Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Tuesday 4 September 2007 European and External Relations Committee Procedure 25 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Showing Jackie Baillie only · show everyone

Jackie Baillie’s contributions

14 contributions
Jackie Baillie Lab The Convener · Dumbarton
link

Welcome to the third meeting of the European and External Relations Committee in the third session of the Scottish Parliament. Before we start, I introduce to members our new assistant clerk, Lucy Scharbert, who joined us this week. I record our thanks to Lewis McNaughton, who has left us to undertake a secondment at the National Assembly for Wales—so we will get him back at some point. I have received apologies from Alex Neil, so I welcome Keith Brown, who is attending in his capacity as committee substitute. I also welcome Margo MacDonald, who has a keen interest in matters European and wants to contribute later in the meeting.We have only one agenda item to consider today—our work programme, which we need to agree formally. Today's meeting follows our discussions at the committee away day—all our considerations are contained in the paper that is before members. It might be helpful if I briefly remind members what we agreed, because there have been additions to the recommendations. First, in relation to paragraph 19, three members—Irene Oldfather, Alex Neil and Iain Smith—have agreed to act as reporters on developing the recommendations in the report into scrutiny of European legislation. We will return to that matter when we consider paragraph 19 later.On paragraph 43, on scrutiny of the Executive's international relations policies, we agreed to wait until the Scottish Executive has concluded its internal review of existing strategies and agreements before we look at how we want to scrutinise such issues in our work programme.The committee agreed at the away day to undertake an inquiry into international development and we agreed to explore that remit with a number of stakeholders on 2 October. I will reconfirm that with members later.We also agreed to undertake a mapping exercise on the European and international political organisations that include MSPs representing Parliament, including the current method of accountability, following the recommendation at paragraph 47.Finally, on our consideration of the Scottish Executive's white paper on independence, the committee was firmly of the view that although we want to scrutinise the white paper, we should in the first instance write to the First Minister for clarification of which Scottish minister will be in charge of the white paper; what the intended progress will be; what the format for consultation will be; and what will be the timescale, including for any legislation that is required. Once we have received that response, the committee will be better able to scope out the nature of the inquiry that we want to have.I now invite members to consider the recommendations that are in bold type. First, does the committee agree to the recommendation in paragraph 12?Members indicated agreement.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Convener · Dumbarton
link

Does the committee agree to the recommendation in paragraph 17, to invite the minister to the committee?Members indicated agreement.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Convener · Dumbarton
link

Does the committee agree to the recommendation in paragraph 19, to appoint as reporters three of our number?Members indicated agreement.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Convener · Dumbarton
link

Do we agree to the recommendation in paragraph 27?Members indicated agreement.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Convener · Dumbarton
link

Excellent. This will be the quickest committee meeting in history.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Convener · Dumbarton
link

We have already covered paragraph 39 with the supplementary information that I provided. Subject to that, are members content with the recommendation?Members indicated agreement.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Convener · Dumbarton
link

We have also covered paragraph 43 with supplementary information. Do members agree to the recommendation?Members indicated agreement.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Convener · Dumbarton
link

We have considered paragraph 45 and have resolved to write to the First Minister about the issue with which it deals. I believe that the letter is before members. Is the recommendation in paragraph 45 agreed to?Members indicated agreement.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Convener · Dumbarton
link

Now that we have agreed the committee's work programme, I invite Margo MacDonald to speak to us. She is a welcome attendee at our meeting.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Convener · Dumbarton
link

Indeed. Before I bring in other members, it might be helpful to point out that we have a European officer, who monitors and tracks a number of pieces of legislation. Part of his responsibility to the committee and to the Parliament is to track the European Union constitution. Margo MacDonald will be pleased to hear that that is already within the scope of the committee's work. I am sure that additional information on progress of the reform treaty can be provided to members of the committee and to MSPs more generally.Margo MacDonald is right that the issue is on our agenda, in the sense that the minister will appear before us on 18 September, when the Executive's priorities for the EU will be laid out. I am sure that the EU constitution will form part of the range of priorities about which members will want to question the minister. Any member of the Parliament can attend our meetings and if Margo MacDonald is free on 18 September, we look forward to welcoming her along.Do members have any comments or views?

Jackie Baillie Lab The Convener · Dumbarton
link

I will bring the discussion to a close, not least because there will be an opportunity to raise the issue on 18 September. I take on board Irene Oldfather's point about asking the Executive for further information.Would anyone like to raise any other issues?Members indicated disagreement.

Jackie Baillie Lab The Convener · Dumbarton
link

In that case, I look forward to seeing members on 18 September. Representatives of the Scottish Executive will be in attendance, together with members of the European Parliament. The meeting will start at 10:30 am.

  1. Scottish Parliament European and External Relations Committee Tuesday 4 September 2007 Committee business · 1
  2. Work Programme Procedure · 25

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.