The second continued petition for consideration is PE1768, which was lodged by James A Mackie. The petition calls on the Scottish Government to ensure that all proceedings in children’s hearings be minuted or recorded.
We have received the Scottish Government’s response, which contains further information on the Children’s Hearings Improvement Partnership, including on why parents and children are not involved in it, as we requested. The Scottish Government has explained the background to the recording process for decisions, and it has highlighted the low number of appeals. It acknowledges that although there is no direct representation by children and families on CHIP, they are involved in the group’s work.
The petitioner’s response states that the Scottish Government’s response does not reflect the reality of experiences in the children’s hearings system, and it highlights the
“glaring gaps in procedures that could be amended now”.
He does not agree with the Scottish Government that there is sufficient input by families and children in CHIP and says that
“parents and families are demonized and ignored”.
He states that there are few appeals because the process is difficult and confusing and there is but little guidance on and difficulty in finding support from a solicitor.
In the evidence that we have been given, it has been explained to us quite clearly why children’s hearings are not minuted. I would like to hear members’ views on the petition, starting with David Torrance.
