotland
link

We have just discussed the impact of Covid on eligibility for and uptake of benefits. The number of households in Scotland that receive universal credit has increased from just under 250,000 to just under 500,000.

It is important to understand the impact of increased eligibility and uptake on Scottish benefits. That remains uncertain, but it would be helpful to understand the problems more fully. Could you talk us through, in detail, the difficulties in assessing the impact of that and also indicate when we might get a clearer picture of that impact?

Stephen Boyle
link

I will start, and in a moment I will ask Mark Taylor to come in to set out in a bit more detail the pandemic’s possible implications for the Scottish budget.

We agree that many of the benefits of universal credit are, effectively, passported benefits that flow through to eligibility for some of the benefits that will be captured in Social Security Scotland’s accounts. In the report, we touched on the scale of the numbers that the relative increase in universal credit claimants, caused by the pandemic, has had.

We flowed through what that might mean for the Scottish child payment, as an example. The Scottish Fiscal Commission’s estimates say that in 2021-22 alone there will be an increase in child payment amounts from £65 million to £77 million. The forecast that the Fiscal Commission made and what that means to the impact on the Scottish budget will be captured in the budget when it comes to Parliament in January.

It is undoubtedly true that the situation introduces more volatility into the Scottish budget and is important with regard to the distinction between the Scottish-only benefit arrangements and those that are UK-wide and administered on the behalf of the DWP. Social Security Scotland will bear the risk of the Scottish-only benefits through the implications on its budget.

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

In answer to the question on when we will know more and what we already know, we start with the expectation—as you do, Mr Bibby—that the increase in universal credit, which has been hugely significant in volume, will ultimate play through into passported benefits. It is fair to say that, based on our information from Social Security Scotland—it will be able to provide more up-to-date information on this—we are not seeing that significantly being the case so far. Of course we would expect a degree of lag where lots of people who perhaps are unfamiliar with the benefits system are applying to it and taking advantage of the support that is available for the first time. It will take a little time to work through that and understand what else might be linked to it. Our information is that that is not pulling through in high volumes yet.

As the Auditor General says, the Scottish Fiscal Commission has as a key part of its remit the responsibility for forecasting likely benefits expenditure. It has been unable to update its forecast as a result of the pandemic, but we would expect that, when the Scottish budget is published in the new year, the Fiscal Commission will provide the updated forecast of both what the impact has been in the current financial year and what the likely impact is in the future. At that point, we will get more information and more of a sense of the overall impact of the pandemic.

Lastly, as the Auditor General has said, the extent to which that hits the Scottish budget depends on whether there is an equivalent UK benefit. For the Scottish-only benefits, all the costs fall within the Scottish budget, so, if demand goes up, there is more cost to be borne in the Scottish budget. For the benefits that have a UK equivalent, what matters is the relative uptake—the relative cost per head at an England and Wales level and at a Scottish level. That is much harder to predict, so, where you expect benefit costs to go up, the funding that is available through the block grant adjustment might well go up to the same extent, or indeed it might go up more or less than that. The Fiscal Commission forecast will give more insight into that.

Neil Bibby Lab West Scotland
link

That is helpful. Thanks for that answer.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I have a quick question. When I was social justice secretary, between 2014 and 2016—perhaps I should declare this as an interest—I had responsibility for initiating the discussions on the process that would be used for transferring benefits. The single biggest issue was the computer systems that were used by the DWP. They were like a penny farthing bike, when a Lamborghini was needed.

Auditor General, where do we stand in terms of Social Security Scotland’s future IT capacity and the DWP’s capacity? Both are needed to make the proper transfer of responsibility. If we get additional benefits, could they be much more easily and timeously transferred now than then, without IT being a barrier to doing so?

Stephen Boyle
link

I will start and then ask Carole Grant and Mark Taylor to comment on how that is progressing in the agency.

The committee will know that we have touched on the importance of effective IT arrangements—across the piece, but undoubtedly for this project. One finding in our report from 2019 that provided an update on progress was on IT systems and the sense that the arrangements between the Scottish Government project team and the agency were not as cohesive as they needed to be. We have undoubtedly seen progress on that front during the year. Importantly, users in Social Security Scotland are shaping and are more involved in the process of how IT will work within the agency. That is welcome, and more on that is captured in the report.

Carole Grant can update the committee on progress relating to the process of benefit transfer and how those connections between DWP and Social Security Scotland are working.

Carole Grant Audit Scotland
link

We are seeing a development in the relationship. As part of the performance audit work, which was paused as a result of the Covid-19 pandemic, we did some direct work with the Department for Work and Pensions as well as Social Security Scotland. We heard from both sides that the relationship was in a good place and that both were actively involved in discussions about how they can move forward and what will make the case transfer work. Some of that was covered in what the Auditor General said about improvements in the relationship between the programme and Social Security Scotland. We have also seen improvements in the other, wider relationships that need to be in place as we move down this road.

11:45

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

I will add to that briefly, to recognise the point that Mr Neil made. The interplay between DWP systems and Scottish systems is absolutely still part of the critical decision-making process. We are aware of, and have reported on, the reliance that the agency and the Scottish Government continues to place on DWP systems.

We are also aware that, for example, when the cabinet secretary, Ms Somerville, made an announcement about disability benefits in November, a key judgment that she would have made, and a key part of the programme’s work, would have been to agree with the DWP the path to readiness on that. The committee will see from her announcement some areas in which she added caveats, because that process has not yet been fully nailed down. In other areas, though, it has been clear that both parties are ready to go, which is an important part of the process.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I have a couple of questions on that area. Social Security Scotland is a new agency so, in addition to the work that it does, which we have been discussing today, it is of interest in itself. It is of particular interest to me because it is based in Dundee. How many people are currently employed by the agency?

Stephen Boyle
link

I will definitely have to pass the specifics of that over to my colleagues. You will have seen that the agency has been visible about setting up its headquarters in Dundee, with its new waterfront building. I will check with my colleagues whether we know how many people it currently employs.

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

Yes, I will come in on that one. To quote the numbers from the audited accounts at the end of March, 666 individuals and a full-time equivalent staff of 647 people were employed at that point. There were also around 75 full-time equivalent interim workers.

We know that since then, after pausing it for a short period in March as a result of Covid, the agency has been able to resume its recruitment process. We also know that, during that period, around 400 staff have been recruited in addition to the 666 since that period. Therefore, despite the pandemic, there has been a real gearing-up. The convener will know that there is still a long way to go on employment overall, but the agency has continued to build up its capacity. That is largely in anticipation of the further benefits that it will administer. There is a timetable for the disability benefits that have already been planned. Most pressingly, applications for the Scottish child payment are already open and payments will begin in the new year.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

You are telling me that more than a thousand people are employed by Social Security Scotland. Is that correct?

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

Yes.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Can you tell me how many are employed in the Dundee area?

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

I am afraid that I do not have that information, although perhaps I should have had it with me today, convener. However, we can certainly investigate it with the agency and confirm it to you.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Okay. I would really appreciate it if you could come back to me on that.

I am also interested in where the senior jobs are located. One concern is that we were promised such jobs in the local area, but some of us understand that many of them are located in Glasgow. I would quite like to have a breakdown of where they are located. Obviously, that becomes more complex in light of the Covid pandemic, because people are now working from home. One of the reasons for my question is to get an idea of how that affects our local economy in Dundee. I would like to know how many of the jobs that we were promised are located locally and how many have been spread across the country. If you could come back to me in writing on that, I would be very grateful.

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

We will investigate that with the agency and come back to you.

Stephen Boyle
link

You are right, convener. I was just going to say that the situation is currently much more fluid and so it is much harder to say that with any certainty, in light of the pandemic and the working-from-home arrangements that have been in place. We have seen that organisations—Social Security Scotland included—have been able to function through the use of such arrangements. However, there is less certainty in their being able to predict where people’s bases might be, and that information might not then translate into what their being in a city could mean for the local economy. It is probably a matter on which Social Security Scotland rather than Audit Scotland should update the committee, because it would be able to do so with a bit more certainty.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Perhaps Audit Scotland could give me the information that it has. I understand that the figure of 1,000 jobs represents the total across the country, but I would be interested to know how many of those are held by people who have addresses in the Tayside area.

There is also a huge question about site 6, which was the flagship building for the country. As you said, Auditor General, it is directly across from the Victoria and Albert museum and was extremely expensive for the local authority. The unforeseen circumstances of the Covid pandemic have meant that that building is probably not being used much at the moment, but I wonder what the agency’s plans are for making use of it in the future, when things return to normal. However, perhaps we could pick up all those questions with the agency.

No member has indicated that they wish to raise any further points on the section 22 report with the Auditor General and his team. I thank all our witnesses for their evidence. I now close the public session of our meeting.

11:51 Meeting continued in private until 12:08.

  1. Interests Procedure · 3
  2. Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  3. Section 22 Reports Committee business · 110
  4. 11:00 Section 22 Reports Evidence session · 81

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.