We now move to agenda item 2, which we skipped over earlier but which remains before us for consideration. It is on subordinate legislation, and is consideration of two negative instruments.
In July, Jeane Freeman, the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport, wrote to the committee and provided a series of updates on the digital response to Covid-19. That included working with the UK Government on the potential for an app to be developed by the UK Government and to be used throughout the UK. The instruments put in place the formal arrangements to allow that to happen by enabling an agreement to be reached between the Scottish Government and UK ministers on the operation of such an app within Scotland by UK ministers. They are not of course the agreement itself; they are simply the legislative framework to allow that to happen.
I note the letter and that the cabinet secretary has recently agreed in principle to such an approach. I am not against the SSIs, but I want to ask for clarification. We are told that
“The app is intended to further extend the speed and reach of contact tracing in England and, should Scottish Ministers so choose, within Scotland as part of NHS Test and Protect.”
There have been newspaper reports stating that people in England who have used the app have been asked for their bank details. I am concerned about that, so I would like some clarification on the issue, perhaps in a letter.
I believe that, in July, a question was asked of the First Minister with regard to Scotland having its own track and trace app, which would be similar to or the same as that in the Republic of Ireland. I also wonder where we are on that.
I seek clarification on those two points with regard to the SSIs.
Like Sandra White, I do not oppose the SSIs, but I am interested in the language around impact assessments. We are told:
“A full impact assessment has not been produced for this instrument as no, or no significant, impact on the private, voluntary or public sector is foreseen.”
Sandra White and Emma Harper have asked us to seek further information, but I think that they both said that they are happy to make no recommendations in relation to the instruments. Clearly, we can write to Jeane Freeman to seek clarification in any case. We could delay our consideration of the instruments pending a response, but I think that the members have indicated that they do not want to do that and are simply seeking information. I see that Emma Harper agrees.
Therefore, given the agreement to write a letter covering those points and the other comments from members, does the committee agree to make no recommendations on the instruments?
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.