Notwithstanding the situation that we have faced this year with Covid-19, labour supplies for seasonal horticulture are always a concern for our members. On average, we employ around 10,000 workers from outside the United Kingdom in a period that starts roughly in March, peaks through the summer months of June, July and August and slows down towards the end of the year. Labour supply has always been a challenge for our sector, and we have always maintained that there is a strong case for having a seasonal agricultural workers scheme.
This year, given the travel restrictions that are in place, we immediately foresaw significant issues arising with workers who had been contracted to come over to work. For that reason, early on—before the lockdown—we started a domestic labour-matching service to match individuals who might have found themselves out of work or on furlough, or who were around to give a helping hand, with farmers who were projecting a labour shortage.
Encouragingly, we were overwhelmed with interest in the scheme. That was fantastic—our website had tens of thousands of hits. Unfortunately, however, the final cut-through was fairly indicative of what we have known for a long time: it is difficult to keep folk from the domestic population in those jobs. For one reason or another, it just does not seem to stick. The success rate has been around 10 per cent. I do not want it to sound as though there have been no successful placements, because there have been some, but the scheme has not been taken up as widely as we would have liked.
For that reason, we have been working closely with growers’ groups to ensure that they can get assistance in chartering flights from countries where travel restrictions are not as strict. A few such flights have already arrived in Scotland, and the arrival process has involved some of the safest and most remarkable specifications that I have ever seen. We have workers coming into the country from within and outside the European Union, including workers who had previously been contracted through the seasonal agricultural workers scheme pilot that is currently in place.
At the moment, things are looking steady, but we are now heading into the peak production season. Luckily, it looks as though some countries are beginning to unlock their travel restrictions, and visa offices are reopening in some countries outside the EU, which will make the processing of work permits easier and faster. It is very much a case of keeping a watching brief.
There have obviously been huge challenges this year, but we have really valued the dialogue that we have had with the Scottish and UK Governments, and with the labour providers, to ensure that we have a steady stream of workers coming into the country.
In the longer term, our experience only underlines the major issue that we will come to next year, once free movement ends. This year has, if anything, been an opportune moment to underline the fact that the agricultural sector relies heavily on workers from outside the UK. We now need a strong steer from the UK Government on what it will do to put in place a more enduring seasonal workers scheme from 2021 onwards.