I am particularly interested in the financial aspects of these schemes but, as Peter Reekie said, other things come in as well and I agree that they are very important.
It is welcome that the SFT has taken a fairly liberal approach towards making information on the financial aspects of the schemes available. It has a policy of publishing the financial model two years after the end of the construction period, and that is to be welcomed.
I published a paper through the Fraser of Allander institute that analysed the financial models for three hub schemes and drew some conclusions. One thing to note is that it is not easy to analyse the financial models. That leads to the thought: would it not be much better if, when the project was being tendered for, one of the criteria that were laid down was that certain standard indicators should be produced for each project as a matter of course? That would make it much easier for everybody involved—the SFT; outsiders, when they get their hands on the information; and the public sector client—to understand what was going on.
It is important that there is quite sophisticated information available. It is not just a question of the interest rate being charged on senior debt or earned on subordinate debt. It is also important that there is information available and analysed on the profile of payments through time.
That is where I started to have an argument with Peter Reekie a good long while ago, when he quoted to the committee the weighted average cost of capital, which is just a straight weighting together—90 per cent and 10 per cent, basically—of the costs of senior and subordinate debt. The point that I was making was that, given that the subordinated debt is being paid off much later than the senior debt, for a variety of reasons, the actual cost—the internal rate of return of finance—could be significantly larger than the weighted average cost of capital. That indeed turns out to be the case, as is confirmed in the work that I did and in the Audit Scotland report.
That difference in time profiles means that, potentially, the value of the holdings of subordinated debt to the equity holders, if they came to make a secondary market sale to realise a profit, could be quite large. To understand that, you really need to know what the net present value of the stream of projected payments on subordinated debt is, calculated at a discount rate that a pension company would be looking for if it came to purchase it.
You do not get an understanding of the potential profits that are made by the equity holders unless you have information on the net present value of that stream of payments calculated at an appropriate discount rate. You also do not really know about the opportunity cost to the public sector unless you know the net present value of the overall stream of payments that it is committing to make when it signs the contract, taking out the element that is for on-going maintenance and service and so on, discounted at the sort of interest rate that it will have been paying if it had gone down the national loans fund route.
It is very important that the public sector has an idea of the opportunity cost. One way of doing that is to discount the unitary charge apart from services at the NLF interest rate and potential profit to the private sector, which you get by discounting the subordinated debt payments at the sort of interest rate that a pension had been purchased at. Those are the sorts of indicators that should be being produced. There is no reason why they cannot be calculated from the financial model, although it can be difficult because all financial models are different. There is absolutely no reason why they should not be stipulated as a standard indicator that should be produced, and they should be produced as part of the documentation before the contract is signed. I think that it would be of value to the Scottish Futures Trust, because it would be able to look at those aspects much more easily than it can do at present, and it would be of value to the Scottish Government, obviously.
There is no reason why, after the two-year period of confidentiality is up, those indicators should not be published so that the public has the information. In the shorter term, I suggest that, if there are enough projects, it would be quite possible for the Scottish Futures Trust to aggregate those indicators and publish an average over a year or two years, so that we have an idea of what is going on currently in these projects. That is the sort of suggestion I am making: that there should be those mechanisms, and those indicators should be published.