Thank you for the opportunity to speak to the committee. I am mindful that this is the first time that I have appeared before the committee to speak about migration, and I am grateful for the opportunity to discuss matters.
My predecessor Alasdair Allan spoke to the committee about migration back in March 2017, and there have been significant policy developments over the past three years.
We are not perfect, but, in the main, Scotland is a welcoming and inclusive nation. We are a country that has been shaped by migration. In the past, that was predominantly by young people leaving Scotland to build a future elsewhere. We are shaped by their absence, while they have helped to shape other countries across the world.
I am pleased to state that the situation has changed. Scotland is now a nation of in-migration, with a growing population. Over the past 20 years, Scotland has experienced positive net migration—from the rest of the United Kingdom, the European Union and internationally—of around 20,000 people per annum. Yet, as a nation, we still face significant demographic pressures. All our future population growth is projected to come from migration.
First, that means that we need people who are here to stay. At the end of this year, freedom of movement will end. Our message to EU citizens has always been clear: this is your home, you are welcome here, and we want you to stay. However, I recognise that words alone are not enough. That is why we are committing more than £1 million to our stay in Scotland campaign. That work has been supporting and will support EU citizens during and beyond the transition period to continue living, working and studying in Scotland. I continue to encourage as many stakeholders as possible, including fellow MSPs, to promote the stay in Scotland campaign, and I reiterate that request today.
Secondly, Scotland has distinct migration needs, and we need a tailored approach to meeting those needs. The expert advisory group on migration and population has set out very detailed evidence about the impact of the UK Government’s proposed immigration policies on Scotland’s economy, population and communities. Its report, together with detailed evidence to the UK Government’s Migration Advisory Committee from the Scottish Government and employers across Scotland, demonstrates very clearly why Scotland requires a tailored approach.
After free movement ends, from January 2021, the UK Government intends to introduce a points-based immigration system, and the Scottish Government has a range of concerns about its current policy positions. In order to provide constructive and viable alternative solutions, the Scottish Government’s policy papers “Scotland’s population needs and migration policy: Discussion paper on evidence, policy and powers for the Scottish Parliament”, which was published in February 2018, and “Migration: Helping Scotland Prosper”, which was published in January 2020, set out clear, evidence-based proposals for a tailored approach to migration for Scotland, including the introduction of a Scottish visa.
The Scottish Parliament was established to enable the development of distinct solutions to distinct challenges. For example, the fresh talent programme, which was introduced in 2005, was an instance of a tailored approach to migration for Scotland that worked.
We need an immigration system that meets Scotland’s needs at all skill levels. Scotland, like many countries across the globe, is facing a falling birth rate, and we will be dependent on inward migration to support our economy and communities. It is in all our interests that Scotland is able to attract the people we need.
I have spent two years speaking to employers, local authorities, academics, trade unions, the private sector, the public sector, elected members, individual members of the public and various organisations about how we can develop proposals that meet the requirements for Scotland in the short, medium and longer terms. I welcome the opportunity to discuss the proposals and other matters with the committee.