The crux of the issue is this: how did we get to where we are now? The elimination strategy—zero Covid, as it is often called, or maximum suppression, which is probably a better term—is definitely what the Scottish Government has been trying to pursue. The data for June and July, in particular, and to a lesser extent for May, shows that, as a nation, we were very successful in getting the numbers down. We did well, or reasonably well, during the summer, but the problem is that the numbers are now up again. That was not unexpected; indeed, most of us expected it.
The main drivers for that were as follows. As the virus was not totally eliminated as it was in the Faroe Islands and New Zealand, it was always potentially going to spread again when people started moving around more, and that is exactly what has happened. Another point is that we cannot cut ourselves off, and travel has been a problem. It is clear that people coming back into the country have brought the virus with them—we have specific examples of that—and that quarantine rules are not being followed.
You raised two issues: test and protect, and quarantine. You asked whether I think that test and protect is working. From the data that I have seen, and from discussions with my colleagues who are involved in the system, I think that it is working very well, as much as it can do, but there are sometimes problems that are outwith the teams’ control.
The first part of test and protect is test, and that is currently where the problem is. The problem is not in the contact tracing—the teams are highly skilled, and they are doing that to the best of their ability. We will soon have the app, which will add to that. However, if we cannot get rapid testing, we really are in trouble. The situation that we have seen of people not being able to access tests is worrying. England is in the middle of that right now—there is clearly a problem with laboratory capacity.
The Scottish Government made a commitment to get up to 60,000 tests a day, but yesterday we did 19,000 tests, so we are nowhere near that figure. Testing is crucial. We need mass testing and more testing. The committee and others need to keep on communicating that message.
I know that it is not just Scotland—we are reliant on a UK system as well—but we really must improve our capacity and ability. We also need to move with technology. I am talking about a group-testing approach, where we put samples together and they are tested together to see whether there is no virus in 20 samples. Saliva testing, which is much less invasive and more tolerable for people, will also now be available. We need to use those methods.
I have spoken publicly about quarantine on several occasions. Last week, a good paper was published on a UK study in which only 25 per cent of people who were advised to self-isolate reported that they were doing so comprehensively. I can understand why it might be tough for someone to self-isolate, especially if they do not have enough resources. Incoming travellers are not necessarily following the guidance—we have seen examples of that—and the penalties and enforcement, as a follow-up, are pretty limited, although I cannot comment on that in detail.
Looking ahead, we will require airport testing. I know that the Scottish and UK Governments have been honest about the fact that there are key questions around the timing of the second test in particular. Would the test be done on day 5 or day 8? What proportion of cases would be missed under each of those approaches? I accept that there are genuine scientific questions on airport testing, but other countries are doing it.
The bigger reason why we do not yet have airport testing is to do with infrastructure. We do not have a system that is operating at scale in the community, so it is a big challenge to add a layer—a very complex new system—on top of that. However, I am relatively confident that we will have to embrace that in the future, because mandatory airport testing and repeat testing will minimise the risk of people not following what is essentially voluntary quarantine. I think that there are problems with that.
10:15